SPHILTER & POPBEANS Methords to speak in a GD
In today's class, we learned about two new things. Actually, they are not concepts but rules made for GD. These are something one must know before going for a GD. There are two rules for two types of topics generally asked in GDs — mainly General Topics and Abstract Topics.
Discussing the rule that one should remember when he/she is given a general topic is SPHILTER rule. I will be explaining this rule with an example. Consider the topic given to our group, sitting there in GD is Covid-19.
So expanding the rule SPHILTER it turns out to be
S = Social = In this we have to keep in mind that we can tell both positive and negative impact of Covid-19 to our society.
Positive: During Covid-19, many people actually became more aware of hygiene and cleanliness. We started caring about things like hand washing, wearing masks, and personal health.
Negative: On the other side, it created a lot of distance between people. Social life was badly affected, people stopped meeting even family and friends, which led to a lot of mental health issues.
P = Political = we have to tell positive and negative impact of Covid 19 in politics.
Positive: It brought all the people together, instead of fighting every one started helping each other as much as possible, which in turn led to the formation of strong bonds between political parties and their members.
Negative: But at the same time, in many places, it became a blame game. Opposition and ruling parties were fighting over vaccines, lockdowns, etc. instead of working together.
H = History/Historical = In this we have to tell that such an enormous disaster ever happen in the past or not and what was the positive impact and negative impact of that .
Positive: We can say it made history. Like the 1918 Spanish flu, this will also be written in books. We can learn a lot from this to avoid future disasters.
Negative: But honestly, it brought back the fear of pandemics like in the old days. People were scared, unsure, and many even compared it to war situations.
I = International = in this we have to tell that how this thing had an affect in the international level. Positive: Countries began to support one another. For example, vaccine sharing between nations and countries providing oxygen supplies and medical aid.
Negative: However, international travel and trade were severely affected. Borders were closed, visas were canceled, and economies reliant on tourism suffered significantly.
L = Legal/ Legality = In this, we have to tell what legal actions were taken. Positive: New laws and rules were introduced for public safety, like wearing masks, social distancing, and even paid leaves for Covid-positive employees.
Negative: But sometimes, these rules were too strict or misused. In some places, freedom was affected, and people were arrested for just stepping out.
T = Technology = In this, we have to tell how this helped in technology upgradation or degradation, good use or misuse, etc
Positive: This was a big boost for tech. Online classes, work-from-home, Zoom meetings — everything became digital, and we all learnt new tools.
Negative: But not everyone had internet or devices. Many students and workers were left behind due to this sudden tech shift.
E = Economy = How did this affect our economy?
Positive: Some sectors like digital payments, e-commerce, pharma, and online services grew a lot during this time. Negative: But overall, it was a disaster — job losses, salary cuts, and small businesses shut down. The economic gap became worse.
R = Religion = In this, how does it affect our religious beliefs etc.
Positive: Many people turned more spiritual. Prayers and online religious gatherings became more common, and people started reflecting on life.
Negative: But also, many religious gatherings became super-spreader events, and that created tension between different belief groups.
The next rule, named POPBEANS, is for abstract topics. I am going to explain it with a topic named: Black
P = People = Talk about how “black” is connected to people, their identity, or image.
Positive: Black is a powerful color in fashion — it’s classy, confident, and suits everyone. Negative: Black skin tone has faced discrimination in many parts of the world.
O = Object = Think of black as a color in objects around us.
Positive: Black-colored objects like cars, phones, or clothes look sleek, modern, and elegant. Negative: Black objects, especially in the dark, can be hard to see and cause accidents.
P = Place = Imagine places associated with the color black.
Positive: “Black Forest” in Germany is a beautiful tourist destination known for its mystery and charm. Negative: Places like coal mines or areas with oil spills are dark and dangerous, often linked with blackness.
B = Behaviour = Relate black to human emotions or behavior.
Positive: “Black” can reflect strength and seriousness in behavior — like being bold and fearless. Negative: At the same time, people say “black mind” when someone show happiness on his/her face but is cursing you from inside.
E = Events = Link black with events, whether social or historic.
Positive: “Black Friday” is a shopping event everyone waits for — sales, discounts, happiness.
Negative: But events like “Black Day” are marked for tragedies and sad incidents in history.
A = Actions = Think how “black” can be linked to different actions.
Positive: Wearing black in formal events shows respect and discipline.
Negative: “Blackmailing” is a criminal act, and it’s also derived from this word “black.”
N = Nature = Observe how black appears in natural elements.
Positive: Black night sky full of stars is peaceful and calm, perfect for thinking or dreaming.
Negative: Volcanic ash, dark smoke, or polluted rivers look black and are harmful signs in nature.
S = Society = How does society view or use the color black?
Positive: In many cultures, black is worn during prayers, mourning, or peaceful protests — it shows respect.
Negative: But still, in some parts of society, black is wrongly connected with bad luck or evil.