How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-23 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• GCQFZ Air Fryer Replacement — biggest strength: a steel, nonstick, FDA-standard grill plate built specifically for Gourmia GAF536, GAF556 and GAF566 5QT baskets, with a whirlwind airflow design that spreads heat around food for even browning.
• GCQFZ Air Fryer Replacement — biggest trade-off: it only fits one family of 5QT Gourmia fryers at 8.8''×8.4'', so if your basket is a different brand or size, it won't drop in cleanly.
• GWBSXM Air Fryer Oven — biggest strength: 13.8"×12" fiberglass liners that take heat up to 480°F, block oil and stains, and can be trimmed to fit a wide range of ovens and trays.
• GWBSXM Air Fryer Oven — biggest trade-off: it's a protective mat, not a cooking surface. It won't give you grill marks, a raised rack or any airflow benefit.
• Pick GCQFZ Air Fryer Replacement if you own a compatible Gourmia 5QT fryer and want a replacement crisper plate for steak, wings, fish or vegetables.
• Pick GWBSXM Air Fryer Oven if you own a large air fryer oven or toaster oven and your priority is cutting cleanup time.
This is a replacement part first and a cooking upgrade second. The plate measures 8.8''×8.4'' and is designed for the Gourmia GAF566, GAF536 and GAF556 5QT air fryers. If your original crisper plate has lost its coating, warped, or vanished somewhere between the kitchen and the dishwasher, this is the direct swap. The steel body is food-grade, BPA-free and meets FDA standards, and the nonstick coating is there so steak and fish release without a fight.
Where it earns its place is versatility within its size. The manufacturer lists barbecue, steak, vegetables, fish, french fries, pizza and chicken wings as suitable foods, and that tracks with the ridged, perforated format — it's a general-purpose crisper plate, not a single-trick accessory. It ships with four rubber bumpers that keep the plate from rattling against the basket.
Who should skip it? Anyone who doesn't own one of those Gourmia models. The listing is explicit: measure your basket's inner diameter before ordering. There's also a care caveat worth respecting — no abrasive cloths or metal scouring balls, because they'll strip the nonstick layer. And don't clean it while it's still scorching hot. Treat it like any coated pan and it should hold up.
GWBSXM Air Fryer Oven: Who It's For
This is a completely different kind of purchase. The GWBSXM liners are 13.8"×12" mats made from BPA-free, PFOA-free fiberglass, and their job is to sit at the bottom of your air fryer oven and catch everything that drips. Four come in the pack. They're rated to 480°F (the listing cites both 250°C and 248°C across sections, so treat 480°F as the number that matters), which covers high-heat roasting and baking sessions comfortably.
The fit story is the selling point. They're listed as compatible with Ninja, Cuisinart, Breville and Emeril Lagasse, and specifically sized for the Emeril Lagasse Dual Zone 360 25QT extra-large oven. More usefully, they're trimmable — you can cut them down to match any tray, toaster oven or baking sheet you own. That flexibility is why these make sense for a household with more than one oven-style appliance.
Cleanup is the whole point. Oil and food stains stay on the liner instead of baking onto the appliance floor, and a rinse handles most of it. Stubborn residue can be scrubbed, and the liners are dishwasher-safe. If you've ever spent ten minutes chiseling carbonized grease off the bottom of an air fryer oven, you understand the value immediately.
The honest limitation: these don't cook anything. There's no rack, no perforation pattern, no airflow design. They're a barrier. If you place food directly on them, you're effectively baking on a flat mat, and you lose the circulating-air benefit that makes an air fryer an air fryer. Used correctly — under a basket, under a rack, or on the oven floor — they do their job well. Used as a cooking surface, they're the wrong tool.
Who should skip it? Anyone with a small basket-style air fryer like the Gourmia 5QT above. A 13.8"×12" liner is far too large for that footprint, and trimming it down to fit defeats the purpose when the basket already has its own plate.
• Best for cooking steak with real browning → GCQFZ Air Fryer Replacement. The ridged, perforated steel plate and whirlwind airflow are built for exactly this.
• Best for large air fryer ovens → GWBSXM Air Fryer Oven. Sized for 25QT-class ovens and trimmable to smaller trays.
• Best for protecting the appliance → GWBSXM Air Fryer Oven. Oil and stain resistance is its entire reason to exist.
• Best for a replacement part → GCQFZ Air Fryer Replacement. It's a drop-in swap for a specific, named set of Gourmia models.
• Best for cleanup convenience → GWBSXM Air Fryer Oven. Rinse, scrub if needed, dishwasher. No coating to baby.
• Best for heat tolerance → GWBSXM Air Fryer Oven. Rated to 480°F, which matters for high-heat roasting.
• Best for food release → GCQFZ Air Fryer Replacement. The nonstick coating is designed so food lifts off cleanly.
• Best for multi-appliance kitchens → GWBSXM Air Fryer Oven. One pack, trimmed to fit several trays and ovens.
If you're asking me which one I'd buy, the answer depends entirely on which appliance is sitting on your counter, and I won't pretend otherwise. For a Gourmia GAF536, GAF556 or GAF566 5QT owner who actually wants to cook steak — not just reheat — I'd take the GCQFZ Air Fryer Replacement. It's a real cooking surface with airflow built in, and it's the one that changes what comes out of the basket. For an Emeril Lagasse 25QT or similar oven owner whose pain point is scrubbing grease, I'd take the GWBSXM Air Fryer Oven without hesitation. Two different problems, two different answers. Check the current price on Amazon once you've confirmed which camp you're in.
FAQ
how to air fryer steak
how to air fryer steak medium rare
Medium rare means pulling the steak while the center is still soft to the touch and letting carryover heat finish the job. Because the GCQFZ plate's whirlwind airflow heats food evenly from multiple directions, the window between medium rare and medium is narrow — start checking early. A thicker cut gives you more margin for error.
how to air fryer steak well done
Well done needs a longer cook and a lower risk of a leathery exterior. The nonstick coating on the GCQFZ plate helps here, since a stuck crust tears away and dries out the meat. Flip more often than you would for medium rare to keep both sides from over-browning.
how to air fryer steak bites
Cut the steak into even cubes so they finish at the same time, toss with oil and seasoning, and spread them in a single layer on the GCQFZ plate. Crowding is the enemy — the whirlwind airflow only works if air can move around each piece. Shake the plate once or twice so every side gets exposed.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: GWY Air Fryer Basket vs GCQFZ Toaster Oven Replacement, GWBSXM 10 vs GXCSY Air fryer Replacement: Air Fryer OR Oven, GCQFZ Toaster Oven Replacement vs Hulezt Stainless Steel Air