How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
For air fryer cookies specifically, the split is even cleaner. Air fryer baskets are small and awkward, so you rarely need a full sheet-pan liner — you need something that fits the basket, releases cookies cleanly, and doesn't curl up into the heating element. Fogmhu's modular mats handle that shape problem beautifully. MakMeFre's sheets handle the volume problem: bake after bake, tray after tray, no washing in between. Let's break down which one actually belongs in your kitchen.
• Fogmhu's biggest strength: A modular puzzle design — four 8.3" x 5.5" mats snap together into a full 16.5" x 11" oven liner, so you can cover a half sheet pan or a small air fryer basket with the same set. Reusable, dishwasher-safe, rated from -40°F to 500°F.
• Fogmhu's biggest trade-off: You have to clean it. Every bake means a rinse or a dishwasher cycle, and silicone can hold onto oils and odors if you don't stay on top of it.
• MakMeFre's biggest strength: 200 pre-cut 12" x 16" unbleached sheets with a food-grade silicone coating on both sides, rated to 450°F. Zero cleanup — lift the sheet, toss it, done.
• MakMeFre's biggest trade-off: It's disposable by design. You're buying a consumable, and the sheets are a fixed size, so you can't reshape them for a small air fryer basket without trimming.
• Who each pick is for: Fogmhu for the frequent baker who wants one purchase that lasts and adapts to different trays. MakMeFre for the high-volume baker or anyone who hates doing dishes after cookies.
Fogmhu's whole pitch is flexibility, and for air fryer cookies that's genuinely the point. You get eight mats in the box, each 8.3" x 5.5", plus two storage bands. Snap four together and you've got a 16.5" x 11" surface — the standard half sheet pan footprint. Snap two together and you've got a strip that drops neatly into a small air fryer basket. That modularity is the feature you'll actually notice, because air fryer interiors vary wildly and a rigid one-piece mat would fight you.
The material is fiberglass core with a silicone surface, in a burgundy color, and it's rated for -40°F to 500°F. That range matters: it means the same mat goes from freezer prep to oven to microwave without you thinking about it. The silicone surface is naturally non-stick, so you don't need butter or spray, which is exactly what you want when you're dropping cookie dough into a hot air fryer and don't want to grease a basket with holes in it. And because there's no loose sheet, there's nothing to flutter up against the heating coil.
Buy Fogmhu if you bake often, you want a liner that fits both a half sheet pan and an air fryer basket, and you'd rather own one thing than restock a pantry item. Skip it if you know you'll never wash it, or if you want a perfectly flat, full-size liner with no seams — snapped-together mats have joint lines where food can catch.
MakMeFre Parchment Paper Baking: Who It's For
MakMeFre takes the opposite approach and does it well. You get 200 pre-cut sheets, each 12" x 16", which is the standard half sheet pan size. They're made from natural wood pulp, unbleached, with a food-grade silicone coating on both sides, and they're rated up to 450°F. The shape is rectangular and the count is 200 — that's the entire value proposition, and it's a good one.
For air fryer cookies, the sheets are a slightly different tool. A 12" x 16" sheet is bigger than most air fryer baskets, so you'd trim it down or fold it. That's fine — parchment trims easily with scissors — but it's worth knowing before you buy. What you get in return is speed. Lay a sheet, bake, lift the sheet with the cookies on it, throw it away, lay the next sheet. No washing, no drying, no storage debate. If you're doing batch after batch of cookie dough on a Sunday, that flow is hard to beat.
The unbleached, double-sided silicone coating also means no oil needed and no sticking, whether you're doing cookies, cakes, bread, pizza, or using the sheets to separate candies so they don't fuse together. MakMeFre also lists them for grilling, frying, and steaming, plus air fryers and oven-bottom lining. That's a wider stated use range than most people expect from parchment.
Buy MakMeFre if you bake in volume, you want zero cleanup, or you like having a sheet ready to grab without thinking. Skip it if you want to stop buying a consumable, or if you need a liner that conforms to a small or oddly shaped air fryer basket — the fixed 12" x 16" size means trimming every time.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for high-volume baking days → MakMeFre Parchment Paper Baking. 200 sheets means you never stop to wash between trays.
• Best for zero cleanup → MakMeFre Parchment Paper Baking. Disposable by design — lift and toss.
• Best for long-term value → Fogmhu Silicone Baking Mats. Reusable and dishwasher-safe, so the cost per bake drops the more you use it. Check the current price on Amazon to see how that math works for you.
• Best heat ceiling → Fogmhu Silicone Baking Mats. Rated from -40°F to 500°F versus 450°F for MakMeFre.
• Best for freezer-to-oven workflow → Fogmhu Silicone Baking Mats. The -40°F rating means it goes straight from freezer prep to the oven.
• Best for gift packaging and food separation → MakMeFre Parchment Paper Baking. The sheets double as separators for candies and small gifts.
• Best for tiny kitchens → Fogmhu Silicone Baking Mats. The set rolls or stacks and weighs about 9.6 ounces total.
In my opinion, if your main goal is air fryer cookies, buy the Fogmhu Silicone Baking Mats. The modular design solves the actual problem — air fryer baskets are small and irregular, and a mat you can snap to the right size beats a 12" x 16" sheet you have to trim every single time. The 500°F rating and the -40°F to 500°F working range give you more headroom than parchment's 450°F, and you buy it once instead of restocking.
That said, I'd genuinely recommend the MakMeFre Parchment Paper Baking if you're a volume baker who values the no-wash workflow more than reusability. Different priorities, different winner. If you're torn entirely on cost, check the current price on Amazon for both and compare against how often you actually bake.
FAQ
how to air fryer cookies
how to air fry cookies pillsbury
Refrigerated dough portions go straight onto a non-stick liner without greasing — Fogmhu's silicone surface and MakMeFre's double-sided silicone coating both release cleanly. Space them apart, since they spread as they bake. Check them early the first time, because air fryers run hotter and faster than a full oven.
how to air fry cookies dough
Scoop or slice the dough, place it on your liner with room to spread, and bake in batches rather than crowding the basket. A modular Fogmhu mat lets you fit the basket precisely; a trimmed MakMeFre sheet gives you the fastest cleanup. Neither needs oil or spray.
how to air fry cookies from frozen
Frozen dough goes onto the liner straight from the freezer — no thawing needed. This is where Fogmhu's -40°F rating is handy, since the same mat handles freezer storage and the bake. Add a couple of minutes versus fresh dough and check for a set center before pulling them out.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: CHAOOOQD Parchment Paper Baking vs UBeesize 75: Air Fryer, SIUDANGKA Disposable Parchment Paper vs TCSNOE 125PCS, Ailun 100PCS vs KITMAL Silicone Baking Mat: Air Fryer Spring