We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-22 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a matched basket-and-crumb-tray set built for the KitchenAid KCO124 digital air fry countertop oven, choose atgestore KCO124; if you need a single crumb/drip tray for a Kalorik MAXX 26-quart air fryer oven, choose Allstare 304.
• atgestore KCO124 — biggest strength: a two-piece kit (air fry basket plus crumb tray) in food-grade 304 stainless steel, sized specifically for the KitchenAid KCO124 and KCO124BM.
• atgestore KCO124 — biggest trade-off: it is model-specific. The 14.1"L x 10"W basket and 13.2"L x 13"W x 0.6"H tray are built around one oven family, so it will not help if you own anything else.
• Allstare 304 — biggest strength: a purpose-made replacement drip/pan tray measuring 12.5"L x 11"W for a defined list of Kalorik MAXX ovens, in the same 304 stainless steel.
• Allstare 304 — biggest trade-off: it is a tray only, not a basket, and the fit list is narrow — several 26-quart Kalorik models are explicitly excluded.
• Who each pick is for: the atgestore set is for KCO124/KCO124BM owners who want to restore or upgrade both cooking surfaces at once. The Allstare tray is for owners of the listed Kalorik MAXX models who only need the bottom pan.
This is a replacement set, not a single part. You get a kitchenaid air fryer basket at 14.1"L x 10"W and a crumb tray at 13.2"L x 13"W x 0.6"H, both in 304 stainless steel. The material matters here: 304 is the grade the maker points to for direct food contact, and it is described as more deformation-resistant than ordinary stainless or plated parts that tend to rust and warp over time. In my opinion, that is the real selling point — a tray that stays flat and a basket that holds its shape after repeated heat cycles.
What it does best is the pairing. The basket lifts food and lets hot air move underneath, which is how you get even browning and a crisp finish on things like fries, chicken wings or roasted vegetables. The tray sits below and catches the crumbs, drips and oil that fall during cooking, and because it slides out, cleanup is a matter of removing it rather than scrubbing the oven floor. If you bake bread, cookies or pizza, the basket also gives you a stable, no-flip surface to work on.
Allstare 304: Who It's For
The Allstare 304 is a single crumb tray — 12.5"L x 11"W and 0.43"H — made from food-grade 304 stainless steel that the maker describes as high-temperature resistant, nonstick and not prone to rust or warping. Its job is narrow and clear: it sits at the bottom of the oven, collects whatever falls off your food, and slides out so you can tip the debris into the bin and wipe the surface with a soft, damp sponge. A mild liquid cleanser is fine for keeping stains from building up.
The catch is compatibility, and it is a big one. This tray fits the Kalorik MAXX AFO 46045 SS, AFO 47631 SS2 and AFO 51041 SS. It does not fit the AFO52295SS Flex Trio, the AFO52233SS MAXX Advance, the AFO51781SSCA French Door model, or the AFO 47267 OW 9-in-1. Even though all of those are 26-quart machines, the tray will not seat correctly. The manufacturer is blunt about this — compare your original part's size and model number rather than ordering on looks.
Who should buy it: someone with one of those three supported Kalorik MAXX ovens whose bottom pan is stained, scratched or missing, and who wants a straightforward stainless replacement. Who should skip it: everyone else. If your model appears on the "not fits" list, or you also need a basket or rack, this single tray will not solve your problem. Note the 60-day warranty period — it tells you the maker expects the part to hold up, but it also sets a clear window for anything going wrong.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for a complete two-piece replacement → atgestore KCO124. Basket and tray together, matched to the KCO124/KCO124BM.
• Best for replacing only the bottom pan → Allstare 304. One tray, nothing extra to store.
• Best for KitchenAid KCO124 or KCO124BM owners → atgestore KCO124. It is the set built for exactly those ovens.
• Best for Kalorik MAXX AFO 46045 SS / AFO 47631 SS2 / AFO 51041 SS owners → Allstare 304. Confirm your model number first.
• Bigger tray footprint → atgestore KCO124 at 13.2"L x 13"W, versus 12.5"L x 11"W for the Allstare.
• Most cooking flexibility → atgestore KCO124. The basket adds an air-circulating, no-flip surface on top of the drip-catching tray.
• Highest risk of ordering the wrong part → Allstare 304. Its exclusion list is long, so a model check is mandatory.
I would buy the atgestore KCO124 if I owned a KitchenAid KCO124 or KCO124BM, because you get both working surfaces in one shot and the 304 stainless construction is the whole reason to replace rather than tolerate a bent or rusting original. I would buy the Allstare 304 only if I owned one of the three listed Kalorik MAXX models and my tray alone was the problem. Same material, same idea — the decision comes down to which oven is on your counter, not which tray looks better.
how to clean air fryer crumb tray
Slide the tray out once the oven has cooled, tip loose crumbs into the bin, then wipe it with a soft, damp sponge. For greasy film, a mild liquid cleanser helps prevent stain build-up. Both trays here are removable by design, which is what makes this quick — 304 stainless tolerates regular washing without the rusting you get from plated parts.
how to clean breville air fryer crumb tray
Neither tray on this page is made for Breville ovens — the atgestore set fits KitchenAid KCO124/KCO124BM and the Allstare fits specific Kalorik MAXX models. On any stainless crumb tray, the method is the same: cool, remove, shake off debris, wipe with a damp sponge and a gentle cleanser. Always match the part to your oven's model number before buying.
how to clean ninja air fryer crumb tray
Same routine, different oven — and again, neither product here is a Ninja part. The general rule for stainless trays is to avoid abrasive pads that scratch the finish and to clean soon after use so oil does not bake on. The Allstare instructions are the useful template: slide out, discard crumbs, wipe with a soft damp sponge.
how to get grease stains off of air fryer crumb tray
Clean while the residue is still soft rather than after it has carbonized. Wipe with a damp sponge and a mild liquid cleanser, repeating until the film lifts; the Allstare guidance specifically mentions a liquid cleanser to avoid stain build-up. Because both trays are 304 stainless rather than a plated finish, they handle repeated washing without the flaking and rust that ruin cheaper pans.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: air fryer crumb tray, air fryer tray, Geesta 304 vs GWYSY Air Fryer Replacement