How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-25 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• DNSSY — biggest strength: 125 disposable rectangular paper liners in one pack, each bowl-shaped with a 1.7" raised edge, so you toss the mess instead of scrubbing the basket.
• DNSSY — biggest trade-off: It's a single-use paper product with strict use rules — keep it under 446°F, never preheat on an empty liner, and keep cooking time under 45 minutes.
• LYHOLKEER — biggest strength: Two reusable, thicker-than-average silicone liners with front-and-back perforations for airflow and dual handles to protect your hands.
• LYHOLKEER — biggest trade-off: It's reusable, so you do have to wash it (dishwasher-safe, but still a step), and it may carry a slight odor that needs a boiling-water soak before first use.
• Who DNSSY is for: Anyone with a dual-basket Ninja who hates cleanup and wants a fresh liner every cook.
• Who LYHOLKEER is for: Anyone with a Ninja DoubleStack XL (SL401/SL400/SL451) or another 10QT dual fryer who wants one purchase that keeps working.
DNSSY solves one problem really well: grease and food residue touching your air fryer basket. The liners are rectangular — 8.7" long by 5.5" wide — and shaped like a shallow bowl with a 1.7" depth. That raised edge is the part I like most, because it catches crumbs and oil that would otherwise bleed onto the sides and bottom of the basket. When you're done, the liner goes in the trash and the basket stays clean. The heightened rim also makes it easier to lift food out, which matters when you're dealing with something saucy or fragile.
So who should buy it? If you cook in a dual-basket Ninja several times a week and the cleanup is what stops you from using it, this is the low-effort answer. It's also genuinely handy for camping, BBQs and party cooking, where you don't want to be washing anything. Who should skip it? If you're uncomfortable with single-use paper, or if you like to preheat your air fryer empty, or you run long cooks past 45 minutes, this isn't the right tool. The rules aren't optional — no preheating without food, keep at least two-thirds of the liner covered, and stay under the temperature and time limits.
LYHOLKEER Silicone Air Fryer: Who It's For
LYHOLKEER goes the opposite direction: instead of throwing something away, you buy two silicone liners and reuse them. These are designed specifically around the Ninja DoubleStack XL (SL401, SL400, SL451) and also fit dual models like the DZ302, DZ401 and DZ550, plus other 10QT dual-basket fryers. The shape is rectangular, the colorway is grey and black, and there are two in the pack.
The design detail that actually matters here is the perforation. There are holes at the front and back to let hot air circulate around and under the food, which is the whole point of an air fryer. A solid liner can block airflow and leave you with uneven results; this one is built to avoid that. LYHOLKEER also states these are thicker and taller than competing silicone liners, with dual handles so you can pull them out without burning your fingers. Heat resistance is rated up to 450°F, and the silicone is food-grade, oil-proof and resistant to deforming or tearing — so it should hold up over repeated use.
Cleanup is the trade-off: these are dishwasher safe, which softens the chore, but you're still handling and washing them rather than binning them. One honest note from the listing itself — the liners may have a slight odor out of the box, and LYHOLKEER recommends cleaning and soaking them in boiling water before the first use. That's normal for silicone, but worth knowing so it doesn't surprise you.
Buy this if you want one purchase, less waste, and you're fine with a quick wash. Skip it if you want zero cleanup, or if you own a smaller or single-basket fryer that isn't a 10QT dual model — the fit is specific.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for less waste over time → LYHOLKEER Silicone Air Fryer. Two reusable liners instead of 125 disposable ones.
• Best for Ninja DoubleStack XL (SL401/SL400/SL451) → LYHOLKEER. It's designed specifically for that line.
• Best for a broad list of 8–10QT dual fryers → DNSSY. The compatibility list covers Ninja, Instant Vortex Plus XL, PowerXL, Chefman and more.
• Best for airflow around food → LYHOLKEER. The front-and-back perforations are there for circulation.
• Best for long or hot cooks → LYHOLKEER. It's rated to 450°F with no stated time limit; DNSSY caps at 446°F and 45 minutes.
• Best for camping, BBQs and parties → DNSSY. Toss and go, no washing station needed.
• Best for handling hot liners safely → LYHOLKEER. The dual handles are built for pulling a hot liner out.
• Best if you preheat empty → LYHOLKEER. DNSSY explicitly warns against preheating without food on the paper.
In my opinion, most people should pick LYHOLKEER Silicone Air Fryer. Two reusable liners that fit the DoubleStack XL and other 10QT dual fryers, with perforations for real airflow and handles for safe lifting, is the more practical long-term choice — one purchase, less trash, and no time limits to remember. I'd only steer you to DNSSY if cleanup is the single thing keeping you from using your air fryer, or if you're cooking away from a sink at a campsite or party. If price is your deciding factor, check the current price on Amazon for both before you commit.
FAQ
No. They're disposable parchment-style paper liners meant to be thrown away after cooking. That's the appeal — the mess goes in the bin with them.
No — the listing is explicit. Keep the temperature under 446°F/232°C and heating time under 45 minutes, never preheat with an empty liner, and always cover at least two-thirds of the liner with food.
LYHOLKEER notes a slight odor is normal and recommends cleaning and soaking the liners in boiling water before first use. After that, they're dishwasher safe for routine cleaning.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: MMH Air Fryer Silicone vs Bergner 125-Count, Septe 2Pcs vs Ami.Todfo Reusable Silicone Cupcake: Air Fryer, AMYONE 11x11 vs LYHOLKEER 2Pack: Air Fryer Cheese