We have NINE(!) cats of our own. Yes... we know that's a lot. Shit happens and they make us happy. They are all wonderful in their own way and each has their own unique rescue story. In order of adoption:
PRINCESS was found in the Bronx in October 2011 when Louis worked on Zerega Ave. She was friendly and let her people feed and pick her up. On the way over the Whitestone Bridge she escaped the box she was in, climbed over the seat, and decided to sit on Louis' arm (mid-way over the bridge)!
Instagram: @lotito_cat_squad
ZELDA was found across the street from the parking entrance to the Sky View mall in Downtown Flushing in August of 2014. To us, she was the first for many things. Our first young kitten under 8 weeks old. And our first experience with ringworm... :-\
Instagram: @lotito_cat_squad
LINK was living in our backyard, before we began TNR, and was caught in February of 2015. He was the oldest kitten we have ever caught, at about 3 months old, and socializing him took time. He has come a long way.
Instagram: @lotito_cat_squad
BLUE was the only male kitten in our first rescued litter, the Raptor Squad, born in April 2016. After watching them grow, Blue made his way into our home and became cat #4.
Instagram: @lotito_cat_squad
FLOOF was 3+ months old when he was found by locals in College Point, NY in November of 2016. They were not able to keep him and posted a blurry picture of him on the College Point Facebook community where it was spotted by TNR Utopia. Once we realized this little boy was a fluffy it quickly became apparent that he wasn't going anywhere.
Instagram: @lotito_cat_squad
DELTA is Blue's sister, one of the three girls in the Raptor Squad litter. She returned to TNR Utopia after her adopter suffered from bad allergies. Since she was already older we quickly integrated her into our home while she remained "up for adoption". A few months later we removed her from our adoption page. Delta was here to say as cat #6.
Instagram: @lotito_cat_squad
JASPER came to TNR Utopia on March 27, 2018 with his sister. He was 6.5 years old at the time and needed our help in finding a new forever home. Jasper is a super smart cat who does what he wants. He will nip if you pet him in the wrong place or if you don't open his can of cat food fast enough. And touching his paws to cut his nails, forget about it! After being avaiable for adoption for 650 days Jasper finally found someone to give him a chance. We cried and cried as we had come to love Jasper and had even integrated Jasper into our home. Unfortunately Jasper was returned to TNR Utopia 6 weeks later. It was clear that Jasper's place was with us. In January 2020 Louis signed the adoption contract and Jasper became #7.
Instagram: @jaspers.way, @lotito_cat_squad
ZIGGY was rescued by @nycpetnanny in May 2020 as a very young kitten during the hight of the COVID-19 pandemic. He was not doing well and needed intensive supportive care. We were all home and had the time so Michelle took on the challenge. The bond between Ziggy and Michelle only continued to grow making him #8.
Instagram: @lotito_cat_squad
KIRA was rescued on June 23, 2023 in Flushing, Queens. She was suffering from very severe eye infections which ended up requiring the complete removeal of both her eyes. KIRA is blind. The broken ones, and the ones who we care for the most and the longest, are always the hardest to say goodbye to and, just like that, KIRA became cat number 10. You can see more photos of KIRA and more about her story on her Instagram account @kiraseestheworld.
- 11/04/2025
🌈 In Loving Memory of Stubby
Stubby was one of the very first cats we trapped when TNR Utopia began in 2016. He was an orange tabby with an ear tip and a short, stubby tail — the feature that gave him his name. From the beginning, he had a calm, steady presence that made him unforgettable.
For years, Stubby lived in our backyard — a true feral community cat who kept his distance but always stayed close. Over time, he began to trust us, especially Michelle, who spent countless afternoons sitting outside with him. Their bond grew quietly, built on patience, consistency, and care.
Then, in December 2021, Stubby went missing — something he never did. After nearly a full day of searching and worry, we received a message from Irene, a community cat caregiver down the block. She mentioned that a “kitten” had appeared on her porch and seemed friendly.
When Michelle went to check, carrier in hand, she walked through Irene’s house and came face-to-face with an ear-tipped orange cat looking back through the glass door — it was Stubby. (He was no kitten.)
Irene was actually Stubby’s original caretaker, from before he moved into our yard in 2016. She used to call him Morris and still feeds his four TNR’d children in her yard. Without hesitation, Michelle gently placed Stubby into the small carrier and brought him home.
That day marked the beginning of Stubby’s next chapter. He had lost weight and slowed down, but he was ready — or maybe he decided it was time — to come inside. After a full vet check-up, he was diagnosed with diabetes. From then on, Stubby received insulin injections twice daily, every 12 hours, without fail.
Even indoors, Stubby remained a feral cat at heart. We were never able to pet or hold him; he allowed touch only during feeding, when we’d give his insulin as he eagerly awaited his meal. He was wonderfully food motivated — and those shared moments became the quiet rhythm of our lives together.
To gain the trust of a feral cat is to know unconditional love. It’s a bond not built on touch, but on presence — on showing up, every day, in the ways they allow. Stubby gave us that gift.
He taught us devotion, patience, and what it truly means to care for another being — not by changing them, but by loving them as they are.
Stubby will always be part of TNR Utopia’s story — one of the first, one of the most special, and one of the most loved. 💛
07/25/2018 - 01/27/2019
Never did I think I would be writing this and this is very hard for me to share. Misty died suddenly and unexpectedly on the evening of Sunday, January 27. We don’t know what happened. She was happy and fine that morning and afternoon. When we found her body she was already gone. She was a very special kitten who taught us so much.
We are better because Misty was in our lives, even if it was only for six short months. Misty, who so valiantly fought the odds, enriched the lives of those who met her, even when she wasn’t especially nice to new people! 😆 Misty taught us to live in the moment, to play hard and to sleep harder, to soak up the sun at every opportunity, to hold your ground and to overcome your obstacles because that’s what we are all meant to do in life.
Michelle, Sharon and I want to thank everyone who supported Misty, both with donation and kind words, and for the countless messages we got asking for updates. Without you, our work with Misty would have not been possible. On Monday 01/28, the day after Misty left us, Michelle and I signed on the line and officially adopted her. Although this may sound silly, it was our way to show our love and the forever home she had with us. I have gathered together some of the many pictures from the last six months that show Misty's growth from bottle baby to kitten.
We are struggling greatly with this. It hurts every time we come home and she is not there, every time it's time for her medication and every time we open our camera roll. Thank you in advance for the kind words and for all your support. 💔 #helpkittenmisty