Barriers

Drawings are made by individuals from a range of disciplines, including the visual arts, design, engineering, architecture, science and beyond. Though often associated with artistic creativity, drawing is an important instrument for problem solving in design, science, and engineering (Cicalò, 2017). Despite advancements in digitally networked technologies that can provide perceptual cues across a variety of sensory modalities, blind and and partially sighted (BPSI) learners still lack an effective drawing tool that could foster their inclusion in the many disciplines and activities where drawing is required.



Sketch of a hand holding a pencil to draw

Perceiving Drawings Non Visually

Raised line graphics are a common technique used to make graphics or drawings accessible for BPSI. Schiafone et al. found that most raised-line graphics in STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, Math) textbooks follow visual cues of their source images, such as perspective foreshortening, to convey depth, or textures to convey shadows, even though those lines are presented haptically, although some studies claim that raised line perspective views are useful with training (Heller et.al, 2005). Han (2020) reported how visually impaired (VI) participants found these raised line graphic representations of objects difficult or impossible to comprehend, engendering recognition errors, more so when they lacked visual experience (even with training). In contrast it was found that 3D models are much easier to comprehend.




Image of a visually impaired participant exploring a raised line graphic of an umbrella through touch

Image of visually impaired participant exploring raised line drawing of umbrella

Context For Project

Research and development focused on digital multi-sensory feedback tools for BPSD is ongoing but only a few commercial solutions are available. An effective digital drawing tool for blind users would increase collaboration between BPSI and sighted users and offer a means for BPSD to convey their perspectives, thus informing the design of educational materials for blind and partially sighted learners.


Despite research and development efforts focused on drawing tools for blind and partially sighted learners, access and representation in education and industry is still limited. The National Federation of Blind estimates that in 2015, 42 percent of Blind and Partially Sighted Individuals are in the workforce, however less than 15 percent have earned a bachelor’s degree and more than a quarter did not finish high school (Blindness Statistics | National Federation of the Blind, 2019). Although multi-sensory feedback components such as audio and haptic elements have been explored to a certain extent, research conducted in this area is still limited.



Image of a raised line drawing of an umbrella drawn by VI participant using Sketchpad

Raised line drawing of umbrella created by VI participant using Sketchpad

Graphic of 3D pyramid construction and pencil drawing of a triangle

Graphic of 3D construction of pyramid and drawing of triangle