Critical thinking (and applied critical thinking or adaptive thinking) [in the Data Detectives Game] is measured by assessment. More specifically, the assessment of the successful/unsuccessful application of the needed critical thinking skill set to case study presented in the Data Detectives Game can be accomplished in a variety of ways (see below, with the preferred method of assessment in bold text).
Students demonstrate their mastery of the application of the needed critical thinking skill set to the Data Detectives Game case study by the submission of a written essay.
Students demonstrate their mastery of the application of the needed critical thinking skill set to the Data Detectives Game case study by their [graded] contributions to a class/group discussion (and the class/group discussion can be staged in the virtual world, online in a threaded text discussion in a learning management system platform, or face-to-face in a classroom setting).
Students demonstrate their mastery of the application of the needed critical thinking skill set to the Data Detectives Game case study by their answers to a [graded] test. Note: If a [graded] test is used to access students/trainees, given the need to evaluate the thought process behind the conclusions drawn, an essay or short answer test format is preferred. A self-grading multiple choice test format can be utilized in the assessment process but is the less preferred method of testing (in comparison to the option of an essay or short answer test).
Students demonstrate their mastery of the application of the needed critical thinking skill set to the Data Detectives Game case study by the combination of their [graded] contributions to a class/group discussion and their answers to a [graded] essay or short answer essay test.
Rubric scoring: Unacceptable = 0-25 points; Marginal = 26-50 points; Proficient = 51-75 points; and Exemplary = 75-100 points.
[See "Deconstructing the Clues" analysis -- beyond the examples detailed below -- in pages 28-38 of Data Detectives Instructor Manual.]