Senior Pastors
1885 Marvin D. Jump
1886 – 88 Homer Eaton
1889 – 91 Henry A. Starks
1892 – 94 Thomas G. Thompson
1895 – 97 Henry S. Rowe
1898 – 1900 Charles L. Hall
1901 – 04 George W. Brown
1909 – 17 Charles V. Grismer
1917 – 22 John A. Hamilton
1922 – 28 Mark Kelley
1928 – 33 Harvey F. Connor
1933 – 50 David Reid
1950 – 60 Hobart Goewey
1960 69 - Paul V. Hydon
1969 – 75 Orrin Ireson
1975 – 78 Stanley Moore
1978 – 86 Willian Vigne
1986 – 89 Jim Perry
1989 - Marcheta Townsend
1989 – 2001 Clark Callendar
2001 – 10 Richard Hibbert
2010 – 20 Mark Demers
2020 - Kerry Cameron
Associate Pastors
Chester Simmons
1961 – 1963 Donald Howard
1963 – 1967 Leonard Bass
1967 – 1971 Charlene Saunders
1971 – 1973 Charles Kellerman
1973 - 1975 Robert Kanuck
1975 – 1978 William Barney
1980 – 1983 James Osborne
1983 – 1989 Marcheta Townsend
1989 Don Van Dreser
1989 – 1994 James Bowen
1994 – 1998 Mari Clark
1998 – 2002 David Murphy
2002 – 2006 Dee Anne Lowman
2014 – 2017 Rae Freeman
Pastors of the Second Methodist Episcopal Church (Pine Street)
1855 - Lorenzo Marshall
1856 - William Brown
1858 – 59 David McKenzie
1860 - James Edgerton
1861 - Charles H. Richmond
1862 - Volney M. Simons
1863 - William R. Puffer
1864 - McKendres Petty
1865 - Alanson L. Cooper