Outsider
Outsiders have the wrong idea and think Sam and Dean are evil murderers. Outsiders can be either police officials, civilians, crossover characters from cops shows (NCIS etc).
** = I love it, * = I like it
Canon Universe
All That I'm Living (Dying) For by creedcascade & majorbrat
MA, Complete, Sam/Dean, >2,000, Warning: [major character death]
- After defeating the yellow-eyed demon, Sam and Dean get caught by the FBI again.
And They Cry To See Your Face by honeylocustree
K+, Complete, >2,000, Warning: [violence, gore]
-Sam meets old friends from Stanford and they don't recognize him, what with him and Dean swooping in all huge and violent with guns and knives and arcane rituals to rescue them all from some horrifying eldritch creature. And then his friends are all, "OMG! It's Psycho Sam who was a closet satanist and was wanted by the FBI!" And Sam is very conspicuously injured, but he and Dean can't stop to patch him up because the eldritch creature is still trying to rip their throats out. And Sam's feelings are hurt because his old friends are scared of him now.
* The Angel Killer by vikki
K+, Complete, >5,000
- The FBI is tracking a case of a serial killer who leaves his victim's bodies with winglike shapes burned underneath them. Then they find Castiel standing over one of those bodies. He's too hurt to 'teleport'. How do they react to him.
Basic Instinct by foolsdance
M, Complete, >7,000, Warning: [referenced but non-existent underage incestuous non-con & abuse]
- After Dean is once again arrested on suspicion of murder while investigating a case, it's up to Sam to come up with a way to get him out of jail, not easy when he's in custody as well and being looked at as a possible accomplice. The lie he comes up with makes Dean one very unhappy camper.
Blood and Wine Are Red by kroki-refur
K+, Complete, <2,000
- Eventually, one of those boys is going to get caught.
Case Study 24-17X by pheebs1
T, Complete
- A psychologist presents his insane patient Dean Winchester to his students.
Days Without Feathers by pyrebi
T, Complete
- It’s tragic, everyone says. A chance in a million—a shorted wire, an untended candle. When they get the news (one survivor, a young male), she puts a hand over her mouth and waits for the world to end.
Fellowship of the Nine by emebalia (alternative)
T, Complete, >26,000
- Sam spends a weekend with some Stanford friends. But he's not the man they used to know anymore. Outsider POV. Season two.
Mistakes and Monsters by lickerdysplit
T, Complete, >20,000
- Dean. Sam. Henricksen. A race against time to find missing kids...and deep dark woods hiding darker secrets. Rated T to be safe. Written before Jus in Bello aired, so kind of AU, but everyone you know is the same.
** Monster by foolsdance (alternative)
T, Complete, >22,000
- Following the disastrous events in Colorado, Sam and Dean encounter a new problem. An unknown creature changes Sam into his twelve year old self. Going from bad to worse, they are soon after caught by the FBI, who believe Sam has been kidnapped by Dean as a replacement for his missing brother. It's up to Sam to break Dean out of custody, not easy when you're suddenly a pint sized foster kid.
Out of Eden by delwyn
T, Complete, >15,000
- Sam knew it was a bad idea to take the hunt in Palo Alto. Little did he know that a teacher’s curiosity would lead to a very dangerous situation. Not to mention that pesky PI who was apparently determined to get himself killed.
* The Outsider by Denihil
T, Complete, <2,000
- Short fic. Henriksen's impressions of the Winchesters.
Pandora's Box by emebalia
T, Complete, >2,000
- Tag to 8.10 so SPOILERS for that episode. What does Amelia actually know about the man she has wanted to share the rest of her life with? Google is just one click away.
Serial Worship by ghostmonsters
T, Complete, 8,000
- It's not every day you get to meet the dead Brothers Grimm. Sometimes you get more than you could wish for.
Turned Out by foolsdance (sequel: Turned Out Again)
MA, Complete, Dean/OMC, >2,000, Warning: [dub-con]
- Dean gets a new cellmate who's young, out of his depth and very good looking. Dean comes on to him and isn't at all surprised when his cellmate agrees to have sex, since after all who wouldn't want the hotness that is Dean? They start a relationship of sorts and Dean is actually happy.
What he doesn't realise is that his cellmate has a very different view on the situation. He's too afraid of the Winchester brothers to say no to Dean, and thinks he has to let Dean fuck him to pay for his safety. He's terrified that one day Dean will snap and hurt him.
Turned Out Again by foolsdance (sequel to Turned Out)
MA, Complete, Dean/OMC, >7,000, Warning: [dub-con]
- Sequel to Turned Out. This is basically a retelling of episode 7x06 with some significant changes. The Leviathans started a crime spree posing as the Winchesters, beginning with a bank robbery in Jericho and a hold up in Colorado. The real Sam, meanwhile, is spotted at a gas station. We're going to imagine the brothers didn't just drive off into the night, but were caught at this point and sent to prison for safekeeping while awaiting trial. This story picks up from there.
Until you call me by raziella
T, Complete, 2,500
- Sam’s the first one to give in and call his brother after that fallout they had over Amy.
If only Dean had his phone.
In which Dean gets drunk and loses his phone, and someone gets a surprise call from Sam.
Crossovers
>Criminal Minds
Defect by kikkimax (plus sequels)
K+, Complete, >35,000
Dean is finally captured by the FBI just as his time runs out. Gen.
* The Deep Indigo Night by portraitofafool
M, Complete
- Strange cases have been popping up for years and then in 2010 they start occurring with even more frequency. This time the clues all point to one man, a man named Sam.
Eat It, Twilight by liliaeth (alternative)
K+, Complete, >47,000
- The BAU has to deal with a serial killer who believes he's hunting vampires. The unsub's name, Dean Winchester.
Partners by shadownashira
K, Complete, Dean/Gabriel, <2,000
- “We had a very interesting conversation with your partner, Dean. Gabriel claims the two of you are married,” Hotch said, watching for Dean’s reaction. Written for the 5 Acts meme.
The Time Has Come To Be Gone by jujuberry136
K+, Complete, >25,000
- When Aaron Hotchner stepped into the interrogation room to interview one of the FBI’s most wanted unexpectedly apprehended earlier in the afternoon, he never thought the evening would end with bloodshed and rock references.
>NCIS
Five Times Dean and Tony Bumped Into Each Other by tassosss
K, Complete, >2,000
- Prompt: Tony DiNozzo, Dean Winchester; Five Times Dean Bumped into Tony
Language Barriers by BoundLight
K, Complete, Dean/Castiel, >15,000
- While hunting a windego, Sam, Dean and Castiel fall into NCIS custody. Established Dean/Cas
* Rule Number 7: Always Be Specific When You Lie by Anniehow
K+, Complete, >3,000
-I know bailing me out of police custody wasn’t part of your orders... SPN/NCIS Dean & Castiel
>Numb3rs
Doubt by aleo-70 (sequel to Explained, with sequels: Alliance, Nightmare & Trick)
K+, Complete, >7,000
- A graveyard on Halloween? Not the safest place to be.
Explained by aleo-70 (sequel to Unexplained, with sequel: Doubt)
K+, Complete, >3,000
- Don finds the murderers have not left town as expected.
Unexplained by aleo-70 (sequel: Explained)
K+, Complete, >3,000
- Thirteen grisly murders. When Don stumbles on the scene of the final murder he fears he is about to become the fourteenth victim. Crossover with Supernatural from a Numb3rs POV.