How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
If you want a single flat mat that doubles as a grill-surface liner and works for indirect cooking on gas, charcoal and electric grills, choose Ciieeo Air Fryer Mat; if you need a round carbon-steel tray that drops into an air fryer basket as a divider, crisper plate and steaming plate all at once, choose Vaguelly Air Fryer Replacement.
• Ciieeo Air Fryer Mat — biggest strength: one flat 7.87 x 7.87 inch carbon-steel mat that is sold as heat-proof, non-stick and built to resist heat without burning or shrinking, and it is the more flexible of the two because it works for indirect cooking on gas, charcoal and electric grills, not just inside an air fryer.
• Ciieeo Air Fryer Mat — biggest trade-off: it is a flat square sheet, not a shaped accessory with a raised lip, so it does not act as a divider or a tray with walls, and at 7.87 inches per side it is best matched to a 5.2QT–6.3QT basket rather than a small round one.
• Vaguelly Air Fryer Replacement — biggest strength: a round carbon-steel tray with a double-layer non-stick coating, dishwasher-safe care, and a design described as easy to install and remove, so it works as a divider, crisper plate and steaming plate in one piece.
• Vaguelly Air Fryer Replacement — biggest trade-off: it is round and roughly 8.53 inches across, so it fits round air fryer baskets well but is a poor match for square or rectangular baskets, and it is narrower in scope than Ciieeo because it is not pitched for gas, charcoal or electric grill use.
• Pick Ciieeo Air Fryer Mat if you want a flat, grill-friendly liner that handles chicken, wings, ribs, burgers, steaks, fish, shrimp, fruit, vegetables, breakfast and pizza.
• Pick Vaguelly Air Fryer Replacement if you want a round drop-in tray you can run through the dishwasher and use for frying, steaming and crisping in the same basket.
The Ciieeo Air Fryer Mat is a 20 x 20 x 0.2 cm flat mat in black carbon steel, listed at about 7.87 by 7.87 inches and weighing roughly 3.84 ounces. That is a thin, light, flexible-feeling sheet rather than a rigid pan, and the specs frame it around three jobs: an air fryer mat, a non-stick grill mat, and a cooking paper mat substitute. The point of the design is to sit between your food and a hot surface so food does not stick and cleanup is simpler, while the material is described as heat-resistant enough not to burn or shrink.
Who should buy it: someone with a 5.2QT–6.3QT air fryer who wants a flat liner for sticky or messy foods, and who also wants a non-stick surface for indirect grilling. The item highlight calls it a heat-proof divider accessory with a black finish that supports shrimp and wings, so if you want a divider-style surface you can drop in and lift out, this fits that role.
Who should skip it: anyone with a small round basket who needs a tray shaped to the basket wall, and anyone who wants a dishwasher-safe accessory with a raised rim. Those buyers are better served by the Vaguelly tray. Also skip it if you mainly want a rigid pan with sides — this is a flat mat, and its strength is surface coverage, not containment.
Vaguelly Air Fryer Replacement: Who It's For
The Vaguelly Air Fryer Replacement is a round carbon-steel tray in black, listed at roughly 21.7 x 21.7 x 0.1 cm, or about 8.53 by 8.53 inches, and weighing about 3.52 ounces. The specs lean hard on three ideas: it is a divider, it is a crisper plate, and it is a steaming plate. The multifunctional framing is the whole pitch — one round piece that can fry, steam and crisp, rather than three separate accessories.
The details that matter most are the double-layer non-stick coating and the dishwasher-safe care instruction. A double coating is described as making cleanup easier and helping food release while supporting the accessory's longevity, which is the practical answer to the usual complaint about air fryer inserts: food welding itself to the surface. Being dishwasher safe is called out repeatedly, so this is the pick for someone who wants to cook, then load the tray into the dishwasher instead of scrubbing it by hand.
Installation and removal are described as easy, which matters if you use your divider often — you can set it up for a divided cook and take it out for cleaning and storage without a fight. The listed food range covers steaks, vegetables, fish, fries, pizza and chicken wings, so it handles both protein and sides.
Who should buy it: owners of round air fryer baskets who want a shaped tray, a divider for cooking two things at once, and a crisper plate for frozen foods, all with dishwasher-safe cleanup. Who should skip it: anyone with a square or rectangular basket, and anyone who wants a flat mat for outdoor grill use — the Vaguelly specs do not mention gas, charcoal or electric grills.
• Best for a flat, grill-friendly liner → Ciieeo Air Fryer Mat. The specs explicitly cover indirect cooking on gas, charcoal and electric grills.
• Best for a round basket with a shaped tray → Vaguelly Air Fryer Replacement. Round, roughly 8.53 inches across, and built as a drop-in divider.
• Best for dishwasher cleanup → Vaguelly Air Fryer Replacement. Dishwasher-safe care is stated directly; the Ciieeo sheet does not list dishwasher use.
• Best for cooking two foods at once → Vaguelly Air Fryer Replacement. It is described as a multifunctional divider, which is exactly the divided-basket job.
• Best for camping, parks and garden cooking → Ciieeo Air Fryer Mat. Its listed uses include home, parks, gardens and campgrounds.
• Best for a 5.2QT–6.3QT air fryer → Ciieeo Air Fryer Mat. That basket range is named in its title.
• Best for crisper-plate and steaming-plate duty → Vaguelly Air Fryer Replacement. Frying, steaming and crisping are all listed.
• Best for a sticky-food surface across several appliances → Ciieeo Air Fryer Mat. Non-stick, heat-resistant, and not limited to the air fryer.
In my opinion, the Vaguelly Air Fryer Replacement is the better buy for most air fryer owners, because it is purpose-built for the basket: round, dishwasher safe, double-coated non-stick, and usable as a divider, crisper plate and steaming plate. It solves the everyday problem — divided cooking plus easy cleanup — in one piece. I would only steer you to the Ciieeo Air Fryer Mat if your cooking jumps between an air fryer and an outdoor grill, or if you own a 5.2QT–6.3QT basket and want a flat liner rather than a shaped tray. Check the current price on Amazon before deciding, since both are budget-tier accessories and the gap is small.
FAQ
which air fryer has a removable divider
Yes. Dishwasher-safe care is stated directly in the Vaguelly specs, and the double-layer non-stick coating is described as making cleanup easier. That combination is the main reason I favor it for daily basket cooking.
It depends on your basket shape. A round tray like the Vaguelly fits round baskets and acts as a divider, crisper plate and steaming plate. A flat 7.87-inch mat like the Ciieeo suits 5.2QT–6.3QT baskets and also works for indirect cooking on gas, charcoal and electric grills.
Both sheets list a similar range: chicken and wings, steaks, fish, shrimp, vegetables, fries and pizza. The Ciieeo mat also lists ribs, burgers, fruit and breakfast items, while the Vaguelly tray adds steaming to its frying and crisping duties.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: GXF Air Fryer Cooking vs GCQFZ Toaster Oven Replacement, HQT 8QT vs INFRAOVENS Air Fryer Parchment: Power XL Air, Megachef 9.5 vs OLIXIS Toaster Ovens Countertop: Air Fryer