This lesson takes students into the heart of the book, where understanding is necessary for them to truly comprehend its significance. What is greed? How is it different from ambition and addiction? How can one evaluate differences or degrees of greed? How does it compare to self-centeredness? How does it compare to other-centeredness? Which characters are greedy? Do any characters resist greed and choose to be other-centered? Students will warm up with reflective questions about greed. The class will then follow a teacher-led discussion about the questions above, defining the terms. The class will briefly explore the Langston Hughes poem, I Dream a World. The words to the poem will be in the packet. On the screen the poem will be recited accompanied by music. The students will work within their assigned groups to fill in their charts with data and conclusions about the characters from the book, and with citations from the book supporting the students’ conclusions. This lesson is a quality collaborative, student-led exploration of themes in the book. It also encourages students to begin to systematically explore the text for statements which will support the summative assessment, as each student must document his or her work, whether Artisan or Scholar. The teacher must be ready to support a Clan whose leader or Clan members need aid in research or in cooperating as group members.
Curriculum Standards Addressed
MCPS 8th Grade ELA Honors Inclusion
Assessment limits:
Character's traits based on what character says, does, and thinks and what other characters or the narrator says
Character's motivations
Character's personal growth and development
Assessment limits: Connections between personal experiences and the theme or main ideas
5. Explain the implications of the text for the reader and/or society
Assessment limits: Ideas and issues of a text that may have implications for the reader
NCTE-Standards
3. Students apply a wide range of strategies to comprehend, interpret, evaluate, and appreciate texts. They draw on their prior experience, their interactions with other readers and writers, their knowledge of word meaning and of other texts, their word identification strategies, and their understanding of textual features (e.g., sound-letter correspondence, sentence structure, context, graphics).
6. Students apply knowledge of language structure, language conventions (e.g., spelling and punctuation), media techniques, figurative language, and genre to create, critique, and discuss print and nonprint texts.
11. Students participate as knowledgeable, reflective, creative, and critical members of a variety of literacy communities.
Objectives
The student will derive evidence to support an understanding of themes through reflection, watching video and PowerPoint, and through small group interaction.
The student will begin to explore the new poem by watching and listening to the musical video version and reading along with it.
The student will build an understanding of universal themes between texts.
The student will extend the understanding of the Epic Hero and poetry to an understanding of faults within heroes and others, and the importance of resisting the faults.
The student will participate in small group (Clan) discussion.
The student will associate plot features and elements of the poem with the positive and negative traits of the characters in the book.
The student will work with those of other racial, cultural, and interest groups to accomplish the purpose of the Clan.
The student will cooperate in the class and Clan activities, and will help others willingly.
Materials
The Hobbit Text
Highlighters
Student Reflective Journals
Writing Utensils
PowerPoint Slides
Promethean Board
Project Packet
Proactive Behavior Management
Please refer to Unit Plan Header under “Proactive Behavior Management.”
Provisions for Student Grouping:
Please refer to Unit Plan Header under “Provisions for Student Grouping.”
Procedures
Students have handouts; extra copies of today’s page must be requested. Warm-up and small group procedures are established.
Warm-Up (5 minutes)
The warm-up is a series of three questions about greed, including a reflective question about personal greed. The warm-up is on the first PowerPoint slide, before the Hobbit Day 3 introduction.
Motivator/Bridge (8 minutes)
a) Review prior learning.
The teacher will go over the previous night’s reading to ensure that the students understand it. We will discuss greed in the context of the homework and the warm-up.
b) Tie new learning into students’ prior knowledge.
Students know that the motivation for the journey was the gold of the dragon, Smaug. They know the attitude of the dwarfs and some of the characters. The new knowledge will be tied to that. Tie greed and the other attributes into the homework. The poem introduces the concept of the world without greed and cultural animosity, which we will tie into the previous day’s mention of the cultures and the poem.
c) State the goal(s) and objective(s) for the lesson.
