Jonathan moved to Henry County, Indiana in 1842. An extensive article about him and his son, Elias, are found In The History of Henry County, Indiana, copyrighted 1884, and is viewable at the downloadable file below page 324, Henry County Jonathan Phelps, son of Samuel Phelps, grandson of Jonathan #3 Phelps An article about his son Jesse is in the History of Rush County, Indiana and is found in the downloadable file below, page 610, Rush County
1. JONATHAN6 PHELPS (JONATHAN #35, HENRY4, JONATHAN #23, JONATHAN #12, NICHOLAS1) was born 04 Jan 1801 in Randolph County, NC, and died 17 Jan 1876 in Rush County, Indiana. He married (1) MARY HENLEY. She was born 23 Oct 1804 in North Carolina, and died 10 Oct 1893 in Rush County, Indiana. He married (2) SUSANNAH HENLEY Dec 1822 in Randolph County, NC. She was born Abt. 1801 in North Carolina, and died 01 Aug 1847 in Rush County, Indiana.
Children of JONATHAN PHELPS and SUSANNAH HENLEY are:
i. PENNINA7 PHELPS.
ii. LEVI PHELPS, d. 14 Aug 1871, Rush County, Indiana.
iii. SARAH PHELPS, b. 11 Oct 1823, North Carolina; m. SAMUEL GATES.
iv. JOSEPH PHELPS, b. 23 Feb 1829; m. JANE HILL, 30 Sep 1853, Rush County, Indiana.
v. THOMAS PHELPS, b. Bef. 1830, North Carolina; d. 01 Jan 1861; m. LUCINDA HOGAN, 30 Sep 1858, Rush County, Indiana; b. Virginia.
vi. MARK PHELPS, b. 09 Mar 1833, Rush County, Indiana; d. 07 Aug 1900, Indiana; m. LOUISA PITMAN, 09 Nov 1865, Marion County, Indiana; b. Indiana; d. Bef. 1880, Indiana.
vii. JESSE L. PHELPS, b. Abt. 1835, Rush County, Indiana; m. ELIZABETH ANN JUNKEN, 25 Oct 1860, Rush County, Indiana; b. 26 Jun 1832, Rush County, Indiana.
viii. HENRY PHELPS, b. Jul 1838, Rush County, Indiana.
ix. WILLIAM PHELPS, b. Dec 1840, Rush County, Indiana.