Game Development Scorecard

This is how Game Designs are evaluated.

Scoring

1- Project Structure: (Total: 3)

Evaluate the project Structure practices employed during development. Assess factors such as task organization, scheduling, resource allocation, and the ability to meet deadlines.

• Folder Organization (1)

• Clean Code Structure (1)

• Prefab Management (1)

2- Code Quality:  (Total: 3)

Assess the quality of the game's underlying code. Evaluate factors such as readability, maintainability, efficiency, and adherence to coding standards. Review the use of appropriate data structures and algorithms.

• Code Style and Practices (1)

  • 0 = Code does not follow the best practices.

  • 0.5 = Follow best practices with some issues or spelling mistakes or confusing naming conventions.

  • 1 = Clean code and strict adherence to best practices.

• Readability: Comments and Documentation (1)

  • 0 = No comments or unclear comments

  • 0.5 = Some useful comments provided, but missing in areas or redundant on self-explaining code.

  • 1 = Comments provided and they are clear, and help understanding the whole codebase.

• Performance (1)

  • 0 = Poor performance with timeouts, hangs or crashes or excessive use of resources.

  • 0.5 = Good performance, but not scalable or will consume heavy resources.

  • 1 = Good performance with attention to scalability.

3- Bug Tracking and Testing:  (Total: 2)

Evaluate the effectiveness of bug tracking and testing processes. Consider the robustness of the testing strategy, the identification and resolution of bugs, and the overall stability and performance of the game.

• No errors appearing (1)

• No Warnings (1)

4- Collaboration and Communication: (Total: 3)

Assess the level of collaboration and communication among the development team members. Evaluate their ability to work together effectively, share knowledge, and address challenges efficiently.

• Code Documented easily understood (2)

• Code Good appearance in editor (1)

5- Version Control and Documentation: 

Evaluate the use of version control systems to track changes and manage code. Consider the completeness and clarity of documentation, including code comments, user manuals, and technical specifications.

• Use of Unity version 2022.3.8f1 or higher (1)

6- Iterative Improvement: (Total: 2)

Assess the ability of the development team to iterate and improve the game based on user feedback and testing. Evaluate their responsiveness to identified issues and their ability to implement updates and fixes.

• Game Can Easily Update it (1)

• Code reusability and prefabs easy access (1)

7- Technical Innovation: (Total: 6)

Consider any technical innovations or unique features implemented during development. Evaluate their effectiveness, originality, and impact on the overall game experience.

• Game Overall output as expected (3)

• All Functionality working (Logical Errors) (3)