How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• GoodCook Everyday Muffin Pan — biggest strength: A heavy-gauge steel, warp-resistant 6-cup pan with a nonstick coating that releases cleanly whether or not you bother with liners, and it's dishwasher-safe.
• GoodCook Everyday Muffin Pan — biggest trade-off: It's one pan with six cups, so a big batch means baking in rounds, and it takes up real cabinet space.
• Miliocry Cupcake Liners — biggest strength: A 50-pack of food-grade, grease-proof paper cups rated for oven and air fryer use up to 420°F, so you can bake directly in them with no tray and no washing.
• Miliocry Cupcake Liners — biggest trade-off: They're disposable and single-use, and they're not meant to sit directly on a flame or burner.
• Who each pick is for: GoodCook for the home baker who wants one dependable pan for years; Miliocry for anyone doing air fryer muffins, parties, or bake-and-carry batches.
The GoodCook Everyday Muffin Pan is built around one idea: bake six muffins or cupcakes evenly, then get them out without a fight. The heavy-duty gauge steel is designed to resist warping, and the carbon steel construction spreads heat across the cups for thorough baking. That matters more than it sounds — a thin pan that twists in the heat gives you lopsided muffins with pale centers.
The nonstick coating is the detail I'd point a buyer to first. It's specified to release well with or without cupcake liners, which means you can go bare-metal for a crisper edge on a muffin, or line it if you're doing something sticky. It's also dishwasher-safe, so cleanup after a messy batch is a short job. The pan measures 14.5" wide by 8.5" deep by 6.8" high and holds six cups, and it carries a limited lifetime warranty from the manufacturer.
Who should buy it: the everyday home baker who wants one pan that lives in the cabinet and handles muffins, cupcakes and small tarts for years. Who should skip it: anyone feeding a crowd in a single go, or anyone who mainly bakes in an air fryer where a full-size six-cup pan may not fit the basket. Six cups also means two batches if you're making a couple dozen — a real consideration if you bake often.
Miliocry Cupcake Liners: Who It's For
The whole point is that you skip the tray. You set the cups straight into the oven or air fryer basket, bake, and serve — no greasing, no unmolding, no scrubbing a pan afterward. Because they're rigid enough to stand on their own and stack for storage, they double as a carry container: pack frosted cupcakes for a birthday, a picnic or a bake sale and you don't need a cake stand or a box. They're also positioned for gifting and packaging, not just baking.
Who should buy it: air fryer users, party hosts, parents sending treats to school, and anyone who wants disposable convenience over a permanent pan. Who should skip it: bakers who want a reusable pan they'll still own in five years, or anyone planning to bake over an open flame. And note the size — these are mini-style cups at 3.5 oz, so they suit smaller muffins and cupcakes rather than jumbo bakery-style ones.
• Best for air fryer muffins → Miliocry Cupcake Liners. They're explicitly rated air fryer safe up to 420°F and need no tray.
• Best for oven batch baking with even heat → GoodCook Everyday Muffin Pan. Heavy-gauge steel and even heat distribution are the core design here.
• Best for bake-and-carry → Miliocry Cupcake Liners. Rigid, stackable paper cups protect the dessert and travel without a box.
• Best for durability over time → GoodCook Everyday Muffin Pan. Warp-resistant steel plus a limited lifetime warranty points to a long service life.
• Best for zero cleanup → Miliocry Cupcake Liners. Disposable means no unmolding and no washing.
• Best for baking without liners → GoodCook Everyday Muffin Pan. The nonstick coating is specified to release with or without liners.
• Best for parties, weddings and holidays → Miliocry Cupcake Liners. A 50-count pack in colorful polka-dot paper fits exactly that use.
• Best for a single, repeatable muffin recipe → GoodCook Everyday Muffin Pan. Six cups, one pan, same result each time.
My Verdict
If I had to pick one, it depends on where you actually bake — so let me be concrete. For air fryer muffins, I'd buy the Miliocry Cupcake Liners, because the 420°F air fryer rating and the no-tray, no-wash workflow are exactly what that appliance rewards. For traditional oven baking where I want a pan I'll still be using years from now, I'd buy the GoodCook Everyday Muffin Pan — the warp-resistant steel and nonstick release are the specs that matter most in a muffin pan. Honestly, a lot of bakers will end up owning both: the pan for oven days, the liners for air fryer days and parties. If you're only buying one today and your kitchen leans air fryer, get the liners. If it leans oven, get the pan.
Use cups that are rated for the appliance — the Miliocry liners are oven and air fryer safe up to 420°F. Set the paper cups directly in the air fryer basket, fill them with batter, and bake; there's no tray needed and nothing to unmold afterward. Just keep them off any open flame or direct fire.
how to air fry english muffins
This is a different job from baking batter — you're reheating or toasting an already-made English muffin rather than baking in a cup. The specs here don't cover that, so treat the Miliocry liners as a baking cup for batter, not as a tool for toasting. For a baked muffin from batter, the liners' 420°F rating is the number that matters.
how long to air fry muffins
Timing depends on your air fryer, your batter and the cup size — the Miliocry cups hold about 3.5 oz each, which is a smaller muffin, so they'll bake faster than a standard tin. The data sheets don't give a bake time, so start checking early and rely on your own recipe as the guide rather than a fixed number.
No. The liners are designed to go straight into the oven or air fryer without a baking tray, which is the whole convenience of them. The GoodCook pan is the alternative route — a reusable six-cup pan that works with or without liners and goes in the dishwasher.
The GoodCook Everyday Muffin Pan is the durable option: warp-resistant heavy-gauge steel with a limited lifetime manufacturer warranty. The Miliocry liners are disposable paper cups — a 50-count pack meant to be used once and tossed. Different products, different lifespans by design.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Rtuopk Air Fryer vs HOTEC Air Fryer Liners: Air Fryer, AKOLAFE 8 vs RHQQ 11: Air Fryer Pizza Pan, ALJ 8PCS vs MMH Air Fryer Liners