Going Beyond the Room
A challenge for psychonauts
Whether you got here by clicking the little cat or through a link from your pyschonaut community, you are on the right page.
The question posed here is: Is it possible to experience something beyond the familiar boundaries of subjective experience? And if so, how could you ever know?
The BAL-looping framework approaches these questions through a distinction between baseline experience and looped subjective experience.
The following selections from Dialog 2.5: Beyond the Room – Animal Minds and the Looping Prestige Error introduce this distinction and a curious problem that arises from it.
Excerpts from the dialogue, beginning with a statement by Haplous:
“We begin at the end of subjective experience and ask: when do we have it? Do we have it continuously?”
Synergos considered. “According to the framework, we do not. We have it only through looping, and we are not looping all the time. Looping is a cognitive tool the brain uses to build recollections, to imagine something, to create a fantasy, or to perceive the world in a looping-enhanced way, through conscious attention to vision, hearing, touch, or any other sense. Otherwise, it makes sense that the BAL would give it a rest when it was not needed, and from my own introspection I sense it is not operating at all times.”
“Very good. And when we are not looping, how is our experience?”
“It is unlooped, baseline experience, like that of the other systems we were discussing – paramecia, C. elegans, fish, cats, and so on, provided they are not looping.”
...
“Sure, and I will use a metaphor. Let’s say that the whole operation within the BAL is like a house, and the content from the PTD constitutes something akin to one room of that house.”
Synergos shifted on his bench. “OK, that is clear; one house, with the looping room as one part of it.”
“The PTD looping room is where everything we can name, recall, and report takes place. When ‘you’ are in that room, the BAL is attending to the semantically formatted activity of the PTD. And this room has a special significance, because the PTD is what we speak with, what we listen with, what we write with, and what we read with. It is also what we recall things with and imagine things with. It supplies the semantic formatting characteristic of our subjective experience.”
The monastery cat was on its back among the clover, batting at a tassel of clover above it, as Synergos leaned forward with a very intent look on his face.
Synergos paused, and then the words came slowly: “And when we leave that room, what do we experience?”
Haplous sat serenely for a moment, his face infused with a warm glow from the afternoon sun. “We must still be careful with the word ‘we,’ but ‘experience’ is exactly the broader word we need. Outside the room, the BAL still experiences whatever content it attends to. What is absent is the looped formatting that characterizes subjective experience.”
Synergos nodded. “Point taken.”
Haplous continued, “But that does not mean the BAL disappears when the room is inactive. The BAL is the whole house, and it can attend to unlooped sensory content outside the room.”
Synergos frowned. “So when people say ‘I,’ they often identify themselves with the activity in the looping room, because that is the part they can recall and report. But in the more inclusive and technically accurate sense, the experiencer is the BAL as a whole?”
“Exactly. You are not merely the room. You are your BAL.”
Synergos leaned forward. “So I am the whole house.”
“That’s it. The room has a special role because it is where content is looped and semantically formatted, but it is only one part of the house.”
...
“Yes, exactly. Now suppose I asked you, just after a period of baseline experience, what your experience had been like. How would you be able to tell me?”
“I would have to recall it, of course, even if it had occurred only a few seconds earlier.”
“And in the framework, how do we recall something?”
Synergos considered. “We use the PTD to begin producing incipient expressions about it. The BAL works through a process called the naïve archeologist method, drawing on functional traces from multiple sources and normally achieving practical fidelity with what we were objectively doing just then. The principle that assures this close fidelity is called interfunctional complementation. The result is a reconstruction we can rely on for practical purposes as an account of the experience occurring in those previous moments or minutes.”
“But you said that we are not always looping...”
A look of sudden realization came to Synergos’s expression. “Ah! I see your point. After a period without looping, recollection nevertheless produces its result in the format of looping, because the recollection itself is looped. So, through recollection, all experience – even unlooped experience – necessarily appears as looped experience.”
“Exactly,” Haplous said in agreement. “In fact, I am presently writing a BAL-looping glossary in which this principle appears under the heading ‘Looping Indeterminacy Principle.’”
“So wait a minute. Looking back, we seem to have no way of knowing at what times we were looping, and at what times we were not?”
...
“There are at least two reasons,” Haplous replied. “The first follows straight from what we have just been discussing. Whenever we look back upon some span of time in our experience, we do so through recollection, and we carry out the process of recollection through looping. So even experience that was originally unlooped winds up in our recollection as looped content. Therefore, whenever we look in the rearview mirror, so to speak, looped experience seems to be everywhere. This makes it appear as though it is all that we ever do.”
“I see. Baseline experience leaves traces, but when those traces are taken as evidence by the naïve archeologist operation, they result in content that has the format of subjective experience.”
“Exactly. Looping therefore enjoys a kind of retrospective monopoly. It supplies not only the subjective experience we have while looping, but also the only form in which our unlooped experience can later be recalled.”
...
“OK, let’s do that. Suppose you have just passed through a period of unlooped experience, and I ask you to recall what you were doing. As you recall it, your PTD activates the same neuronal proxies that were active in the unlooped experience, but now activates them through the semantic formatting characteristic of looping, because semantic formatting is the first step in the PTD loop. Now compare this subjective experience with the previous unlooped experience. How are they different?”
“Well, how could I say with certainty? Have I ever recalled unlooped experience except through looping? I cannot recall it without looping, and I cannot examine it analytically while it is happening, because the act of doing so would itself engage looping. So how could I know what it was like?”
“Yes, you see it clearly, that is the point,” Haplous observed. “And if you cannot make that direct comparison within yourself, how could you know what a cat’s unlooped experience is like?”
...
“Precisely. In our social life, the PTD plays a massive role, and in our private, subjective experience, it is literally the ‘without-which-nothing.’ This is true. The mistake is to infer from its privileged position that it is the whole of experience, or the whole of the experiencer. It is the room in which the BAL reads, writes, remembers, and speaks. But the privilege of that particular room does not make it the entire house, nor is it necessarily the most important room, nor should we unreflectively consider it the without-which-nothing of our existence.”
...
As they began their walk toward the chapel, Synergos looked ahead and saw the cat there along its side wall, sniffing among some stalks of grass. “I think I understand, Haplous. I am the house. The room is just where I write the letters.”
Haplous nodded. “And once you know that, the letters become much more interesting.”
The Challenge
Can you go beyond the room, beyond looping, and return with a recollection of what you experienced?
This question could serve the same sort of purpose as a Buddhist koan. Succeeding or failing is not the point. The point is to try, and in doing so, to discover insights that cannot be taught in words.
But there is a practical purpose as well. The BAL-looping framework is a scientific model, and your observations could be useful data for it. The question of how recollection is constructed is elusive due to priors – our own preconceived impressions of how it works – and a psychonaut can examine the question free of these priors.
Working with this challenge may bring you insights you can share with others in your psychonaut community who are in contact with the BAL-looping project. Such observations could help refine the framework's understanding of the relationship between baseline and looped experience.
It's a way to expand your mind and contribute to science at the same time.