PJ vulnerability

Project description: 

Using species distribution models with multi-agency data to estimate future landscape suitability for pinyon-juniper and map trends in priority management areas

Background

Pinyon-juniper ecosystems cover a large portion of western North America, providing arid tree habitat across 3,500 km from Canada to Mexico. Future climate change is likely to alter PJ woodland composition, in addition to prior widespread mortality events, which may threaten the integrity of our irreplaceable national park lands and millions of acres of old-growth and mature forest type. Simultaneously, PJ species interact and conflict with adjacent biome types, further complicating effective management that balances habitat needs across western North America. 

Land and park managers across the Colorado Plateau could greatly benefit from projections of long-term suitability of PJ species, but existing studies lack either the west-wide geographic scope or use only one or a few future climate models, limiting the amount of confidence managers can place on results under uncertain climate change. 

Objectives & Approach

In this project, we fit species distribution models (SDMs) for nine PJ species and project how landscape suitability under current climate conditions will change under a variety of future climate scenarios. SDMs are a fairly common approach to support conservation decision making, and our goal was to maximize applicability of our models by assembling a set of dryland-focused predictor variables, using models types that facilitate ecological interpretation, and quantifying robustness in our projections of PJ suitability. 

For each PJ species, we compare driving climatic and soil variables and map suitability change for four future emissions-time period scenarios. We contrast the amount of area that projected to gain or lose suitability, and summarize range-wide trends in suitability shifts and shrinks.

Outcomes

PJ species’ suitabilities respond to many temperature and precipitation covariates expected to change in the future. Some species, such as J. osteosperma and J. californica, are projected to experience modest decreases in suitable areas that are balanced by increases elsewhere, indicating ability to shift distribution in the future. Others, such as J. monosperma and J. scopulorum, are projected to shrink in response to widespread suitability declines that are not compensated by newly suitable area. Highly managed species, such as P. edulis, P. monophylla, J. osteosperma and J. occidentalis, all vary in where and how much land area is projected to gain suitability to enable distribution shifts under future climate.

We found that species were projected to experience more losses than gains in suitability, for overall range shrinks rather than shifts. Land managers have the capacity to increase woodland resilience to drought, and our results can inform range-wide management planning and conservation efforts in PJ woodlands.

Collaborators

Brad Butterfield - Northern Arizona University, Department of Biological Sciences and Center for Environmental Research

Megan Swan, Jodi Norris - National Park Service, South Colorado Plateau Inventory & Monitoring Network

Kim Hartwig - National Park Service

Support 

USGS Climate Adaptation Science Centers   

National Park Service