How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 8 min read · Independent comparison
• chengziyue 6QT — biggest strength: A double-layer nonstick carbon steel crisper plate that drops into a 6QT Gourmia GAF616 basket, with a built-in handle for lifting it out and dishwasher-safe cleanup.
• chengziyue 6QT — biggest trade-off: It is built around one specific air fryer model, and the four silicone feet may need adjusting so the fit feels right in your basket.
• GWYSY Air Fryer Crumb — biggest strength: A large 12.5 × 11 × 0.3 inch steel drip pan that catches crumbs, grease and drips under the cooking area of a Kalorik MAXX 26 Quart oven combo, which helps cut down on smoke and lingering odors.
• GWYSY Air Fryer Crumb — biggest trade-off: It is a bottom tray, not a cooking surface — it protects the appliance rather than holding your food, and it is sized for a 26QT oven combo, not a 6QT basket.
• Who each pick is for: Choose chengziyue 6QT if you own the Gourmia GAF616 and want to crisp more food at once; choose GWYSY Air Fryer Crumb if you own a Kalorik MAXX 26QT combo and are tired of scrubbing the bottom.
The chengziyue 6QT is a replacement crisper tray for the Gourmia GAF616 6QT digital electric air fryer. It is square, measures 8.8 x 8.8 x 0.15 inches and weighs only 0.32 ounces, so it is a thin, light insert rather than a heavy piece of cookware. The idea is straightforward: it sits inside the basket and gives you a raised grilling surface, which is the kind of setup that helps air circulate under food instead of letting it sit in its own drippings. If you have ever wished your 6QT basket could handle a main and a side at the same time, this is the accessory that makes that possible.
What it does best comes down to two things: material and finish. It is made from food-grade carbon steel that the manufacturer states meets FDA standards and is BPA-free, non-toxic and tasteless. The coating is a double-layer nonstick process, described as high-temperature resistant and resistant to flaking, which matters because a crisper plate takes more abuse than a plain pan — it is constantly being lifted in and out of a hot basket. There is also a handle, which sounds minor until you have tried to fish a hot grate out of an air fryer with tongs. And when you are done, it goes in the dishwasher.
The extras are worth noting because they solve real annoyances. You get four silicone rubber feet, and the instructions explicitly tell you to adjust the tightness of those feet so the tray matches your air fryer — that is the manufacturer acknowledging that fit can vary slightly and giving you a way to correct it. You also get a nonstick cleaning cloth, plus a warning not to scrub with abrasive pads or metal balls, which is the single fastest way to ruin any nonstick coating.
Who should buy it: anyone with a Gourmia GAF616 6QT who wants a second cooking level, easier release of crispy food, and a rack that survives the dishwasher. Who should skip it: anyone who does not own that specific air fryer. This is a model-specific part — it is sized and shaped for the GAF616 basket, and it will not do anything useful in a different brand or a different capacity. If you are unsure whether it matches your machine, measure your basket before ordering.
The GWYSY Air Fryer Crumb is a completely different kind of accessory. It is a bottom drip pan — a crumb tray — designed for the Kalorik MAXX 26 Quart 10-in-1 countertop toaster oven air fryer combo. It measures 12.5 × 11 × 0.3 inches, weighs 10.8 ounces, and the manufacturer notes it also fits other air fryer toaster ovens of the same size, which makes it more of a universal-size part than the chengziyue plate. It is a large, flat sheet of premium steel, and its job is not to cook your food. Its job is to catch everything that falls off it.
That is a bigger deal than it sounds. In a 26QT oven-style air fryer, grease and crumbs drop onto the bottom of the cavity and then bake onto whatever is down there — often right near the heating element. That is where the smoke comes from, and that is where the smell lingers after dinner. By collecting drips and crumbs before they reach that surface, the tray directly addresses both problems. The manufacturer lists smoke and odor reduction as a core benefit, and the logic holds up: fat that never touches a hot element cannot burn on it.
Build quality is pitched at the same level as the chengziyue plate. It is food-grade premium steel, BPA-free, non-toxic and odorless, and stated to meet FDA standards. The steel is rated to withstand up to 480°F, and the manufacturer recommends a simple preheat before first use — 10 minutes at 300°F — to help the tray hold its shape over time. That is a sensible break-in step for stamped steel and takes almost no effort.
