How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
• chengziyue 6QT — biggest strength: a purpose-built square carbon steel crisper plate with a double-layer nonstick coating, a handle, and a dishwasher-safe finish made specifically for the Gourmia GAF616 6QT.
• chengziyue 6QT — biggest trade-off: it is essentially locked to one air fryer family, and it is a thin 0.15-inch plate, so it is not a structural rack or a grease reservoir.
• atgestore Air Fryer Tray — biggest strength: a two-piece 304 stainless steel set (a 20.4" x 13.4" basket plus an 18.8" x 13.4" drip tray) with a mesh design for 360-degree air circulation and a long compatibility list of range ovens.
• atgestore Air Fryer Tray — biggest trade-off: it is a large oven accessory, not a countertop air fryer insert, and at 4 pounds it is a genuinely heavy piece of metal to store and handle.
• Who the chengziyue 6QT is for: someone who already owns a 6QT Gourmia GAF616 and wants an easier-to-clean cooking surface inside the basket.
• Who the atgestore Air Fryer Tray is for: someone with a compatible Samsung/GE/Whirlpool/Maytag range who wants air-fry results in the full-size oven with fat dripping away from the food.
The chengziyue 6QT is a replacement crisper plate, and the design tells you that immediately. It is square, 8.8 x 8.8 inches, and only 0.15 inches thick, which is the profile of a plate that sits inside an air fryer basket and lifts food slightly off the bottom. The material is food-grade carbon steel with a double-layer nonstick coating that the manufacturer describes as high-temperature resistant and not prone to flaking off with normal use. It is also dishwasher safe, and there is a handle so you can lift it out of a hot basket without tongs.
What it does best is solve the cleanup problem inside a Gourmia GAF616 6QT. Instead of scrubbing the basket floor, you cook on the plate, then move the plate to the dishwasher. The included extras — four silicone rubber legs and a nonstick cleaning cloth — are small but sensible: the legs let you adjust how the plate sits, and the cloth is there because the manufacturer explicitly warns against abrasive scrubbers or metal balls that would wreck the coating.
Who should buy it: owners of a Gourmia GAF616 6QT who want one dedicated, nonstick surface for fries, nuggets, vegetables and reheated leftovers. Who should skip it: anyone whose air fryer is not that specific 6QT model, and anyone who wants a stainless mesh basket rather than a coated plate. If you are not sure about the price, just check the current price on Amazon — that is what the button on this page is for.
The atgestore set is a different category of product entirely. It is a two-piece range-oven accessory: a 20.4" x 13.4" mesh basket and an 18.8" x 13.4" drip tray, both in 304 stainless steel with a silver mirror finish. The basket's mesh design is the functional heart of it — it promotes 360-degree air circulation so heat moves around the food instead of pooling under it, and the tray underneath catches the oil, fat and crumbs that drip down. That is the entire point of an air fryer drip setup in a full-size oven: crisp the food on the mesh, and let the grease land somewhere other than your oven floor.
The build is the other selling point. 304 stainless steel resists rust and deformation far better than plated materials, and the manufacturer notes that every wire cross point is welded, edges are smoothed to avoid scratching your hands, and there are handles on both ends for pulling the basket out. Cleaning is a soapy sponge and hot water — no dishwasher claim is made here, so treat it as a hand-wash item.
Who should buy it: anyone with a compatible Samsung, GE, Whirlpool or Maytag range who wants air-fried texture without buying a countertop appliance. The compatibility list is long and specific — Samsung part numbers like NX-AA5000RS and DG98-02316A, GE numbers like PM48X120 and WB48T10095, Whirlpool/Maytag numbers like W11548747. Who should skip it: anyone with a non-listed oven, anyone who wants something for a countertop air fryer, and anyone who does not want to store a 4-pound metal set. Check the model number against the list before ordering, and check the current price on Amazon.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for a 6QT Gourmia GAF616 → chengziyue 6QT. It is built for that exact model, down to the adjustable feet.
• Best for a Samsung/GE/Whirlpool/Maytag range → atgestore Air Fryer Tray. The listed part numbers and oven models are what make it a fit rather than a guess.
• Best for oil and grease management → atgestore Air Fryer Tray. The tray is a dedicated drip pan; the chengziyue plate is not.
• Best for durability over years → atgestore Air Fryer Tray. 304 stainless steel with welded joints versus a coated carbon steel plate.
• Best for airflow around food → atgestore Air Fryer Tray. The mesh basket is designed for 360-degree circulation.
• Best for small kitchens and quick jobs → chengziyue 6QT. It is thin, light and lives inside the fryer.
• Best for cooking for a family in one batch → atgestore Air Fryer Tray. A 20.4-inch basket holds far more than a 6QT fryer plate.
In my opinion, these two do not really compete — they compete for two different kitchens. If you own a Gourmia GAF616 6QT and your complaint is scrubbing the basket every night, I would buy the chengziyue 6QT. It is the simpler, lower-effort fix. If you own a compatible range oven and your complaint is that air frying means a separate appliance on the counter, I would buy the atgestore Air Fryer Tray; the mesh basket plus drip tray is the more versatile piece of equipment. Match the product to your appliance first, then check the current price on Amazon.
FAQ
how to clean air fryer drip tray
With the atgestore tray, the manufacturer's guidance is a soapy sponge and hot water — wipe it down after the fat cools. With the chengziyue plate, you can either hand wash it or put it in the dishwasher. Never use abrasive pads or metal balls on the chengziyue coating.
Neither product here is made for Breville. The chengziyue 6QT is designed for the Gourmia GAF616 6QT, and the atgestore set is listed for Samsung, GE, Whirlpool and Maytag ranges. Follow your Breville manual for its own drip tray instead.
how to clean ninja air fryer drip tray
Same answer: this page's two picks are not Ninja accessories. Cleaning advice that does carry over is the general rule — let the tray cool, use warm soapy water, and avoid anything abrasive on nonstick surfaces.
how to clean cuisinart air fryer drip tray
Again, neither the chengziyue plate nor the atgestore set is specified for Cuisinart ovens. If you want these specific parts, confirm your model against the Gourmia GAF616 or the Samsung/GE/Whirlpool/Maytag compatibility lists before you buy.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: air fryer drip tray, atgestore KCO124 vs Allstare 304: Air Fryer Crumb Tray, chengziyue 6QT vs GWYSY Air Fryer Crumb