How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• Eco Cooking Supplies — biggest strength: you get two 6.5" square liners in one set, sized for 5Qt and larger air fryers and rated heat resistant to 480°F.
• Eco Cooking Supplies — biggest trade-off: no handles and no built-in drainage channels, so lifting a hot liner out of the basket takes care, and grease pools on a flat surface instead of running off.
• EffloToyz — biggest strength: two heat-resistant handles plus an embossed bottom with dedicated oil grooves, so you can lift the liner out safely and let excess fat drain away from the food.
• EffloToyz — biggest trade-off: it is a single 8.3" square liner aimed at 3.5–5 quart baskets, so it is the wrong shape for a big 6-quart-and-up fryer, and there is no second liner in the box.
• Pick Eco Cooking Supplies if you own a 5Qt or larger air fryer, want a spare liner ready while the first one is in the dishwasher, and cook for more than one or two people.
• Pick EffloToyz if you own a compact or mid-size air fryer, want handles for safer removal, and care about draining grease off as the food cooks.
This is a two-pack of 6.5" square silicone liners from Eco Cooking Supplies, each rated for temperatures up to 480°F. The headline feature is coverage: because you get two liners in the set, one can be in the dishwasher while the other is in the basket. That matters more than it sounds. Silicone liners are the kind of accessory you only appreciate when you have a clean one on hand at 6pm on a Tuesday, and a single-liner setup forces you to hand-wash mid-week or cook without one.
The fit is deliberately broad — the liners are designed for most 5Qt and larger air fryers, and the brand lists compatibility with Cosori, Ninja, Breville and similar machines. If your air fryer is a big family-sized unit, this is the shape that actually fills the basket rather than sliding around inside it. The material is BPA-free food-grade silicone, dishwasher safe, and non-stick, so food releases without scraping.
What it does best is the boring stuff done well: baking, steaming and air frying on the same reusable surface, no parchment paper to buy, no oil needed to stop sticking, and cleanup that is mostly a rinse or a dishwasher cycle. The brand also points out that the liner's design promotes air circulation, which is the honest reason food still crisps on a silicone mat instead of steaming in its own moisture.
EffloToyz Silicone Air Fryer: Who It's For
EffloToyz takes the opposite approach: one liner, but a more considered one. It is an 8.3" square reusable basket liner sized for 3.5–5 quart air fryers, and the two features that separate it from a plain silicone mat are the handles and the bottom geometry. Two heat-resistant handles let you lift the liner straight out of the basket without tongs or oven gloves — the brand frames this as a safety feature, and it genuinely is one if you have kids or older family members hovering around the kitchen while you cook.
The second feature is the 3D oil drainage. The bottom is embossed with dedicated grooves, so fat renders off the food and collects underneath rather than sitting in a puddle around it. Combined with the raised edges — which act as a splatter guard and keep the basket walls cleaner — this is the liner for anyone who cooks breaded chicken, bacon, sausages or anything that gives off a lot of grease and wants a crispier, less oily result.
It also comes in two colorways, Classic Black-Gray and Vibrant Red, which is a small thing but a real one if your kitchen has a look and you would rather not hide a bright red liner in a drawer. The food-grade silicone handles high and low temperatures, it is reusable, and when you are done it folds flat for compact storage — a genuine advantage in a small kitchen with limited drawer space, and something a rigid, larger set cannot offer.
Who should buy it: owners of compact and mid-size air fryers, anyone who wants safer removal with handles, and cooks who care about draining grease mid-cook. Who should skip it: owners of 6-quart and larger air fryers, since the 8.3" square footprint is aimed at 3.5–5 quart baskets; and anyone who wants a second liner as a rotation spare, because this is a single-liner product.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for large air fryers (5Qt and up) → Eco Cooking Supplies Silicone Air Fryer. Its 6.5" square liners are built for that basket class.
• Best for getting two liners at once → Eco Cooking Supplies Silicone Air Fryer. It ships as a 2-pack, so you always have a clean one ready.
• Best for safe handling of a hot liner → EffloToyz Silicone Air Fryer. The two heat-resistant handles are the whole point.
• Best for greasy foods like wings, bacon and breaded chicken → EffloToyz Silicone Air Fryer. The embossed bottom and oil grooves drain fat away instead of letting it pool.
• Best for high-heat recipes → Eco Cooking Supplies Silicone Air Fryer. It is rated heat resistant to 480°F.
• Best for splatter control and keeping the basket clean → EffloToyz Silicone Air Fryer. Raised edges catch mess before it hits the basket walls.
• Best for small kitchens and tight storage → EffloToyz Silicone Air Fryer. It folds flat when you are finished with it.
• Best for dishwasher-first cleanup → Eco Cooking Supplies Silicone Air Fryer. Both liners are dishwasher safe, and with two of them you are never stuck hand-washing.
If I were buying for a 5-quart-or-larger air fryer, I would buy the Eco Cooking Supplies Silicone Air Fryer. In my opinion the 2-pack is the deciding factor — two dishwasher-safe liners rated to 480°F means one is always clean, and the fit is aimed squarely at the big baskets most households actually own. I would only switch to the EffloToyz Silicone Air Fryer if my air fryer were in the 3.5–5 quart range, or if handles and grease drainage were things I cared about more than having a spare. Check the current price on Amazon before you commit, since that is the one variable this comparison cannot settle for you.
FAQ
how to clean air fryer silicone liner
Rinse it under warm water with a little dish soap and wipe it with a soft sponge — the non-stick food-grade silicone on both of these liners releases food easily. Both products are dishwasher safe, so on a busy night you can just load the liner into the top rack. Skip abrasive scrubbers and harsh chemicals, since they dull the non-stick surface over time.
Set the liner flat in the air fryer basket, add your food in a single layer, and cook as you normally would. The raised edges on the EffloToyz liner keep splatter off the basket walls, and its embossed bottom with oil grooves lets fat drain away from the food. For the Eco Cooking Supplies liners, the design promotes air circulation so food still crisps rather than steaming.
how to use air fryer silicone liners ninja
Both liners are made for broad compatibility across major brands, and Ninja is named for both the Eco Cooking Supplies set and the EffloToyz liner. The thing that matters is basket size, not brand: the Eco Cooking Supplies liners suit 5Qt and larger air fryers, while the EffloToyz liner is sized for 3.5–5 quart baskets. Match the liner to your basket size and it drops straight in.
how to clean air fryer silicone liner with baking soda
Make a paste from baking soda and a little water, rub it into any stubborn or greasy spots, let it sit for a few minutes, then rinse and wash as usual. It is a gentle option that will not scratch food-grade silicone, and it works well on the EffloToyz liner's oil grooves where grease tends to collect. Follow with a normal soap wash or a dishwasher cycle to finish.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Weber ® Charcoal Cooking vs Uniflasy G460-0500-W1: Air Fryer, WMKGG Silicone Air Fryer vs mutvle Rectangle Air Fryer, PRETYZOOM Reusable Air Fryer vs Elnwnnkc Silicone Air Fryers