AU fics where Sam is being hunted (usually by Dean) for being a psychic/monster OR AU fics where Sam (and psychics) are regarded as monsters and kept in slavery.
** = I love it, * = I like it
Bless the Broken Road by PsychicWonderKitty
T, Complete, >64,000
- “If I didn’t know you? I’d want to hunt you.” If the first half of this statement from Dean to Sam was reality...would the second half be, as well? Largely AU...with a fair amount of canon elements and twists.
Demonic Lover by kirallie
T, WIP, >19,000, Sam/Dean (unrelated)
- AU. Wincest though unrelated. Samuel loved his father until he killed Jessica. When that happened he had no reason not to help the hunter that pulled him from the fire.
Devil's Advocate by UThnkUrFunny IThnkImAdorable
T, Incomplete, >30,000
- AU theyre unrelated. Dean's family is killed by a demon and is trained as a hunter. Sam discovers he IS a demon and is kept in a painful existence. What happens when they're paths cross? Hurt!Sam Protective!Dean Limp!Both Mean!Gordon
Faceless by Fireglass
M, Complete, >290,000, Warning: [slavery]
- When monsters become the pawns in a competition between humans and demons, Dean Winchester adopts a Faceless outcast named Sam who just might bring the broken Winchester family back together again. AU, John/Mary & brief Dean/Jo
Freak Camp: A Monster By Any Other Name by Brosedshield, LaviniaLavender & whereupon
MA, WIP series, >460,000, Sam/Dean (unrelated), Warning: [rape/noncon, underage, graphic depictions of violence]
- The same old Sam/Dean love story, with a darkfic twist. Sam grows up in a concentration camp for monsters, and Dean is raised as an only child and a hunter. Together, they make each other human.
Habitat by BruisedBloodyBroken
M, Complete, >50,000, Sam/Dean (unrelated)
- AU - Dean 29 is a hunter, Sam 26 (psychic abilities like in the show, just a little extended) gets sold on an auction(monster-black-market). Dean "wins" him instead of a hunters-journal he would've needed desperately ... The young man turns his life upside down. love!story hurt!sam implied!torture!rape caring!dean awesome!bobby including!cas unrelated!wincest
Honey and Flies by glasslogic (alternative)
MA, Complete, >30,000, Sam/Dean, Warning: [rape/non-con (not Sam/Dean)]
- College students are turning up dead without a mark, and Dean heads west to investigate after the son of a friend is added to the growing list. But "dead" in this case may be a slight exaggeration. Dean finding the recently deseased chatting up a bartender on the wrong side of the tracks is just his first step into a mystery with roots much closer to home than he ever could have imagined, where all the answers are confusing and the revelations just make things much worse.
** How the Wild Things Start by foolscapper
MA, Complete, >60,000
- This is where it starts — the brightly lit ring, the screams, the glinting of knives, the baring of teeth. This, right here, is where it begins. Sam turns to Dean, Metatron just a hero's walk away, and Dean slams his fist into the side of Sam's face. It will bruise, but that's not the point. Sam will not face Metatron's blade and wrath, but that is not the point. The point is, Dean puts Sam's hands on his chest, the action sickly sweet like perfume left on a tacky, bloated corpse — and then he walks away. He leaves Sam, dreaming black dreams on the ground, just outside of the impala. Baby does not protect him when one of Abaddon's followers finds him. Baby does not scream for help or look for Dean when the demons drag Sam's unconscious body away.
When Dean leaves Metatron's burnt-out husk, his bones screaming ecstasy from the kill, he finds Sam gone
If I Didn't Know You by OpenMindedGirl
T, WIP, >9,000
- Dean Winchester is a hunter. A great hunter who travels America with his father, hunting evil in the name of his mom and brother, both apparently murdered by Azazel. Sam Winchester is a freak. A powerful freak who was raised by demons from a young age and knows that hunters would kill him in a heartbeat. Neither knew about the other until the day their paths crossed... AU/"What If"
* In the Blood by Secret Spy Guy
T, WIP, >23,000
- AU. After John Winchester brings home Sam, the halfblooded son of a demon, Dean finds his family slowly falling apart. As time passes, Dean stays by Sam's side, to protect him, but is it because of his own choice...or is something more sinister to blame?
Ouroboros by nyxocity
MA, Complete, >50,000, Sam/Dean, Bottom!Sam
- S2 AU. Sammy died when Dean was nine. Sixteen years later, he's the last Winchester alive, and hunting a man who's supposed to be the Antichrist. But when he meets Sam Harrison face to face, he can't pull the trigger. They go on the run from the other hunters together, discover a bond they can't quite explain, become a team and more. By the time all the secrets between them are revealed, it's too late to go back, and the Antichrist has risen. The world is ending and Dean's the only one who can stop it--if he's willing to give up everything he never thought he'd have.
Purrrfect Mate by virtual personal
MA, Complete, Sam/Dean (unrelated), Bottom!Sam
- Photographer Sam Wesson has made it his life's work to take pictures of 'the unexplained.' Only now, back from a trip to the jungles of the Amazon, he is one of the unexplained - a werepanther. Deciding it changes nothing, he is on the prowl in the nightclubs of miami, searching for the the thing that is selecting and killing young people from the clubs. Dean Winchester is hunting that same creature and runs into Sam, a lot. The heat between them is incredible but is that enough to prevent the hunter from hunting that which is not human?
Semper Familia by KatZen
T, Complete, >100,000
- When his dad comes back into the clearing with a scrawny kid he's just bought in tow, Dean isn't surprised. He knows Lilim aren't human, that they're creatures, like witches or wendigo.
But the kid that John's got by the arm, who's pulled as far away from Dean's dad as possible without actually trying to get his arm back, the kid whose eyes don't leave John and are bright with fear, the kid who looks like he hasn't eaten in a couple of days and is obviously favoring his left leg...
This kid looks an awful lot like a person. And what's more, he's the same age Sammy would have been.
The Vision Giver by Elegant Ghost
T, WIP, >19,000, Warning: [slavery]
- In a world where the gifted are sold on the black market, lone hunter Dean purchases a visionary with an eye for escape. But as visions lead them into a web of danger and deceit, Sam and Dean are challenged with overcoming their pasts and working together to defeat their enemies.