Working papers:


Childhood Learning and Adult Earnings in Four LMIC Cohorts 

Das, J., Dhuldhoya , Y., Favara, M., Gethin, A., Sánchez, A., Singh, A.


Researchers and policymakers in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs) have customarily relied on indirect evidence to justify investments in learning, either by linking test scores to economic growth or by connecting adult cognitive assessments to earnings. This reliance on indirect evidence largely stems from the scarcity of longitudinal data linking school-age learning to adult earnings. We address this gap by using data from Ethiopia, India, Pakistan, and Peru to estimate associations between foundational learning (FL), measured by test scores around age 12, and human capital and earnings in young adulthood. In Peru, India, and Pakistan, a one-standard-deviation increase in FL is associated with an 8-13 log point increase in adult earnings. Childhood scores also predict 1.1-1.5 additional years of schooling and 9.3-13.5 percentage points higher college or vocational attendance, as well as higher skills in adulthood. Interestingly, a linear-projection decomposition indicates that measured schooling and adult test scores explain between 18% (Peru) to 50-56% (India and Pakistan) of the FL-earnings gradient, suggesting that FL may raise earnings over and above the association with schooling and adult scores. Finally, FL can account for about 5-12 percent of the earnings gap between young Ethiopians and Indians in our sample, a number that could rise to 33 percent as returns to learning grow over the life cycle. We interpret these descriptive findings in light of recent causal evidence on the learning-to-earnings pipeline and discuss the implications for policy investments in FL. 


The Impact of a Growth-Mindset Intervention on Academic Achievement in Peru 

Outes, I., Sánchez, A., Vakis, R. [early draft]


This paper evaluates the academic impact of a growth-mind set intervention on students starting the secondary level in public schools in urban Peru. ¡Expande tu Mente! is a 90-minute school session aimed at instilling the notion that a person´s own intelligence is malleable. Students in schools randomly assigned to treatment showed a small improvement in math test scores and educational expectations, with a large and sustained impact in test scores among students outside the capital city. At a cost of $0.20 per pupil, ¡Expande tu Mente! was highly cost-effective. The results show the potential that brief growth-mindset interventions have for developing countries. 


Stratification of Returns to Higher Education in Peru: The Role of Education Quality and Major Choices

Sánchez, A., Favara, M., Porter, C. 


In the last two decades, access to higher education has increased substantially in Latin America. The quantity of new programs available has created concerns about education quality, which has implications for the labor market. We use rich longitudinal data from a Peruvian cohort tracked from ages 8 to 26 (the Young Lives study) to analyze the profile of students enrolled in different ‘types’ of higher education, and to explore the returns to higher education before and during the COVID-19 crisis. We find evidence of stratification at higher education level: (a) students from the wealthiest households tend to enroll in universities (as opposed to technical institutes), and choose majors and institutions with the highest income rewards; (b) students with higher levels of cognitive skills and socio emotional competencies tend to attend better quality universities; (c) there are hidden gender gaps: females are more likely to enroll in majors that are the least rewarded in the labor market. In the 2020 labor market, by age 26 we find that: (d) pre-COVID, positive returns to higher education are only observable for those that attended better quality universities; (e) during the pandemic, higher education became a protective factor, with the income premium being higher for everyone that attended this education level; (f) the male income premium doubled during the pandemic 


The Impact of the JUNTOS Conditional Cash Transfer Programme on Foundational Cognitive Skills: Does Age of Enrollment Matter?  

Scott, D., Lopez, J., Sánchez, A. & Behrman, J. 


We examine how age at initial exposure to Peru’s conditional cash transfer program, JUNTOS, impacts foundational cognitive skills. Our results show that children exposed to the program when relatively younger display significant improvements in tablet-based test scores for inhibitory control (0.14 standard deviations) and working memory (0.19 standard deviations), compared to those first benefiting when older. We do not find evidence that the timing of program enrollment effects long-term memory or implicit learning. We then employ sequential g-estimation to demonstrate that 24.6% of the relative improvement in inhibitory control is mediated by changes in the probability of timely entry into primary school, a key requirement of many conditional cash transfer programs.


Life-Course Shocks and Food Insecurity: Longitudinal Evidence from Ethiopia, India, and Peru

Favara, M., Quigua, J., Sánchez, A.


This study investigates the relationship between life-cycle exposure to socioeconomic shocks and subsequent food insecurity in young adult households. Using two decades of longitudinal data (2002-2023) from the Young Lives study in Ethiopia, India, and Peru, we analyse how the timing of shocks influences current household food security. Our findings consistently demonstrate a significant association between recent shock exposure and food insecurity in 2023 across all countries. Crucially, in Ethiopia, exposure to shocks dating back more than a decade, as well as shocks that occurred between 2020 and 2021, are significantly associated with current food insecurity, the first highlighting the long-term, cumulative nature of food insecurity in this country, the second pointing to the persistent detrimental effects of the COVID-19 pandemic and the armed conflict in this country. Weather-related events, illness or death of a family member, and loss of income or purchasing power all correlate with increased food insecurity, even after controlling for correlations between shocks. Overall, our findings emphasize the importance of social assistance following exposure to shocks and of a life-cycle perspective when formulating policy responses to mitigate persistent food insecurity. 


Other ongoing projects:


Long-term Impacts and Sustainability of a Secondary-Level Comprehensive Public School Reform in Peru

Campos, A, Favara, M., Sánchez, A. 


Sibling Spillover Effects in Education: Evidence From an Extended School-day Reform in Peru

McQuade, G., Porter, C., Sánchez, A. 


Conditional Cash Transfers in Childhood and Outcomes in Early Adulthood: Evidence from Peru

Woodman, A., Espinoza, D., Sánchez, A. 


Who Stays Silent? Psychosocial Traits and Non-Response to Sensitive Survey Questions in India

Tanima, T., Favara, M., Sánchez, A. 


Does Preschool Attendance Predict Foundational Cognitive Skills During Adolescence? Evidence from Ethiopia and Peru 

Lopez, J., Behrman, J., Cueto, S., Sánchez, A.