How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• SHINYMOMO Air Fryer Liners — biggest strength: 100 pre-cut round liners with a 1.8" raised edge, so you get side-wall protection and easy lift-out without folding, cutting or bending.
• SHINYMOMO Air Fryer Liners — biggest trade-off: the 6.3" round footprint only suits smaller baskets, and the heat ceiling is 428°F versus the Wellsworth's 450°F.
• Wellsworth 40GSM — biggest strength: 125 square 8" sheets rated to 450°F, sized for 5–8 qt baskets and compatible with Ninja, Cosori, Philips and Instant Pot models.
• Wellsworth 40GSM — biggest trade-off: square sheets in a round basket mean you must weigh the paper down with food or it can curl, and you have to measure your basket to get the fit right.
• Who each pick is for: SHINYMOMO for small-basket owners who bake cakes and want zero fuss; Wellsworth for large-basket owners who cook bigger batches and want the higher heat rating.
SHINYMOMO's liners are built around one idea: you should never have to scrub a basket again. Each sheet is made from natural wood pulp with a silicone oil coating, which is what gives it the oil-proof, non-stick and heat-resistant behaviour. They're rated up to 428°F (220°C), which covers the vast majority of cake, muffin and quick-bread recipes you'd run in an air fryer. The material is unbleached and food grade, and because the coating does the releasing work, you're not relying on a heavy layer of grease to stop your bake from welding itself to the paper.
The detail I like most is the shape. These are 6.3" (16cm) round with a 1.8" (4.5cm) raised edge, pre-cut on each side so the liner lifts out cleanly without spilling. That edge matters for cake specifically — batter is liquid before it sets, and a flat sheet gives it nowhere to go. A lipped round liner holds the batter in place while it rises and keeps the basket walls clean at the same time. No tearing, folding, cutting or bending: you drop it in and pour.
Wellsworth 40GSM: Who It's For
Wellsworth takes the opposite approach: bigger, hotter, more. These are 8" square sheets, 125 to a pack, made from unbleached natural parchment paper with a silicone coating that's BPA-free and fluorescent-free. The headline number is the heat rating — up to 450°F — which is meaningfully above the SHINYMOMO's 428°F ceiling if you like to push roasting temperatures or do a high-heat finish on a bake. The "40GSM" in the name refers to the paper's grammage, and that weight is why these sheets hold their shape better than flimsier parchment.
The sizing is the other half of the story. 8" square is aimed at round 5–8 qt baskets, with compatibility called out for Ninja, Cosori, Philips and Instant Pot models. Square paper in a round basket is a deliberate trade: you get more usable surface and better coverage of the corners where food tends to sit, but you have to manage the fit. Wellsworth's own guidance is honest about this — never preheat with the liner in and no food on top, because an unweighted sheet can lift and touch the heating element. Distribute food evenly, or weight the edges with something heat-resistant like a small stainless steel fork.
For cake, that's the practical caveat. A square sheet under a round cake tin works fine; a square sheet holding loose batter on its own does not, because there's no raised lip. These liners are at their best under roasting vegetables, chicken, fish, fries and reheated leftovers, and as a base layer under a pan. If you want the no-scrub benefit at scale, and you own a big basket, Wellsworth is the more natural match. One more thing worth knowing: Wellsworth notes that grease pools under the paper by design — the liner is trapping it so your basket stays clean.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for air fryer cake batter → SHINYMOMO Air Fryer Liners — the 1.8" raised edge contains liquid batter that a flat square sheet can't.
• Best for large 5–8 qt baskets → Wellsworth 40GSM — 8" square sheets are sized for that range; the SHINYMOMO's 6.3" round is not.
• Best heat tolerance → Wellsworth 40GSM — 450°F versus 428°F on the SHINYMOMO.
• Best for no-measuring, no-fiddling setup → SHINYMOMO Air Fryer Liners — pre-cut round with a lip, no folding or weighting required.
• Most versatile across appliances → SHINYMOMO Air Fryer Liners — the sheets are also listed for microwave, oven, skillet, steamer and cooker use.
• Best for roasting and reheating in a big basket → Wellsworth 40GSM — square coverage plus the higher temperature rating suits savoury cooking.
• Best for small-basket bakers → SHINYMOMO Air Fryer Liners — round shape and side-wall protection are built for baking small cakes.
For air fryer cake — the thing most people searching this comparison actually want to do — I'd buy the SHINYMOMO Air Fryer Liners. In my opinion, the raised 1.8" edge is the deciding feature: cake batter needs a wall, and a pre-cut round liner that lifts out without spilling solves the exact problem that makes people avoid baking in an air fryer. If your basket is 5–8 qt, or you mainly roast rather than bake, I'd take the Wellsworth 40GSM instead for the bigger square sheets and the 450°F ceiling. Whichever you pick, measure your basket first, and check the current price on Amazon before you commit.
how to make air fryer cake
Line your basket with a liner that has a raised edge so the batter can't run, pour the batter in, and keep the temperature within your liner's rating — 428°F for the SHINYMOMO, 450°F for the Wellsworth. Never preheat with a liner in and nothing on top, since an unweighted sheet can lift toward the heating element.
how to air fryer cake mix
Mix the batter as normal, then pour it into a lined basket rather than straight onto the grate. A round liner with a lip (SHINYMOMO's 6.3" round, 1.8" edge) is the simpler option for loose batter; a square Wellsworth sheet is better used under a pan than as the only thing holding the mix.
how to air fryer cake
The short answer is line, pour, bake, lift. A disposable liner means the basket itself stays clean, and both options here are food grade with a silicone coating — the SHINYMOMO is unbleached wood pulp, the Wellsworth is unbleached parchment that's BPA-free and fluorescent-free.
how to clean air fryer caked on grease
The whole point of these liners is that you throw them away instead of scrubbing. Wellsworth does note that grease pools under the paper by design — that's the liner holding it so your basket stays clean. If residue still bakes on, clean the basket without a liner in place, and only add a new liner when you're ready to cook.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: rhsaae Air Fryer Silicone vs Wellsworth 40GSM: Air Fryer, RedLemon Air Fryer Paper vs SHINYMOMO Air Fryer Liners, POPQEEN Air Fryer Liners vs onluckdeer 300