Cleanup is the whole point here. The tray is dishwasher safe, the surface resists sticking, and it is described as sturdy enough not to bend easily. For stubborn spots, a short soak followed by a soft cloth is the recommended approach. You are essentially trading a five-minute scrub of an awkward oven floor for pulling out one flat pan and rinsing it.
Who should buy it: Kalorik MAXX 26QT owners who cook greasy food — wings, bacon, fries, anything breaded — and want to stop fighting the bottom of the oven. Who should skip it: anyone with a basket-style air fryer. This tray is far too large for a 6QT basket, and even in a smaller oven-style unit it may not sit correctly. It is also not a cooking surface, so do not buy it expecting to grill on it.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for catching mess before it bakes on → GWYSY Air Fryer Crumb. It is a bottom tray whose entire purpose is collecting crumbs, grease and drips.
• Best for a 6QT basket air fryer → chengziyue 6QT. Sized 8.8 × 8.8 inches for the Gourmia GAF616 specifically.
• Best for a 26QT oven-style combo → GWYSY Air Fryer Crumb. Sized 12.5 × 11 inches for the Kalorik MAXX 26 Quart and similar large ovens.
• Best for reducing smoke and lingering odors → GWYSY Air Fryer Crumb. Keeping fat off the heating element is exactly what it is designed to do.
• Best for nonstick food release → chengziyue 6QT. The double-layer nonstick coating is the standout feature of that plate.
• Best for dishwasher convenience → a tie. Both are stated as dishwasher safe; the chengziyue adds a handle for easier removal, the GWYSY adds a preheat step for longevity.
• Best for fit flexibility → GWYSY Air Fryer Crumb. It is described as fitting other same-size air fryer toaster ovens, while the chengziyue is tied to one model.
In my opinion, the right buy is decided before you read a single spec: match the accessory to the appliance you actually own. If you have the Gourmia GAF616 6QT, I would buy the chengziyue 6QT — the nonstick double-layer coating, the handle and the dishwasher-safe design make it the more useful everyday upgrade, and the four adjustable feet give you a way to dial in the fit. If you have a Kalorik MAXX 26 Quart combo, I would buy the GWYSY Air Fryer Crumb instead, because the smoke and odor benefit of keeping grease off the bottom of that oven is worth more than any crisping surface would be. Neither one is a universal product, and buying the wrong one helps nobody.
FAQ
It is designed specifically for the Gourmia GAF616 6QT digital electric air fryer, and the 8.8 × 8.8 inch square shape reflects that. The manufacturer notes the four silicone feet can be adjusted for a snugger fit, but I would not count on it working properly in a different model or capacity.
It is made for the Kalorik MAXX 26 Quart 10-in-1 countertop toaster oven air fryer combo, and the manufacturer also states it fits other air fryer toaster ovens of the same size. At 12.5 × 11 inches it is far too big for a standard basket-style air fryer.
For the GWYSY tray, yes — the manufacturer recommends preheating it in the oven at 300°F for 10 minutes before first use to help it hold its shape. The chengziyue plate has no preheat step, but you should adjust the four rubber feet so it sits correctly in your basket.
Both are dishwasher safe. The GWYSY tray is a flat sheet that resists sticking and can be soaked for stubborn bits; the chengziyue plate has a handle that makes it easier to lift out of a hot basket. For the chengziyue, avoid abrasive cloths and metal scrubbers, since those will damage the nonstick coating.
They are different categories of accessory, so comparing them on cost alone is not meaningful. Check the current price on Amazon for whichever one matches your appliance, and judge it against how much scrubbing or how much basket space it saves you.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: AODPWEN 2 vs Onader Air Fryer Basket, HEISENLIN Air Fryer Replacement vs AKS Magnets Air Fryer Cheat, RAMLLY Air Fryer Replacement vs HEISENLIN Air Fryer Replacement, ACWIEOIB UCGAOIOQ Air Fryer vs Generic Air Fryer Conversion