Maintaining an Active Research Career through Collaboration
Throughout history great mathematics has been conducted in collaboration at institutions where mathematicians and scientists came together at seminars and workshops to exchange their developing ideas. In our age of international travel and communication on the internet, the opportunities to collaborate have expanded exponentially. In this panel we will discuss issues that arise in mathematical collaborations, including questions such as how to start and maintain a successful collaboration, how collaborative efforts can build a research program and a career, how to engage students in collaborative research, and how to obtain funding for collaboration. Panelists will share their experience at research institutions, undergraduate institutions and in industry.
Wednesday, January 4, 2012, 2:15 pm - 3:40 pm.
Association for Women in Mathematics Panel Discussion
Moderator: Ami Radunskaya
Panelists: Ruth Haas, Trachette L Jackson, Jill Pipher, Ulrica Wilson
Organizers: Ruth Haas, Jennifer Lewis, Ami Radunskaya, Christina Sormani
The discussion will continue online at https://sites.google.com/site/awmpanel2012/
Online Panel
We have divided the questions into three major categories:
I. Collaboration, Coauthoring and One's Career
These questions concerns ways in which collaboration can help one's career: the basics of collaboration and questions regarding collaboration as a postdoc and tenure track faculty member, coauthoring with undergraduates and obtaining funding.
II. Building Collaborations to Achieve Mathematical Goals
These questions concern the exchange of ideas and building of collaborations where the goal is to solve a mathematical problem. While these questions are relevant to young mathematicians, they are essential to mature mathematicians.
III. Collaboration Difficulties
These questions focus on specific difficulties that may arise during the collaboration process and how they may be addressed. We encourage mathematicians with concerns to send in questions and they will be posted anonymously. Collaboration is an essential part of the mathematical process and it is important to understand how to maintain a successful collaboration especially in a long term project.
IV. Additional Questions
Anyone who has a question should email them to the online moderator. We will list them here and try to find someone to answer the question. Some questions may be inserted under an existing topic. Others will be added at the end.
I. Collaboration, Coauthoring and One's Career:
A. How to find Collaborators or Make Yourself Available as a Collaborator on an Existing Project?
B. How can Mathematicians in Isolation Collaborate?
C. Collaborating with Scientists and Mathematicians Outside of Your Field
D. Collaborating with Undergraduates
E. Collaborating with Colleagues in Your Department
F. Collaborating with A Spouse or Parent
G. Collaborating with Multiple Coauthors on a Single Project
I. Collaborating without Coauthoring
K. Obtaining Funding for Collaborative Research
II. Building Collaborations to Achieve Mathematical Goals:
A. How to Exchange Ideas without Giving them Away?
B. How to Develop Ideas through Seminars and Workshops?
C. How to Contribute Ideas to an Existing Project?
D. How to Find Collaborators to Assist with your Project both within and outside of your field?
G. What are the Advantages and Disadvantages of Open Online Collaboration in a Public Forum?
III. Collaboration Difficulties
B. The Missing Collaborator: when a collaborator stops contributing and the clock is ticking for the other
C. The Domineering Collaborator: making your ideas heard
F. Adding Additional Coauthors
G. Communicating Concerns about the Collaboration
H. Finding a Mediator for a Troubled Collaboration
I. Handing a Mathematical Divorce: when two Mathematicians decide to stop Working together
J. Starting to Collaborate Again: looking for the Warning Signs
K. Finding Collaborators for Long Term Projects that Span Years and Maintaining a Good Relationship
IV. Additional Questions
A. What to do when a collaborator makes mistakes?
B. When should we post, repost or withdraw a paper from the arxiv?
C. What to do when a collaborator stops replying to all emails and never communicates with you again? (unanswered)