Students will see these objectives as a part of the class introduction on the Promethean Board:
Define terms: greed, ambition, addiction, self-centeredness, other-centeredness
Identify the motivations and actions of characters in The Hobbit which demonstrate these characteristics
Work well with your Clan to find the answers and evidence
Use your strategy Making Connections
The PowerPoint presentation continues, showing the day’s objectives and linking the theme and the character groupings of Middle Earth. The poem is introduced in the presentation, in both word and song.
Procedural Activities
Take attendance and take care of any problems during Warm-up.
Model for Teaching:
Lesson Topic: Greed, Ambition, Addiction, Self-Centeredness and Other-Centeredness in The Hobbit and the Langston Hughes poem I Dream a World Type of Lesson: Developmental
Context for Learning
The discussion of the trait, and the introduction in integration of the themes of the poem are teacher-led, as the directions for the project. The student small group exploration of character and theme are guided student inquiry.
Developmental Activities (36 minutes)
Students experience the Langston Hughes poem as a song, a form of entertainment, but the cultural theme and wish for a world without race or greed with be mentioned by the teacher, if the class does not bring it up. . The class will locate words representing themes paralleling those on their handout charts, negative or positive traits of characters in the Hobbit.
Part two of class is the Clan activity. Students are reminded that they are expected to be kind, helpful and supportive of one another on their Clans. They are told that they may, if they choose, use the citations they find for this chart as a part of their evidence for Friday’s presentation. The Clan members will help one another to fill out the chart and to locate passages to support their answers.
Assessment
The formative assessment will be each individual chart filled out within the group, including the requested documentations.
Summary/Closure (5 minutes)
In five minutes, the teacher will remind the class of the Epic Hero and ask if heroes can have faults. Do they overcome their faults? How?
*Generalization/Extension Activity
Students are asked to help one another with their projects. For those who wish to go further, two activities are listed on page 33 of the Project Package under “Digging Deeper”. One activity involves the opportunity to translate the names of group members into runes. The second activity encourages interested students to read the Lord of the Rings trilogy, and to compare that epic hero with those in this unit. The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle is also linked, for those with very advanced interests. In the unit, students are allowed to assume a secondary role, if all responsibilities are met, including research and making artifacts for the group. It must be a role not chosen by another group member. See the unit guide for recommended combinations. Students will receive one extra minute of presentation time.
Review/Reinforcement (Homework)
Today’s homework will be to continue reading The Hobbit as per the schedule in the project packet, and to help one another to gather citations for the 5-6 page group paper and the 250-word essays. All homework assignments for the Unit, including this lesson, are listed on page 15 of the Hobbit and Middle Earth Project Package. This package is available to parents, tutors and students on the class web site at
Adaptations
For this particular lesson, the ADHD student will be placed in the far right, front seat, in a location where his noise and activity should not infringe upon that of the other groups to hear, and where he can easily move and be helped. The seating chart is adapted for the student in the wheelchair, for the class and the groups. She is also in the front, where she has space to turn her chair as needed. For the developmental reader, the book is available in audio from the BBC radio performance (see above) at http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WckpBnpZ0M0 or on MP3 at http://torrentz.eu/e737d32fdec61ff5bb15ba140ed878cb5d29074f . He is scheduled to listen to the book while he reads during his sessions in the reading center, and his tutor has a copy of our unit plan and handbook, as well as the web page. Extra links and references sections are provided on pages 34-35 of the packet.
Differentiated assignments are the heart of the Middle Earth concept, where each Clan member uses his or her talents to help the Clan. Clan placement is involuntary; job choice is voluntary. Jobs consist of:
The roles for the unit are:
1. Leader/Spokesman (chosen Week 2 Day 1),
2. Ethnographer
3. Historian
4. Cartographer
5. Bard
6. Minstrel
7. Tailor
8. Armorer
9. Herald
10. Linguist