We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a compact, dishwasher-safe pan built specifically for Breville Compact and Mini Smart Ovens, choose GWBSXM 10; if you need a larger multi-piece basket-and-tray set sized for the Ninja Flip SP151 and similar air fryer ovens, choose GXCSY Air fryer Replacement. Both are replacement accessories rather than standalone appliances, so the real question — air fryer or oven, which is better — comes down to which cooking machine you already own, and how big a batch you cook.
• GWBSXM 10 — biggest strength: food-grade steel pan sized at roughly 10.6" × 10.4" × 1.18", designed for Breville Compact Smart Oven and Mini Smart Oven, dishwasher safe, with a mesh basket that sits above the tray for 360° heat circulation.
• GWBSXM 10 — biggest trade-off: it needs a preheat step before first use (300°F for 10 minutes) or the steel can deform, and it will not fit larger ovens or Ninja Flip models.
• GXCSY Air fryer Replacement — biggest strength: a four-piece set for the Ninja Flip Toaster Oven & Air Fryer SP151 — basket, grill pan, crumb tray and wire rack — at 13.4" × 10.6" × 1.3", stainless steel with a nonstick coating.
• GXCSY Air fryer Replacement — biggest trade-off: it is the bigger, heavier option, and fit is unforgiving — you must measure your appliance's inner dimensions before ordering.
• Who each is for: GWBSXM 10 for Breville Compact/Mini Smart Oven owners who want one simple pan; GXCSY for Ninja Flip SP151 owners (or similar 13.4" × 10.6" cavities) who want a complete air-fry kit.
The GWBSXM 10 is a single baking pan, and it is honest about what it is. The steel body is rated to 480°F, it is BPA-free and non-toxic, and it meets FDA standards per the product data. The mesh basket design sits above the tray so heat wraps around the food instead of only hitting it from one side — that is the same 360° circulation idea that makes air frying work, just applied inside a toaster oven. You should not have to flip chicken wings or fries halfway through, which is the whole appeal of this style of cooking.
Buy it if you own a Breville Compact Smart Oven or Mini Smart Oven and want one sturdy pan for wings, fries, vegetables, pizza, steak or a small batch of cookies. Skip it if you own a Ninja Flip SP151 or any oven with a cavity much bigger than 10.6" — the pan simply will not seat properly, and a loose pan in a hot oven is a bad time.
GXCSY Air fryer Replacement: Who It's For
The GXCSY set is the more complete package, and it is built around a specific machine: the Ninja Flip Toaster Oven & Air Fryer SP151. The dimensions are 13.4" long, 10.6" wide and 1.3" high, and the set ships with four pieces — an air fryer basket, a grill pan, a crumb tray and a wire rack. That combination is what separates it from a bare pan. You get the mesh basket for crisping, the solid pan underneath for drips, the crumb tray for cleanup, and the rack for straight baking or grilling.
The mesh basket uses the same 360° circulation logic as the GWBSXM 10: heat moves around the food rather than just over it, so you do not have to flip halfway. The data also notes you can use it as a grill basket for fruit, vegetables, tableware and cups, which is a nice bit of flexibility for parties or holiday gifting. Materials match the other set — food-grade steel, nonstick coating, BPA-free, meets FDA standards, dishwasher safe, and the same warning against abrasive scrubbers.
The trade-off is size and fit. At 4.44 pounds for the set, it is noticeably heavier than the single pan, and the manufacturer is blunt: measure the inside diameter of your appliance before ordering. If it does not fit, the set is wasted money. Buy it if you own a Ninja Flip SP151 or an air fryer oven with a cavity that matches those dimensions and you want the full kit — including the crumb tray that keeps cleanup sane. Skip it if you are working with a small Breville Compact or Mini, where the 13.4" length is simply too much pan.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for Breville Compact or Mini Smart Oven owners → GWBSXM 10. It is designed for exactly those models.
• Best for Ninja Flip SP151 owners → GXCSY Air fryer Replacement. It is built for that appliance, and the four-piece set covers more cooking modes.
• Best for larger batches → GXCSY. At 13.4" × 10.6", it holds more than the roughly 10.6" × 10.4" GWBSXM pan.
• Best for minimal setup → GWBSXM 10. One pan, one preheat, done — versus measuring and fitting four pieces.
• Best for cleanup convenience → GXCSY. The included crumb tray and drip pan catch the mess before it reaches your oven floor.
• Best for lower weight → GWBSXM 10. At 0.16 kg, it is far lighter than the 4.44-pound GXCSY set.
• Best for a single-purpose, low-fuss replacement → GWBSXM 10. If you just want a pan that crisps wings and fries, you do not need four pieces.
In my opinion, the right pick is decided entirely by which oven sits on your counter — not by which accessory is "better." If you own a Breville Compact or Mini Smart Oven, I would buy the GWBSXM 10; it fits, it is light, it crisps well, and the one-time preheat is a minor hassle. If you own a Ninja Flip SP151, I would buy the GXCSY Air fryer Replacement, because the basket, grill pan, crumb tray and wire rack turn one appliance into a genuinely versatile air fryer oven. Measure first, then buy the one that matches your machine. Check the current price on Amazon before you commit.
what's better air fryer or oven
Neither is universally better — it depends on the machine and the accessory. An air fryer oven like the Ninja Flip SP151 uses a mesh basket for 360° circulation, which is why it crisps food without flipping and with less oil. A traditional oven with a pan like the GWBSXM 10 can do similar work if the pan is designed for circulation, as this one is. For small, crispy batches, the air fryer setup usually wins; for larger or slower baking, the oven wins.
what makes an air fryer better than an oven
Air circulation. Both the GWBSXM 10 and the GXCSY basket use a mesh design that surrounds food with moving heat, so you get a crispy exterior and a tender interior without flipping halfway. That is the core advantage — faster crisping and less oil than a standard flat baking sheet, which only heats from one direction.
It is not automatically better — it is better for specific jobs. Air frying shines for wings, fries, vegetables and anything you want crispy, which is exactly what both accessories are built for. A regular oven is better for large batches, cakes and slow bakes. The GXCSY set actually covers both, since it includes a wire rack and grill pan alongside the air fry basket.
Do I need to preheat these accessories before first use?
For the GWBSXM 10, yes — the manufacturer specifies preheating at 300°F for 10 minutes to prevent the steel from deforming or bending. The GXCSY set does not list a required preheat step, but you should always measure your appliance's inner dimensions before ordering, since fit is the main reason either accessory fails.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: HQT Air Fryer Replacement vs LIEMAND 2: Air Fryer Grill Pan, GWYXC Air Fryer Replacement vs TRINENOX Air Fryer Dust, CHEFMADE Baking vs CuwrYet Oven Mitts Mini: Air Fryer Donuts