Wes Culwell
Franklin Ferguson
Brian Hay
Darren O’Hare
Robb MacArthur
Dan Wells
Michael Godinez
Jason Tiner
Brian Austin
Paul
Jim
Chris
Episode 1 - Boy Meets Boys and Overexuberant Host - Fifteen suitors try to attract the attention of single gay man. (Jul 29, 2003)
Episode 2 - Where Have All The Possibly Straight Cowboys Gone? - Group dates begin for James and his suitors. (Aug 5, 2003)
Episode 3 - It's Raining Gay and Secretly Straight Men - James narrows the group to six. (Aug 12, 2003)
Episode 4 - Yeah, But Do You LIKE Me? - The group narrows to three. (Aug 19, 2003)
Episode 5 - The Possibly Straight Cat's Out Of The Bag - James tries to figure out which one of the remaining suitors is straight. (Aug 26, 2003)
Episode 6 - Finale - James and Andra hold one last strategy session; Brian, Franklin and Wes await the elimination ceremony; James makes his final choice. (Sep 2, 2003)