Application of Knowledge
Maddie Beuthien & Skyla Meyer
Maddie Beuthien & Skyla Meyer
In Module 1, we spent time learning about the "Triangle of Quality Service" model. This model contains three aspects to quality service including education, direct service, and reflection. The model focuses on the importance of having all three components when it comes to service work. Without education, the service may feel unprepared for and could hurt the community. Without service, the education learned may feel like it does not have a bigger meaning. Finally, without reflection, the service and education could be easily forgotten. Our education before traveling to Des Moines mostly consisted of in-class discussions regarding service work. We discussed how we should approach the trip in order to make the most out of our time at the YMCA. When we were actively participating in direct service during the week, we made sure to incorporate what we learned from the class into our volunteering. Finally, each night during our trip, we would reflect on our service from that day. We would talk about the things we enjoyed, things that were surprising to us, and new things we learned. We also talked about how we could take what we learned and use it for support back home in Iowa City.
In Module 2, we learned that the Active Citizenship Continuum is a continued process where there is always growth potential for a new area (ex. You could be a Conscientious Citizen when it comes to Homelessness, a Member when it comes to Gentrification, and a Volunteer when it comes to Disability Rights), and that Active Citizenship is a lifestyle. We learned that education was going to be key to becoming a helpful volunteer team. We learned about these modules to prepare us for service, and learned about one another to make the team strong when working together. During the trip, we saw the team-building pay off because we did not need to worry about interpersonal conflicts, and we were able to help each other while carrying out tasks, making service more efficient than if we did not get to experience the class together beforehand. Gaining social skills in Iowa City made it easier to get to know the people we were working with at the YMCA, the leaders and the residents. Because of the lessons, we were all on the same page as to how to approach service (ex. being a good listener) once we arrived in Des Moines. We learned some of the root causes of the social problem we were there to help with from the leaders at the YMCA, for example, the rise in housing costs in cities that are difficult to meet.
In Module 3, we learned about the "Deprivation Trap" (pictured to the left) and discussed a paper titled "Babies in the River." Both of these works focus on the idea that community issues are multi-layered. The deprivation trap looks at how a lack of stability in one area leads to downfall in another area. On the first day of our service trip, Brooke—the community engagement director, discussed this very idea with us. She talked about how if someone is out of employment, they can easily lose their home. It is also true that if someone loses their home, they could lose their job because they may not be able to meet their same work demands when dealing with the stressors of losing a place of residence. Even more, Brooke talked to us about how rent is much higher the further you get downtown, so it becomes difficult for those with low income to live downtown, but then they are met with issues of finding transportation to jobs and stores. We were able to see how the YMCA SHC has met some of these needs through their various programs. The YMCA is right near downtown for easy access. Many residents travel by bike, so they also have a new bicycle fix station so that their community members do not have to worry about transportation.
In Module 4, we learned about the Savior Complex and how to avoid it. Asking before taking pictures, not making the service about ourselves, and treating all equally are important in a trip like this. During the trip, Brooke taught us that people experiencing homelessness at the bare minimum, need to be seen as people. She talked about the common urge to avoid walking near or looking at homeless people you encounter outside, and how politely saying 'no' to someone asking if you have money to spare is better than acting like you did not hear them at all. A Savior Complex would cause a person to not see the people they are meant to be helping, as people too. It could entail going through the service trip we did without any contact with the residents themselves. The ways we interacted one-on-one rather than only behind-the-scenes included directly serving meals, eating meals with the residents, and joining one of their Walking Club trips, talking along the way. Beyond that, rather than trying to create something from scratch in a community other than our own, we joined the YMCA SHC, a great asset that already existed by and for the community members there. During service we helped with the tasks that they provided rather than deciding what to do on our own, many times doing the work as a larger team with these leaders, too.
In Module 5, we learned about the "Asset-Based Community Development (ABCD)" model. In it, an Asset is a "resource that an individual, organization, or entire community can use to reduce or prevent poverty and injustice." We went over how people need their basic needs yet to adequately meet any other demands such as school (why we have a Food Pantry at the University of Iowa), securing a job, or taking care of others. The YMCA's Supportive Housing Campus is just that, both a hub of resources for the Des Moines community, which has become a community in it of itself. When a person leaves the SHC, they are called a Graduate, and it is not uncommon for them to keep in touch with the workers and other residents, or to return to the SHC as a visitor sometimes. We see this as a Social Asset: the public areas that visitors can enter (the dining area, game room, and outdoor area) so that residents can maintain outside connections, and these public areas also encourage interaction of the current residents with one another. They can eat together (and or sometimes with workers and volunteers) when they serve a hot meal and come together for events such as when they celebrate everyone's' birthdays for that month, Christmas, or pop-up shops. They also have the Walking Club as a low-stakes opportunity to get to know each other, and might take classes together in the classroom that we got to spend time in. In the ABCD model, there are Social Assets as mentioned, but also Physical, Human, Environmental, Political, and Cultural Assets as well. On Day 1 of our service trip, we received a tour on the SHC's Physical Assets: The 140 housing units (including a bed, bathroom and kitchen each), the laundry room, the pantry which holds food, clothing, and hygiene all at once (fueled by donations), their outdoor area that includes a garden that the residents use to grow more food, the game and dining room, the classroom, and the kitchen where workers and volunteers cook meals at least once a week for the residents, sometimes more if extra help is available. Human Assets are people holding skills and knowledge. The SHC had the Human Assets of the case managers running classes and individual plans for the residents. One resident shared his skill of singing and playing guitar for everyone before those weekly meals, and another helped paint the origami swans we saw on the wall outside, and that you can see on our Home page. For Environmental Assets, they had the Walking Club as an easy option to spend time outdoors, and their garden. The Political Asset we learned about was the lobbying and voting that Brooke said she did often, all for the goal of a more supported community. Cultural Assets I saw were the kindness rocks residents painted together and kept both inside and outside and the puzzles they do that get hung up on the wall in the dining area.
In Module 6, we learned about the social change model and how everyone experiences change at a different rate. We learned that social change can occur on large or small scales and can cover a wide variety of issues. Those lobbying for change are usually the ones mostly affected by the cause but could also just be supporters. The YMCA SHC is a part of social change in and of itself as it is the only one of its kind. Brooke talked to us about how they are always trying to reach out to community members to find more support for the cause. On the fourth day of our service trip, we went to the local Dollar Tree to collect hygiene products as donations. We talked about after how surprised we were that so many people were willing to donate, even when many community members did not know what the SHC was. After completing our service at the YMCA, we came together as a group and discussed how we could apply what we learned to making social change on our own campus in Iowa City. We talked about the need for change and what issues are stopping it from happening. During our talk, we reflected on what we had learned during the trip, and we came up with some ideas that we could work towards back home.