How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 7 min read · Independent comparison
• chengziyue 6QT — biggest strength: a food-grade carbon steel crisper plate with double-layer nonstick coating and a handle, built specifically for the Gourmia GAF616 6QT air fryer basket.
• chengziyue 6QT — biggest trade-off: it only fits that one air fryer family, and you have to adjust the four silicone feet to seat it properly, plus avoid abrasive scrubbing.
• Matchwaves Grease Tray Liners — biggest strength: 20 heavy-duty aluminum foil liners with reinforced edges that lock into Char-Broil Big Easy grease trays and handle heavy grease without leaking.
• Matchwaves Grease Tray Liners — biggest trade-off: they're disposable, single-use consumables rather than a permanent accessory, and they're sized for specific grease tray part numbers.
• Who each pick is for: chengziyue 6QT for Gourmia GAF616 owners who want to grill and crisp food on a raised surface; Matchwaves for Char-Broil Big Easy and compatible outdoor air fryer owners who hate scraping grease trays.
The chengziyue 6QT is a replacement crisping rack, not a basket liner. It's a square plate made from food-grade carbon steel, roughly 8.8 x 8.8 inches and only about 0.15 inches thick, which means it sits low in the basket and adds almost no bulk. The double-layer nonstick coating is the headline feature: it's built to resist high heat and to keep the coating from flaking off over time, which is the usual failure point on cheap replacement racks. There's a handle on the plate so you can lift it straight out of the basket without tongs gymnastics, and it's dishwasher safe, though the instructions specifically warn against abrasive cloths or metal scrubbers because they'll chew through the nonstick surface. chengziyue even throws in a nonstick cleaning cloth with the rack.
The reason to buy this is cooking surface, not cleanup. A raised grill plate gives hot air room to circulate under and around food, which is what you want for things like chicken wings, sausages, bacon, or vegetables that would otherwise sit in their own drippings at the bottom of the basket. It also keeps smaller items from falling through the basket's own grate.
Matchwaves Grease Tray Liners: Who It's For
Matchwaves sells the opposite philosophy: a box of 20 disposable liners that you drop in, cook on, lift out, and throw away. They're made of heavy-duty aluminum foil with reinforced edges, sized at 10.4 x 6.3 inches, and they're designed to sit firmly in place so they don't slide around mid-cook. The deep tray profile is the practical part — it holds more grease before it needs changing, which matters on long sessions like a turkey or a big batch of wings.
Compatibility is the entire story here, so read it carefully. Matchwaves lists these as fitting Char-Broil Big Easy grease trays 2425514W12 and CB1250032P6, and being compatible with Char-Broil 17102065, 14101550 and 24102165 models. That includes the 24102165 outdoor air fryer. The brand also markets them as multi-use for food prep, baking, roasting and drip-catching in other air fryers, smokers and ovens, but the precise fit claim is tied to those Char-Broil trays.
Who should buy them: anyone running a Char-Broil Big Easy turkey fryer or a compatible outdoor air fryer who is tired of soaking and scraping a grease tray after every cook. Lifting out a foil liner and binning it is a genuinely different cleanup experience than scrubbing baked-on fat. The leak-resistant edges also protect the tray itself, which is the part you actually don't want to ruin.
Who should skip them: anyone who wants a reusable accessory, anyone cooking indoors in a standard basket-style air fryer who doesn't have a matching grease tray, and anyone who dislikes generating foil waste per cook. If your air fryer doesn't have a removable grease tray with those part numbers, these liners won't have anywhere to sit.
• Best for adding a grill surface to a Gourmia GAF616 6QT → chengziyue 6QT. The raised nonstick plate lets air circulate under food instead of letting it sit in drippings.
• Best for hassle-free grease cleanup → Matchwaves Grease Tray Liners. Lift and toss, no scrubbing or soaking.
• Best for reusable, long-term value → chengziyue 6QT. One carbon steel plate with a double-layer coating and handle versus 20 single-use foil liners.
• Best for high-volume, greasy cooks → Matchwaves Grease Tray Liners. The deep tray and reinforced edges are designed for heavy grease loads and fewer mid-cook changes.
• Best for precise fit confidence → chengziyue 6QT, if you own the exact 6QT Gourmia GAF616. It's a dedicated part rather than a cross-compatible one.
• Best for outdoor air fryer and turkey fryer owners → Matchwaves Grease Tray Liners. The fit list is built around Char-Broil Big Easy trays and the 24102165 outdoor air fryer.
• Best for dishwasher convenience → chengziyue 6QT. It's dishwasher safe, though you must skip abrasive pads and metal scrubbers.
• Best for multi-purpose kitchen use → Matchwaves Grease Tray Liners. Matchwaves positions them for prep, baking, roasting and drip-catching beyond the grill.
In my opinion, the right answer comes down to what's actually sitting on your counter. If you own a Gourmia GAF616 6QT and you want to cook better — crisper wings, less soggy bottoms, a surface you can lift out by the handle — I'd buy the chengziyue 6QT. It's the more interesting product because it changes how the air fryer performs, not just how it cleans up, and the double-layer coating and dishwasher-safe design suggest it'll hold up with reasonable care. If you own a Char-Broil Big Easy or a compatible outdoor air fryer and your real pain is grease, I'd buy the Matchwaves liners instead — 20 of them, leak-resistant, and no scraping. Neither is a universal pick, and neither is meant to be. Check the current price on Amazon once you've confirmed your model matches, because fit matters far more than anything else here.
FAQ
how to clean air fryer drip tray
It depends on the tray. If you're using the Matchwaves liners, you don't clean the tray at all — you lift the foil liner out and discard it, which is the whole point of the reinforced, leak-resistant design. For the chengziyue 6QT crisper plate, it's dishwasher safe, but the brand warns against rough abrasive cloths or metal balls because they damage the nonstick coating. A soft cloth is the safer route either way.
how to clean breville air fryer drip tray
how to clean ninja air fryer drip tray
Same caution applies. Neither the chengziyue plate nor the Matchwaves liners list Ninja compatibility, so I wouldn't assume a fit. The chengziyue is built around a specific 6QT Gourmia basket, and Matchwaves ties its liners to specific Char-Broil tray numbers. Measure your tray and confirm the model before ordering.
how to clean cuisinart air fryer drip tray
Again, neither product claims Cuisinart fit. What's useful to take away is the method: a disposable foil liner like Matchwaves eliminates cleaning entirely, while a reusable nonstick plate like chengziyue needs only a dishwasher cycle or a gentle hand wash with a soft cloth. Match the approach to whatever tray your Cuisinart actually uses.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: tutikuki 8 vs lakipum 6/7/8: Air Fryer Cake Pan, GWYXC Air Fryer Accessories vs BBQ-PLUS Stainless Steel Splatter, SharkNinja Air Fryer Max vs OSTBA 8.5QT: Best Air Fryer for