This study examines complementor response to competition with the platform owner. We account for the existence of complementors’ outside option of repositioning to a competing platform, and we argue that generalists experience low repositioning cost and are more likely to shift effort to a competing platform, while specialists focus on the focal platform. We examine Apple’s “Files” app entry and find support for our hypotheses. Contrasting Apple’s entry with that of other non-platform large firms, we find that only the platform owner elicits a strong complementor response, highlighting unique characteristics of platform owner as competitor. This paper contributes to the competitive and corporate strategy literatures, underscoring how complementor heterogeneity affects cross-platform allocation of effort when the platform owner becomes a competitor in complementor spaces.
This study investigates the use of a prevalent but rarely studied form of intellectual property protection: trade secrecy. Building on existing survey evidence of firm-level, cross-sectional use of secrecy, we document the effect of stronger legal protections for trade secrets on the project-level use of such secrets. Our setting is the U.S. oil and gas hydraulic fracturing industry, from 2014 to 2018, in states where firms are required to disclose fracturing fluid ingredients to regulators except for substantiated claims of trade secrets. We examine how the enactment of the federal 2016 Defend Trade Secrets Act (DTSA) affects well-level trade secret use across states with varying levels of pre-DTSA protection. We find substantial increases in the use and novelty of trade secrets. Further, wells with trade secret ingredients are, on average, more productive. However, the DTSA exerts limited additional effect on trade secret–related productivity. Supplementary tests address alternative explanations, show no evidence of intellectual property substitution, and provide additional support that we are capturing policy effects. Our results provide rare empirical evidence on actual trade secret use and enhance our understanding of how appropriability shapes use of trade secrets and associated inventive activity.
This study examines how multi-business firms redeploy resources following an industry shock. Using the case of oil & gas firms diversified into wind power, I show that firms reduced expenditure in oil & gas—particularly on complex offshore projects—while increasing investment in wind after the 2014 oil price crash. These investments tended to involve newer, more powerful technologies (turbines) when co-located with existing offshore oil & gas assets. The study provides detailed empirical evidence of resource redeployment and documents conditions under which firms shifted away from one industry and pursued more demanding projects in another. The findings underscore the role of asset colocation in shaping redeployment patterns. They also highlight that market-based inducements may not be sufficient in driving the energy transition.
Digitization has enabled modern firms to expand at unprecedented rates. Prior research has highlighted the role of digital platforms in facilitating mass-market expansions by resolving frictions associated with market entry. Accordingly, various studies have emphasized the positive impact of market friction reduction on aggregate market size and efficiency. In this paper, we argue that the extreme resolution of frictions may also have a downside: it can nudge platform participants to overlook the heterogeneous nature of different markets and, consequently, to engage in large-scale, potentially myopic marketexpansions. These expansions, in turn, may engender lower customer satisfaction and firm performance.We test our arguments in the context of Apple’s App Store. We find that apps that undergo rapid, large-scale market expansions, relative to apps that do not expand or expand more gradually, see a short-run increase in client base but longer-run declines in ratings, downloads, financial performance, and innovation.
In this chapter, we look at how business secrets, which include but are not limited to trade secrets and sensitive information, can create value to organisations, and we also look at how they increase value for them. We consider both monetary and non-monetary benefits. We consider the forms of business secrets that create value, and how organisations can identify and manage them. We provide some example approaches for organisations to develop valuations for IP assets, including business secrets. Finally, we also consider the associated downsides of business secrets—the associated costs to maintain, and potential costs of loss.
Artificial intelligence (AI) makes it easier than ever to produce research outputs. The pressing question is how researchers should organize their work with this technology. The question is not new: software engineering and security research have long studied how teams of people and machines keep control of a shared body of work with many contributors. We distill principles from the practices these literatures report and transpose them to AI-assisted research. The principles form TRACE: Track records, Review against sources, Accept independently, Control transitions, and Evaluate corrections. Together, the five principles give researchers a common basis for remaining in control while integrating AI into their workflows. By bounding units of work and attending to how each is shaped, they help researchers pace AI-assisted work to human attention rather than to the speed at which AI produces content. We also introduce TRACE-OS, an open source operating system for AI-assisted research projects. It puts the principles into practice through shared instructions, tools, and records that fit researchers' existing workflows. The shared standard can contribute to building trust, which allows teams to delegate and realize the productivity that AI promises. More broadly, we aim to open a conversation about the governing principles through which the research community can benefit from AI.
Artificial intelligence challenges a premise of intellectual property: humans create valuable inventions and receive the associated IP rights. We examine how firms adjust value-capture strategies when reliance on AI in the invention process complicates the attribution of inventorship to human inventors. We exploit the U.S. Federal Circuit’s 2022 decision holding that an AI system cannot be a named patent inventor. Our analysis shows that, after the decision and relative to other firms, firms with high pre-shock AI exposure reduced their AI-citing patent applications. Among publicly listed firms, R&D expenditure showed no detectable relative decline, while AI-related and overall job postings increased. The study identifies attribution as a driver of appropriability strategy, showing how AI can affect value capture through firms’ disclosure choices.
We study the link between intangible resources and their application in the product market. The resource-based view in strategic management posits that rarer and more difficult to imitate resources enable superior performance, but embedding such resources in commercialized products may be difficult due to the leap in technological application they require. We find that more incremental, less novel intangible resources (patents) are more likely to be embedded in products. We also show that an exogenous change in the disclosure environment, shifting incentives from “first to invent” to “first inventor to file” is associated with a reduction in the scope of patents, consistent with the interpretation that firms “rush to the patent office”: following this environmental change, products contain less novel patents, on average. Thus, this paper provides rare evidence on the actual commercial use of patents in products and how patent and environmental characteristics translate into product market innovation.
Trade secret licensing can generate substantial private and societal benefits, yet risks detrimental information leakage. While prior work typically assumes leakage risk prevents such transactions, we examine how mechanisms that mitigate such risk can enable firms to “rent” trade secrets. Using contract-level data on patent licenses, we exploit the adoption of the Uniform Trade Secrets Act (UTSA) across U.S. states as an exogenous reduction in leakage risk. Stronger UTSA protection leads to a substantial increase in trade secret licensing. We further document that firms increase trade secret licensing most in the deals where leakage risk is otherwise highest: non-exclusive deals, those without additional registered intellectual property, and those spanning greater geographic distance. Further, we distinguish technology and commercial trade secrets, and find licensing increases most in commercial trade secret deals. These findings highlight how firms navigate information sharing transactions in leakage-prone settings and demonstrate that markets for technology are richer and more complex than previously assumed in the patent-focused literature.
Why do some firms innovate during industry downturns? While prior literature highlights the role of market exit and resource reallocation in enhancing productivity during recessions—the so-called “cleansing effect”—this paper offers a novel mechanism linking industry shocks, resource reallocation, and firm-level innovation. We argue that downturns free up constrained complementary resources, thereby enabling firms to reorganize and innovate when previously limited by input bottlenecks. We exploit the 2014 oil price crash and examine the U.S. onshore oil-producing firms’ outcomes in Texas between 2010 to 2017. We document a widespread contraction, firm exit, and resource reallocation—specifically land—but also substantial within-firm resource redeployment. We find that productivity gains were concentrated among surviving firms in congested areas, where freed-up land leases allowed for more efficient, technologically advanced horizontal drilling. These effects were not observed in previously less congested regions. Our findings highlight the importance of input complementarity in enabling innovation during downturns. We contribute to strategic management by providing evidence for how industry-level reallocation and firm-level redeployment drive innovation by alleviating structural input bottlenecks that had previously limited firms’ ability to innovate and improve productivity.