First Person Stories from Enslaved People


Dear Xenokles and mother,

I'm nearly dying in the foundry! Please do something about it. Come to my masters and find something better for me here(?). I've been handed over to an absolutely dreadful man. I'm getting thrashed within an inch of my life; I'm tied up; I'm being treated like dirt - it's getting worse and worse.

Yours, Lesis.

A long piece of thing lead with faint Greek writing inscribed on it. The top and bottom edges are ragged and there is some ripping of the letter near the right edge.

IL 1702, Ephorate of Antiquities of Athens City, Ancient Agora, ASCSA: Agora Excavations. © Hellenic Ministry of Culture and Sports/Hellenic Organization of Cultural Resources Development (H.O.C.RE.D.). Translated by Harvey (2007). 

Description

This lead letter (23 x 5 cm) dates to 4th century BCE Athens and was excavated in 1972 from a well in the Athenian Agora. It was written by an enslaved boy named Lesis, who describes in brief terms the suffering he faces as an apprentice at a foundry. Lead was a very accessible material for writing and was used frequently in Athens, although Lesis may have paid a scribe to write the letter. The letter is on one side of the tablet, which would have been the inside when it was rolled up. There are faint marks on the outside, but due to corrosion and wear it is unclear whether these may have been other letters. The letter was probably written with a reed stylus and the lead sheet would have been cut with shears, causing the visible crinkled edges. The writing is neat and the spelling is good.

A close up of the Greek writing on the letter. 

Ephorate of Antiquities of Athens City, Ancient Agora, ASCSA: Agora Excavations. © Hellenic Ministry of Culture and Sports/Hellenic Organization of Cultural Resources Development (H.O.C.RE.D.)

Context

While the initial scholar who published this tablet assumed that Lesis was a free metic (resident foreigner, non-citizen), the language of the tablet suggests that he was instead enslaved. The term used for "masters" (despotes), is only ever used for enslavers in surviving Greek texts. If Lesis is enslaved, then his mother (likely also enslaved) and Xenokles would not be able to do anything to protect him, so it was initially assumed that there would have been no point in sending this letter. However, it speaks to the desperation that comes from experiencing such violence, as Lesis may have been making an emotional plea for recognition of his suffering or for any possible help, rather than a request for realistic legal aid.

This letter reflects the normalization of violence against enslaved people in Classical Athens. However, it can also be read as a small act of agency that an enslaved person could exercise in the face of that violence. While this letter may not have changed his status, Lesis still used the resources available to him to attempt to speak out against the terrible treatment that he faced. This also reminds us that the normalization of such violence was not actually all-encompassing; Lesis was certainly capable of recognizing the unnecessary brutality of his situation. 

Reading between the lines, this letter also provides a complicated view of relationship networks for enslaved people. On one hand, there are elements of Orlando Patterson's concept of natal alienation, or the removal of enslaved people from societally recognized family and cultural structures. Lesis is clearly separated from his immediate family as he must send a letter to his mother to alert her of his experience. If Lesis was born to an enslaved mother, her enslaver could have easily sold him off to his current "masters" without any input from her. Lesis is also a non-Athenian name, which is a reminder of the forced separation of enslaved people from their communities, both in moving them to Greece and by purposefully separating them from other enslaved people of similar origin (Pl. Laws 6.777c-d). However, the letter also shows how enslaved people can maintain those natal ties and create their own networks. While Lesis' mother may not have had any legal authority over her child, she was still clearly an important figure in his life. Traces of foreign homelands in names and epitaphs show that enslaved people may have still identified with their lost homes, despite enforced physical distance. 

An example of an Athenian epitaph, although this one is for a free citizen Athenian. The cost of marble and skilled inscribers is one issue that complicates the reading of supposed first-person statements on epitaphs for enslaved individuals.

© 1980 Musée du Louvre / Maurice et Pierre Chuzeville

Comparison to Other First-Person Sources

The unique value of this letter is as an unmediated first-person account from an enslaved person. Most information about slavery comes from the enslavers, who treat violence against enslaved people as necessary (Dem. 30 37), motivational (Xen. Oec. 21.10), or even comedic (Aristoph. Frogs 605-674). Accounts by enslaved people are exceedingly rare, with the most common source being funerary epitaphs (such as the epitaph translated below, which reflects similar issues of natal alienation). However, the financial barrier for epitaphs and the context of an enslaver’s authority over enslaved people, even in death, makes it difficult to tell whose words are on the inscription: the enslaved person or their enslaver. On the other hand, this letter almost certainly represents Lesis’ own words, and it describes his suffering with a simplicity and frankness that highlights the violence that formed the basis of Athenian society.

A Funerary Epitaph

IG II2 10051 (trans. Braund)

Ἀτώτας μεταλλεύς.

Πόντου ἀπ’ Εὐεξείνου Παφλαγὼν μεγάθυμος Ἀτώτας

ἧς γαίας τηλοῦ σῶμ’ ἀνέπαυσε πόνων.

τέχνηι δ’ οὔτις ἔριζε· Πυλαιμένεος δ’ ἀπὸ ῥίζης

εἴμ’, ὃς Ἀχιλλῆος χειρὶ δαμεὶς ἔθανεν.




From Pontus Euxinus, Paphlagonian great-hearted Atotas, In a land from which, my body rested from toils.
In skill no-one supplanted me, from the family-tree of Pylaemenes am I, who, mastered by the hand of Achilles, met his death.

Further Reading

Braund, D. 2011. "The Slave Supply in Classical Greece." In The Cambridge World History of Slavery, edited by K. Bradley and P. Cartledge, 112-133. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Harris, E. M. 2004. "Notes on a Lead Letter from the Athenian Agora." HSCP 102:157-170.

Harvey, F. G. 2007. "'Help! I'm Dying Here': A Letter from a Slave." ZPE 163:49-50.

Hunt, P. 2016. "Slaves as Active Subjects: Individual Strategies." In The Oxford Handbook of Greek and Roman Slaveries, edited by S. Hodkinson, M. Kleijwegt, and K. Vlassopoulos. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Jordan, D. R. 2000. "A Personal Letter Found in the Athenian Agora." Hesperia 69:91-103.

Patterson, O. 1982. Slavery and Social Death: A Comparative Study. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.