How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• FENMORE's biggest strength: 3 reusable, 100% BPA-free food-grade silicone mats in red, blue, and black that handle up to 430°F and go in the dishwasher.
• FENMORE's biggest trade-off: It's only 3 liners at 8 inches round, so you'll be washing them regularly, and they're built for round baskets roughly that size.
• ailifeer's biggest strength: 150 disposable 6.3-inch liners that need no cutting, wrapping, or cleanup — pull one out, cook, and throw it away.
• ailifeer's biggest trade-off: It's single-use paper with a 428°F ceiling and a warning against leaving it in during preheat or using too little food, so it demands a bit of care.
• Who FENMORE is for: People who cook in their air fryer constantly and want to stop buying liners.
• Who ailifeer is for: People who hate cleanup, cook in small batches, and want the easiest possible path from basket to trash.
FENMORE's set is built around one idea: protect the air fryer basket's non-stick coating so food releases easily and cleanup stays quick. Each mat is a round 8-inch (200mm) silicone disc with a perforated pattern, and that perforation matters more than it looks. Air fryers work by moving hot air around the food, so a liner that blocks airflow turns crispy food soggy. The holes are there precisely so the liner doesn't interfere with circulation. In my opinion, that's the single most important design detail on any silicone liner, and FENMORE got it right.
The material is 100% BPA-free food-grade silicone rated to 430°F (220°C), which covers air frying, steaming, pressure cooking, and oven baking. That range puts it above what most air fryer recipes call for. The mats are also non-stick, dishwasher safe, and hand-washable, and you get three of them in three colors — red, blue, and black — which makes rotation easy. Cook, wash, repeat. The three-pack means you can run one in the basket, one drying, and one ready to go.
Who should buy it: anyone who air fries several times a week, wants to cut down on disposable paper, and owns a round-basket fryer in the 8-inch neighborhood — the description names Ninja, Instant Pot Duo, Power XL, and Foodi as compatible examples. Who should skip it: people who want zero washing up, or who own a small 2–3 quart fryer where an 8-inch mat would be oversized. If you'd rather never touch a sponge, this isn't the product for you.
Ailifeer takes the opposite approach. This is a 150-count box of round, unbleached parchment-style liners, each 6.3 inches across at the base with a 1.77-inch (4.5cm) high wavy edge. That raised rim is the practical star here — it's designed to stop oil and food from splashing up the sides of the basket, which keeps the fryer cleaner and, by extension, means less scrubbing between uses.
The material is food-grade silicone-coated oil paper: waterproof, oil-proof, non-stick, and heat resistant up to 428°F. There's no tearing, cutting, or wrapping involved. You take one liner out, drop your food on it, and cook. When you're done, you throw it away. Because there are 150 of them, an occasional messy batch costs you one sheet and no cleanup time at all. The 6.3-inch base is sized for 2Qt to 5Qt fryers, with COSORI, Cuisinart, Chefman, Nuwave, Philips, and Ninja listed as fits.
The trade-offs are real, though, and they're spelled out in the product's own notes. Never put a liner in alone during preheating — put food in first, then bake. And don't underfill the basket, because a light paper liner can get blown up onto the heating element. Follow those two rules and it behaves well. Who should buy it: small-batch cooks, people feeding one or two, anyone who wants disposable convenience for parties, camping, or baking days. Who should skip it: heavy daily cooks who'd burn through 150 sheets fast, and anyone whose fryer basket is larger than 5 quarts.
• Best for zero cleanup → ailifeer 150PCS. Nothing to wash, ever. Toss the liner and you're done.
• Best for long-term value → FENMORE Air Fryer Liners. Silicone is reusable, so 3 mats replace a continuous stream of paper.
• Best for small 2–5 quart fryers → ailifeer 150PCS. Its 6.3-inch base is sized specifically for that range.
• Best for 8-inch round baskets → FENMORE Air Fryer Liners. The 200mm diameter matches that footprint.
• Best for high-heat cooking → FENMORE Air Fryer Liners. 430°F versus 428°F, and silicone tolerates longer exposure without the paper-specific warnings.
• Best for airflow and even crisping → FENMORE Air Fryer Liners. The perforated design is made to let hot air through.
• Best for parties, camping, and baking days → ailifeer 150PCS. A big stack of disposables is exactly what a crowd cook needs.
• Best if you hate washing dishes → ailifeer 150PCS. That's its entire reason to exist.
I'd buy FENMORE Air Fryer Liners. Here's my reasoning: I cook in an air fryer most days, and a reusable silicone mat that survives 430°F, goes in the dishwasher, and comes in a rotating three-pack solves the problem permanently instead of restocking it. The perforated design also tells me FENMORE thought about airflow, which is where cheap liners fail. I'd only switch to ailifeer if I owned a smaller 2–5 quart fryer or genuinely wanted to throw cleanup away with the liner. For most round-basket owners, FENMORE is the one I'd keep in the drawer.
how to use air fryer silicone liners
Set the FENMORE mat flat in the bottom of the basket, then place your food on top of it. The perforations let hot air circulate so food still crisps. When you're done, wash it by hand or in the dishwasher and rotate in the next one.
how to clean air fryer silicone liner
Because the mats are non-stick, warm soapy water and a soft sponge handle most residue, and they're dishwasher safe for heavier jobs. The 3-pack is designed so you can keep one in use while another dries. Avoid abrasive scrubbers that could dull the surface over time.
how to clean air fryer silicone liner with baking soda
A paste of baking soda and a little water works as a gentle scrub for stuck-on grease on silicone. Apply it, let it sit briefly, then rinse and wash normally. It's a handy method for the FENMORE mats since they're reusable and see repeated use.
how to use air fryer silicone liners ninja
For Ninja round-basket models, lay the 8-inch FENMORE mat flat on the basket floor before adding food — the description lists Ninja among compatible brands. If you're using the disposable ailifeer liners on a smaller Ninja, put food in first and never preheat with the paper alone.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: SHINYMOMO Air Fryer Liners vs Wellsworth 40GSM: Air Fryer, INFRAOVENS Parchment Paper Sheets vs Tonmom Air Fryer Liners, Generic 1000 vs LYHOLKEER Loaf Pan Liners: Air Fryer Banana