How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a replacement air fryer grill pan sized and shaped for Gourmia 6-quart models, choose chengziyue 6QT; if you need one built for the Ninja Pro 5-quart AF141/AF142 basket, choose GCQ Air fryer Replacement.
• chengziyue 6QT biggest trade-off: It only fits Gourmia 6-quart GAF698/GAF686 baskets, so it is useless if you own a different brand or size.
• GCQ Air fryer Replacement biggest strength: A compact 8.43 × 8.43-inch aluminum crisper plate with an enameled double-layer nonstick finish, handle, and dishwasher-safe cleanup for Ninja Pro 5-quart models.
• GCQ Air fryer Replacement biggest trade-off: It is smaller and aluminum-based, so it will not fill a 6-quart Gourmia basket and is not stated to fit that brand at all.
• Who each pick is for: Choose chengziyue if you own a Gourmia 6QT; choose GCQ if you own a Ninja Pro 5QT 4-in-1 AF141 or 5-in-1 AF142.
The chengziyue 6QT is a purpose-built replacement tray, not a universal accessory. Its stated fit is the Gourmia 6-quart GAF698 and GAF686 air fryer ovens, and the plate measures 9.39 × 9.09 inches. That footprint is the whole point: it is sized to sit inside a 6-quart Gourmia basket the way the original crisper plate did, so you get the same cooking surface and airflow pattern you had before. If your stock tray warped, lost its coating, or went missing, this is the direct swap.
The standout construction detail is the material. The sheet lists food-grade 304 stainless steel, described as FDA-compliant and BPA-free, with a double-layer nonstick coating that the brand says resists flaking. There is also a handle for lifting it out of a hot basket, and it is dishwasher safe. The package includes the tray plus a nonstick cleaning cloth and four rubber bumpers — those bumpers matter, because the brand asks you to adjust the tightness of the four feet to get a snug fit in your specific unit.
Who should buy it: Gourmia 6-quart owners who want a stainless-steel-based plate with a handle and a coating designed to hold up. Who should skip it: anyone with a Ninja, Philips, or any air fryer outside the listed Gourmia models — the size and fit simply will not match. If you are unsure, measure your basket's inner diameter first, because this is a fit-specific part. As for cost, the current price is always worth checking on Amazon before you commit, since replacement trays vary.
The GCQ plate is the Ninja Pro counterpart. It is designed for the Ninja Air Fryer Pro 5-quart 4-in-1 AF141 and 5-in-1 AF142, with an 8.43 × 8.43-inch surface. That is noticeably smaller than the chengziyue plate, which makes sense — it is matching a 5-quart basket, not a 6-quart one. The material here is aluminum with an enameled, double-layer sprayed nonstick coating that the listing describes as easy to clean and more durable, and it is dishwasher safe.
Like its rival, it has a handle so you can pull the plate out of the frying basket without tongs, and it ships with a magic cleaning cloth and four rubber bumpers. The brand notes it works for pizza, fries, steak, wings, and vegetables — the usual air fryer lineup. One thing I like: the brand explicitly tells you to measure your air fryer's inner diameter before ordering, which is honest advice for a part this fit-dependent.
Who should buy it: Ninja Pro 5-quart AF141/AF142 owners who want a lightweight aluminum crisper plate with a handle and easy cleanup. Who should skip it: Gourmia 6-quart users, or anyone hoping a single tray covers multiple air fryer brands. At 8.43 inches square, it will look and feel undersized in a 6-quart basket, and the listing does not claim compatibility with Gourmia at all.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for Gourmia GAF698/GAF686 owners → chengziyue 6QT. It is the only one of the two stated to fit those exact models.
• Best for Ninja Pro 5QT AF141/AF142 owners → GCQ Air fryer Replacement. It is built for that basket size and those model numbers.
• Stainless steel construction → chengziyue 6QT. The sheet lists 304 stainless steel; the GCQ sheet lists aluminum.
• Lightest build → GCQ Air fryer Replacement. Aluminum keeps the plate light for lifting in and out of the basket.
• Easiest cleanup → both. Each is dishwasher safe with a nonstick coating, and each includes a cleaning cloth.
• Most forgiving fit for odd baskets → chengziyue 6QT. Its four adjustable feet let you tune the tightness to your unit.
• Best for small households or single portions → GCQ Air fryer Replacement. The smaller plate suits a 5-quart basket and lighter loads.
In my opinion, the right buy comes down entirely to which air fryer sits on your counter. If you own a Gourmia 6-quart GAF698 or GAF686, I would buy the chengziyue 6QT — the 304 stainless steel build, the larger surface, and the adjustable feet make it the stronger match for that basket. If you own a Ninja Pro 5-quart AF141 or AF142, I would buy the GCQ Air fryer Replacement instead, because it is sized for that machine and the aluminum keeps it light. Neither is a universal part. Match the model number first, then buy.
how to clean ninja air fryer grill pan
Both plates here are dishwasher safe, and the GCQ sheet specifically lists a ceramics-style nonstick coating that cleans easily in the dishwasher. If you hand-wash, use the included cleaning cloth or a soft sponge. The brand warns against rough abrasive cloths or metal balls, which can damage the nonstick layer.
how to use philips air fryer grill pan
These two products are not listed as compatible with Philips air fryers, so neither is the right pick for that brand. The general idea with any grill pan is to set it in the basket, add food in a single layer, and let air circulate around it. For a Philips unit, you would need a tray sized to that specific basket.
how long to grill paneer in air fryer
Neither data sheet gives cooking times, so I will not invent one. What I can say is that a grill pan like these lifts food off the basket floor so hot air reaches the underside, which helps browning. Paneer is soft, so check it early the first time and adjust from there.
will the chengziyue 6QT fit a Ninja air fryer
No — the chengziyue sheet states its fit is the Gourmia 6-quart GAF698 and GAF686, plus any air fryer matching its 9.39 × 9.09-inch size. Ninja Pro 5-quart baskets take the smaller GCQ plate instead. Always measure your basket's inner diameter before ordering either one.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: chengziyue 6QT vs Matchwaves Grease Tray Liners: Air Fryer, Ciieeo Air Fryer Mat vs Vaguelly Air Fryer Replacement, Weber ® Charcoal Cooking vs CyHiThai Air Fryer Grill