How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-23 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• Cooks Innovations — biggest strength: a trimmable 23" x 16.5" PTFE non-stick mat that catches spills before they bake onto your oven floor, and it's dishwasher safe.
• Cooks Innovations — biggest trade-off: it's a flat sheet, not a structural part. It won't replace a broken rack or add airflow. You cut it yourself, so a sloppy trim is on you.
• GWBSXM — biggest strength: food-grade stainless steel wire rack sized specifically for Cuisinart TOA-60/65/70 ovens, with a heavy-duty build meant for 360° heat circulation so food browns without flipping.
• GWBSXM — biggest trade-off: it only fits those three Cuisinart models. If you own anything else, it's the wrong part. Its dimensions are fixed, so there's nothing to adjust.
• Buy Cooks Innovations if you already have a working oven or air fryer and you're tired of scrubbing the floor of it.
• Buy GWBSXM if your Cuisinart's rack is lost, bent or rusted and you need the oven working again.
This is a maintenance product, not a cooking appliance. You trim the 23" x 16.5" sheet down to fit your oven, lay it on a rack near the bottom, and it does one job: catching whatever falls off your pies, casseroles, pizza and roasts before it carbonizes onto the oven floor. The material is PTFE non-stick, it's declared free of PVC and PFOA, and it ships as a single liner in a copper color. That's it. No moving parts, nothing to plug in, no learning curve.
The real argument for it is the cleanup math. An oven floor that's been splattered on for months is one of the worst cleaning jobs in a kitchen — you're reaching into a hot box with a scraper. This mat intercepts that mess and then goes in the dishwasher, or wipes clean by hand. It's also described as thinner and lighter than comparable liners, which matters more than it sounds: a flimsy mat is easier to pull out, rinse and slide back in without wrestling it. You can also conform it to fit around gas oven grates rather than fighting a rigid sheet.
Who should buy it: anyone with a working oven or air fryer who cooks messy things regularly and wants to stop scrubbing. Renters who don't want to damage an oven they don't own. People who bake a lot of pizza and casseroles. Who should skip it: anyone expecting it to fix a broken rack, change how food cooks, or fit a cavity smaller than 23" x 16.5" without trimming. And if your oven is already spotless because you clean it weekly, this solves a problem you don't have.
This is a replacement part, and it's honest about that. The rack is built for the Cuisinart TOA-60, TOA-65 and TOA-70 air fryer convection toaster ovens specifically — the listing says plainly it isn't suitable for other models. So the first question isn't "is this good," it's "do I own one of those three ovens." Measure your cavity before ordering; the rack's maximum footprint is 12.4" long, 11" wide and 0.78" tall.
If you do own one of those ovens, the case is straightforward. It's food-grade stainless steel, BPA-free, and the heavy-duty wire design is intended to let heat circulate 360° around the food so it cooks evenly and crisps without burning — the manufacturer's pitch is that you don't need to flip anything, just set temperature and time. In practice that's the whole appeal of a wire rack over a solid tray: hot air moves underneath instead of trapping steam. Smooth handles make it easier to lift out of the basket, and it's dishwasher safe. The listing does warn against scrubbing it with abrasive cloths or metal balls, which is standard advice for keeping stainless looking decent.
Who should buy it: Cuisinart TOA-60/65/70 owners whose original rack is missing, warped, rusted or was never replaced after a move. Anyone who wants to cook chicken wings, bacon, fish, meatballs, vegetables or potatoes on a rack rather than a flat pan. It also doubles as a general baking or grill-style rack for fruit, vegetables and even holding tableware or cups. Who should skip it: everyone else. If your oven isn't one of those three models, this part will not fit, no matter how good the steel is. And if your existing rack is fine, there's nothing here you need.
• Best for protecting your oven from spills → Cooks Innovations. That's literally what it's designed for, and the non-stick surface plus dishwasher-safe cleanup is the whole point.
• Best for restoring a Cuisinart TOA-60/65/70 → GWBSXM. It's the direct-fit replacement rack, sized 12.4" x 11" x 0.78" for those ovens.
• Best for airflow and even crisping → GWBSXM. A wire rack lets heat circulate around food; a flat liner does not.
• Best for messy baking (pies, casseroles, pizza) → Cooks Innovations. It catches drips before they burn onto the floor of the oven.
• Best for fit flexibility → Cooks Innovations. You trim the 23" x 16.5" sheet to your oven or air fryer, so it adapts. GWBSXM is a fixed size for a fixed set of models.
• Best for durability under heat and weight → GWBSXM. Stainless steel with a heavy-duty build, meant to hold food and be handled repeatedly.
• Best if you're unsure what you need → neither, yet. Measure your appliance first. One product is a mat, the other is a structural part, and they solve unrelated problems.
• Best pairing → both, if you own a Cuisinart TOA-60/65/70. The rack does the cooking; the liner catches what falls through it.
In my opinion, the right pick depends entirely on what's broken in your kitchen, not on which product is "better." If your oven works and the chore you hate is scrubbing the bottom of it, I'd buy the Cooks Innovations liner — it's a cheap, low-commitment fix for a genuinely annoying job, and the trim-to-fit design means it works in more places. If you own a Cuisinart TOA-60, TOA-65 or TOA-70 and your rack is gone or damaged, I'd buy the GWBSXM rack, because no amount of liner will cook your food. Between the two, I'd lean Cooks Innovations for the broader audience — it helps more people — but that's a verdict about usefulness, not about which one your oven needs. Check the current price on Amazon before you commit, and confirm your model number first.
If scrubbing baked-on spills off your oven floor is a job you avoid, yes — in my opinion it earns its place. It's non-stick PTFE, trims to fit most ovens and air fryers, and cleans in the dishwasher. Just don't expect it to replace a rack or change how food cooks.
Only if you own a Cuisinart TOA-60, TOA-65 or TOA-70. The rack measures 12.4" long, 11" wide and 0.78" tall, and the manufacturer states it isn't suitable for other models. Measure your oven's interior before ordering.
An oven liner is a non-stick mat that sits on a rack to catch drips and splatters. A replacement rack is the structural wire shelf your food actually rests on, and it's what allows air to circulate for even crisping. They do completely different jobs and aren't interchangeable.
Yes, and that's the sensible setup if you own a compatible Cuisinart. Put the GWBSXM wire rack in place and set the Cooks Innovations liner on a rack below it to catch drips. You get airflow for cooking and protection for the oven floor.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: GCQFZ Air Fryer Replacement vs GWBSXM Air Fryer Oven, GWBSXM 10 vs GXCSY Air fryer Replacement: Air Fryer OR Oven, mutvle Air Fryer Disposable vs ANQIA Non-Stick Round Disposable