This page includes validated tools that students can use to evaluate the reliability of the information they find online, spot media bias, and understand copyright and fair use.
A STIC Model infographic created by Dr. Loertscher and his graduate students. View the original at The Informed Learner.
The Six Tests of Information Confidence, also known as the STIC Model, is a way of assessing the accuracy and credibility of information that we find online.
The STIC Model invites us to consider six pieces of information about each of our sources (shown in bold below):
Who is saying what to me?
For what Reasons?
For what Gain?
Through what Channel?
and with what Evidence?
Explore the STIC model at The Informed Learner, an interactive website developed by Dr. Loertscher and his graduate students at SJSU.
The SIFT Method is an alternative approach developed by digital literacy expert Mike Caulfield that you can use to determine if information you find online is credible. The SIFT method asks that before you share any information, you:
Stop.
Investigate the source
Find better coverage
Trace claims, quotes and media to their original context.
The SIFT Method encourages us to consider whether we are having an immediate emotional reaction to the content we view online, what we know about a source, whether that source is an expert or likely to be biased, whether an already trusted source has covered the same topic, and whenever possible, to trace claims back to their original source so that we can review them in their original context.
The University of Chicago has published an excellent primer on using the SIFT Method here.
Austen Kellerman has published a 7 minute video that students can use to test their ability to spot media bias in news stories.
Harvard University has put together this website to explain copyright and fair use to its undergraduate students.
References
Kellerman, A. (2021, March 26). Can you spot media bias? [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n9-X3z4P7c0
Loertscher, D. (2021). The STIC model. The Informed Learner. https://sites.google.com/view/theinformedlearner/home
Office of the General Counsel. (2023). Copyright and fair use: A guide for the Harvard Community. Harvard University. https://ogc.harvard.edu/sites/hwpi.harvard.edu/files/ogc/files/ogc_copyright_and_fair_use_guide_bea_july_2023.pdf?m=1689173591
University of Chicago Library. (2024). Evaluating resources and information: The SIFT method. https://guides.lib.uchicago.edu/c.php?g=1241077&p=9082322