In today’s class, we learned psychometric analysis. We were separated into multiple groups of 8–9 students and were given a small case. We had to present our opinions and try to convince the other members of the group to accept them. This was truly the beginning of understanding psychometric analysis — where we not only defend our own points but also face counterpoints from others.
The case given to us was:
There is a coal mine situated near a river. Due to a blast, the wall close to the river broke and water started entering the mine. Most people escaped, but only four were left:
A child, 6 years old, 22 kg
A lady from the Council of Research and Development in India, on a one-day visit to the mine. She is asthmatic, unmarried, a graduate, 26 years old, 52 kg
A mad scientist, who was isolated in the company for 30+ years. He is 78 years old, smart, unmarried, weighs 55 kg
The owner of the mine, 58 years old, intelligent, handsome, 59 kg
There is only one electric lift, which can carry 60 kg at a time, and takes 2 minutes to go up and 2 minutes to come down. The total time to flood the mine completely is 10 minutes.
So we had to decide which 3 people to save, and who to leave behind.
💡 My Opinion:
Order of rescue:
Child
Lady
Scientist
Owner stays behind
✅ Reason 1: Save the Child first
The child is very light (22 kg), so the lift can take him up quickly.
He is physically and mentally weak, and might panic or cause disruption while others are being rescued.
Due to his short height, rising water or gas may affect him faster.
Counterpoint:
Other adults can simply hold the child on their shoulders to keep him above water/gas for some time.
My response:
That may work temporarily, but it still wastes time and energy, and doesn't reduce the risk if the water fills fast or panic spreads. Saving the child first is efficient and safest.
✅ Reason 2: Save the Lady second
She is a research professional — her insights and report about the visit might help improve safety in future.
Her knowledge and position are valuable to society.
Counterpoint:
She has asthma, but she might survive for 3–4 more minutes after using her inhaler. Also, she can send her notes/documents with the child, so her work is still saved.
My response:
Even with an inhaler, asthma attacks in flooded, high-pressure environments can be life-threatening. Also, her first-hand testimony is more important than written reports. A report without a witness may not hold the same value.
✅ Reason 3: Save the Scientist third
Despite his age, he is intelligent and has deep knowledge of the mine.
He might know what caused the collapse and can help prevent such disasters in future.
Counterpoint (Your version):
If he knew the wall was weak and didn’t warn anyone, isn’t that irresponsible?
Also, he has been isolated for so long, he may not even cooperate after coming out.
Improved counter:
✔ True — if the scientist is mentally unstable or has been completely cut off from communication, there’s a risk he won’t share useful information.
✔ But saving him is still a calculated risk — the potential benefit is high, and at 55 kg, he fits in the lift.
✅ Reason to leave the Owner behind
He is the most physically capable, so he can survive longer if anyone can.
It’s his company, and as a leader, it’s morally right for him to let others go first.
He doesn’t offer any unique skill or critical knowledge compared to the others.
Counterpoint:
But he is intelligent and experienced. If he survives, he can take responsibility and improve safety, train workers, and maybe compensate families of those affected.
My response:
That’s true, but those tasks can also be done by delegation. In this moment, saving those with weaker survival chances or unique knowledge should come first. The owner might accept this responsibility willingly.