How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• Fox Run Muffin Pan — biggest strength: Durable carbon steel with a premium non-stick coating and six half-cup wells, so heat spreads evenly and baked goods brown consistently.
• Fox Run Muffin Pan — biggest trade-off: It's a fixed six-cup metal pan, so you can't reshape it or use it as a disposable liner, and it needs washing after every bake.
• BESPORTBLE Silicone Resistant Baking — biggest strength: A flexible roll of paper that acts as an oil-absorbing, non-stick liner, protects your air fryer basket, and works as food wrapping too.
• BESPORTBLE Silicone Resistant Baking — biggest trade-off: It's a paper roll rather than a pan, so it gives structure to nothing and can't hold batter or shape a bake on its own.
• Who each pick is for: Go Fox Run if you actually want to bake muffins or need a firm mold; go BESPORTBLE if your priority is mess-free air fryer cooking and quick clean-up.
The Fox Run Muffin Pan is a straightforward baking tool done the traditional way. It measures 10.5 x 7.5 x 1.25 inches and holds six wells at a half-cup capacity each — roughly a small-batch pan rather than a full dozen. The body is carbon steel, and the brand pairs it with what it calls an exclusive premium non-stick coating. In practice, that combination is exactly what you want in a muffin tin: carbon steel is a strong heat conductor, so the metal carries warmth up the sides of each well instead of leaving cold spots, and the non-stick surface means muffins release with less wrestling.
The six-cup layout is the real personality of this pan. It suits anyone who bakes for one or two people, who wants to test a recipe without committing to twelve muffins, or who prefers to bake in small rounds so nothing goes stale. If you're doing air fryer English muffin projects, a metal pan like this gives you something paper never can: a rigid, heat-tolerant mold. You can portion batter, set filled wells into a larger air fryer basket, or use the pan as a stable resting structure while you assemble and toast English muffin halves and English muffin pizzas. It won't flex, it won't tear, and it won't blow around when the air fryer fan kicks on.
Who should skip it? Anyone who wants a disposable, wipe-and-toss liner. This pan has to be washed, dried and stored, and it takes up real drawer or cabinet space. It also won't line a basket, absorb oil, or wrap a sandwich. If your goal is zero clean-up rather than actual baking, this is the wrong tool — full stop. In my opinion it's the pick for people who genuinely bake, not for people who just want less scrubbing.
BESPORTBLE Silicone Resistant Baking: Who It's For
That makes it a natural fit for air fryer owners. You cut or tear a sheet to fit your basket, drop it in, and cook. The paper catches drips, absorbs oil, and keeps the basket from gumming up, which is the single most annoying part of air fryer ownership. The brand also notes it's safe and tasteless, that it won't affect the taste of your food, and that it's not easy to tear. It doubles as food wrapping paper, so you can use it to present or hold sandwiches, baked goods and snacks.
Where it falls short is structural. This is a paper roll — one sheet count, one unit — so it holds no batter, forms no cups and gives no shape. It's also not a reusable item; once a sheet has done its job, it's done. And because it's flexible, a loose sheet in a fast air fryer basket needs to be weighted down with food, or it can shift. So who should buy it? Anyone who air fries often, hates scrubbing a basket, and wants a cheap, low-effort barrier between food and metal. Who should skip it? Anyone expecting a pan, a mold or something that will hold a muffin's shape. It is a liner, and a good one, but only a liner.
• Best for actually baking muffins → Fox Run Muffin Pan. Six half-cup carbon steel wells are built for batter; a paper sheet is not.
• Best for air fryer English muffin projects → BESPORTBLE Silicone Resistant Baking. A liner keeps the basket clean while you toast or assemble; the rigid pan helps hold and shape portions.
• Best for even browning → Fox Run Muffin Pan. Carbon steel and the non-stick coating are designed for even heat distribution and consistent browning.
• Best for zero-scrub clean-up → BESPORTBLE Silicone Resistant Baking. The oil-absorbing paper takes the mess and gets thrown away.
• Best for reusability → Fox Run Muffin Pan. It's a one-time purchase you wash and reuse; the paper roll is consumed sheet by sheet.
• Best for wrapping and presenting food → BESPORTBLE Silicone Resistant Baking. It doubles as food wrapping paper with a decorative brown English design.
• Best for small households → Fox Run Muffin Pan. Six cups is a deliberately small batch, ideal for one or two people.
• Best for a fast, low-commitment cooking habit → BESPORTBLE Silicone Resistant Baking. Tear, line, cook, toss — no washing, no storage footprint.
My Verdict
If I had to pick one, I'd buy the Fox Run Muffin Pan. It's the more capable tool: carbon steel, six half-cup wells, even heat and a non-stick surface mean it can do a job paper simply cannot — hold batter and turn it into a properly browned muffin, and give me a rigid mold for air fryer English muffin work. The trade-off is washing and storage, and I'm fine with that.
Split the English muffin, place the halves cut-side up in the air fryer basket, and cook until the surface crisps and the edges toast. If you're using the BESPORTBLE liner, put a sheet under the muffin halves so crumbs and butter don't stick to the basket, and weigh the paper down with the muffins themselves. A rigid Fox Run pan is useful for holding and transferring portions, but the actual crisping happens in the basket.
Toast the split muffin halves first so the base firms up, then top with sauce, cheese and any toppings and return them to the basket cut-side up. Line the basket with BESPORTBLE parchment to catch melted cheese and grease — that's exactly the oil-absorbing, non-stick job the paper is designed for. Keep toppings light so the muffin doesn't go soggy, and use a pan only as a resting or assembly surface.
Split and lightly toast the muffins, spread a thin layer of sauce, add cheese and toppings, then air fry until the cheese melts and bubbles. The BESPORTBLE paper liner is the practical helper here: it keeps the basket clean and stops cheese from welding itself to the metal. The Fox Run Muffin Pan isn't a pizza pan, but its six wells are handy for holding toppings or portions while you work.
Timing depends on your air fryer and how loaded the muffins are, so go by appearance rather than a fixed number: cook until the cheese is fully melted and the muffin edges are crisp, checking every couple of minutes. Because the BESPORTBLE liner is thin paper, it heats through quickly and won't slow the cook, but never use it without food on top to hold it down. Start conservative and add time in short bursts.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: OSOLADY Stainless Steel Air vs DONFAMDS Cuttable Silicone Baking, oecue 10 vs CURTA 8: Air Fryer Baking Pan, Wildone Baking Sheet vs INFRAOVENS Air Fryer Silicone