How We Research
We compare products from their published specs and features; the verdicts below are our independent editorial opinions.
Updated: 2026-09-24 · 6 min read · Independent comparison
If you want a genuine air-frying upgrade for a Breville Smart Oven you already own, choose Allstare Air Fryer Basket; if you need to protect a countertop air fryer oven from dust, grease and pet hair while it sits idle, choose GWYSY Toaster Oven Air.
• Allstare Air Fryer Basket — biggest strength: two 14 x 11.5 inch 304 stainless steel mesh trays built specifically for Breville Smart Oven models BOV800XL, BOV810BSS and BOV845BSS.
• Allstare Air Fryer Basket — biggest trade-off: it is a replacement part, not an appliance. It only makes sense if you already own one of the compatible Breville ovens and want crisp results instead of soggy ones.
• GWYSY Toaster Oven Air — biggest strength: a 600D nylon cover with reinforced stitching that keeps dust, oil, steam and pet hair off a countertop oven between cooks.
• GWYSY Toaster Oven Air — biggest trade-off: it protects your oven but does nothing for cooking. It is also sized around specific machines, so measuring matters.
• Who each pick is for: Allstare for Breville Smart Oven owners chasing crispier chicken wings, fries and vegetables; GWYSY for anyone whose air fryer oven lives on the counter and collects grime.
This is a two-piece set of mesh air fry baskets measuring 14 inches long by 11.5 inches wide by 1 inch tall, made from 304 stainless steel. The design is the whole point: an open mesh grid lets hot air circulate around and underneath the food, which is exactly what separates air frying from plain oven roasting. On a solid baking pan, the underside of a chicken wing steams in its own juices. On a raised mesh tray, the heat gets underneath it and the skin crisps.
The material choice matters too. 304 stainless steel is food-grade and built to take oven heat without warping or rusting — the kind of thing that outlasts the flimsier coated racks that come with cheaper accessories. Each basket weighs a little over two pounds, so there is real metal here rather than a flimsy insert that bends the first time you load it up.
Who should buy it? Anyone who owns a Breville Smart Oven in the BOV800XL, BOV810BSS or BOV845BSS family and wants that appliance to actually air fry. The trays handle meat, pizza, cookies and vegetables, and they are the reason you would bother buying a dedicated basket instead of using the pan that came in the box. Cleaning is straightforward: a soak in hot water with dish soap loosens most residue, and a scouring pad handles the stubborn spots.
GWYSY Toaster Oven Air: Who It's For
This is a cover, not a cooking accessory, and it is worth being clear about that up front. The GWYSY Toaster Oven Air is a 600D nylon dust cover sized for the Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro BOV900BSS, and it is listed as compatible with the Nuwave Bravo XL Pro 30QT, COSORI 12-in-1 and 13-in-1 air fryer oven combos. It weighs just over three ounces, comes in black, and uses reinforced stitching and sewn seams so it holds up to repeated handling.
The case for it is simple and a little unglamorous. Countertop ovens sit out all day. They collect kitchen steam, airborne grease, dust and — if you have pets — a steady supply of hair. Left uncovered between uses, that buildup slowly coats the exterior and works its way into vents and crevices. A wipe-down cover stops most of that before it starts.
The practical details are decent. There is a handle strap so you can lift it off quickly, and the open bottom means it drapes over the machine rather than needing to be threaded on. It folds flat when not in use, which matters in a kitchen where counter space is already contested. Cleaning is either a damp cloth for spot work or a full trip through the washing machine, and the nylon is designed to keep its shape through repeated washes. The material is described as BPA-free and non-toxic.
Who should buy it? Anyone whose air fryer oven sits on an open counter, especially in a household with pets or one that does a lot of frying. Who should skip it? If your oven lives in a cabinet, or you use it daily and would find a cover annoying, pass. And check the listed dimensions against your specific model — the compatibility list is a starting point, not a guarantee, and the listing itself flags that other models need a size check.
Side-by-Side: Which Should You Choose?
• Best for protecting your appliance between cooks → GWYSY Toaster Oven Air. Dust, grease, steam and pet hair are exactly what it is built to block.
• Best if you own a Breville BOV800XL, BOV810BSS or BOV845BSS → Allstare Air Fryer Basket. Those are the models it is made for.
• Best if you own a Breville BOV900BSS, Nuwave Bravo XL Pro 30QT, or a COSORI 12-in-1 / 13-in-1 → GWYSY Toaster Oven Air. It is sized for those machines.
• Best for durability under heat → Allstare Air Fryer Basket. Solid 304 stainless steel is designed to handle high oven temperatures without melting or bending.
• Best for easy upkeep → both, in different ways. The baskets want a hot-water soak; the cover wants a damp cloth or a washing machine cycle.
• Best for a renter or small kitchen → GWYSY Toaster Oven Air. It folds flat and takes up essentially no space when not in use.
• Best for gifting to a home cook → Allstare Air Fryer Basket, but only if you know their exact oven model. A cover is the safer gift when you don't.
In my opinion, these two products are not really competing — they solve different problems, and the honest answer is that the right pick depends entirely on what you are missing. If your Breville Smart Oven is producing limp fries and pale wings, the Allstare baskets are the fix, and I would buy those without hesitation. If your oven already cooks well but looks grimy and sits out all day, the GWYSY cover is the smarter buy. Forced to pick one for the typical shopper, I would take the Allstare Air Fryer Basket, because it changes what your oven can do rather than just how it looks.
FAQ
It is a replacement accessory — two 304 stainless steel mesh trays, 14 x 11.5 inches each. You need a compatible Breville Smart Oven already. Check your model number against BOV800XL, BOV810BSS and BOV845BSS before buying.
They are not comparable purchases. One is a cooking accessory that improves results; the other is a protective cover. Decide which gap you actually have, then check the current price on Amazon for that item.
304 stainless steel is chosen specifically because it resists rust and handles high oven heat without deforming. It is heavier than typical coated racks, which is part of why it holds up. Clean it promptly and it should stay in good shape.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
We are a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites.
When you buy through links on this page, we may earn a commission from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you.
Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon or its affiliates. This site is an independent third-party review and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Amazon or the product brands mentioned.
See also: Plum chef Multifunctional Convection Toaster vs Beelicious Pro 28QT, GXF Air Fryer Cooking vs GCQFZ Toaster Oven Replacement, OPENICE Air Fryer Basket vs Leonyo 11.8x9IN: Air Fryer Fried