SRA HOUSING
APNA GHAR CO-OPERATIVE HOUSING SOCIETY, ANDHERI (EAST)
Grishma Karle
Source : Author
In January of 1995, the city had about 8,05,000 slum dwellings for over 4,000,000 dwellers (“Slum Rehabilitation Scheme, Maharashtra, India Public Private Partnership”, n.d.). This means an average of 5 people living in one ‘house’ which was about 100 sq. ft in floor area. The Government of Maharashtra in December 1995 established the Slum Redevelopment Authority (SRA) in an attempt to provide secure housing for the urban poor living in the slums. The slums in the city started forming ‘co-operative societies’ as developers approached. The Apna Ghar Co-operative Housing Society, my home, in Andheri East was one of those. Before 2003, slum dwellings took most of the space on the land which originally belonged to the BMC and a couple of private owners. As the redevelopment of this slum commenced, the people from the part of the land on which the building was being constructed were relocated to transit camps while the other half stayed. The redeveloped housing encompassed 379 residences of 225 sq. ft carpet area each, accommodating all the dwellers that were there in the slums before. To determine the parameters through which one would be eligible to form a claim over an apartment was that those who were residing in the hut on or before 1.1.95 and had a name in the voter's list of or before 1.1.95 would be provided the housing.
As for me, I was born in the year 2004 - the year construction was completed and homes were provided so I have only heard stories about what it is like to live in those conditions.
Having said that, the “Apartment” living that I grew up with in this setting brought my way experiences so spatially enriching that looking back at it I almost end up romanticizing them. This article is a personal attempt to look at the spatialities through the lens of personal experiences and observations made while growing up.
What is it like to have 20 homes with families of at least 3 living on the same floor sharing a common passage?
How do the neighbors become a neighborhood?
In a space where every home feels yours, how are people claiming their spaces in that one common passage they share?
Three buildings of 7 storeys each were built with 20 apartments on each of those floors connected with a common passage that was almost half the size of the living rooms the apartments had. The ground floors of these buildings were commercial units that were later sold or rented out to generate revenue for running and maintaining the premises. Even though the distances between any of the buildings with respect to each other were not any more than 4 - 4.5m, these open spaces formed the transactional thoroughfares between the buildings becoming the most active spaces throughout the day. These in-between spaces house programs that occur on a daily basis as well as yearly events like festivals, etc where one sees a space transition from being a vehicle parking space to a cricket pitch in a day.
As one enters any of the buildings it tosses your way an overwhelming juxtaposition of living complexities that seem to have habituated themselves over the period of time almost looking as if homes have spilled out in the common area changing the figure ground of that very passage. I’ll be using the 4th floor from building 2A to talk through these growing and shrinking spatialities more. When the common passage provided is of 2 meter width and the space inside the homes limited, it is given that the passage will become an extension to everyone's living room. And what it does to the commonness of that space is, it stitches these smaller communities that treat the floor of 20 apartments as one big household where everyone has their ways to make a claim without disturbing the other’s chosen space.
The idea of this common passage holds the most importance here as this is the element that holds the people together, where it caters to its occupants of all age groups by transforming itself when and as required. From being a playground for kids to play cricket, kho-kho, etc where the belongings of the people in that passage also become a part of the play to the small tables kept outside homes becoming leisure spaces for elderly to sit late in the night to the woman of some of the households collectively deciding to celebrate a festival together making it a community hall hosting people, the passage is able to shape shift to house everyone and their needs in it. And as a kid when I saw this as the environment around me it convinced me I was living in the most fascinating of places and I still somewhere do. There is also a part of me that has realized as I have grown up that with all that this living has offered, there is also a lot it hasn’t. In situations like these, when the boundaries are so blurred and the flow of people, objects and other beings in a constantly hazy patch, on an individual level one experiences a hostile feeling of loss of individuality and privacy where for a growing pubescent, one like me, the space and its conditions often overpower.
Source : Author
Source: Author
Source: Author
Going in further to see how an apartment as a house works with its limited space and inexhaustible wants here, one can find numerous ways in which each person has retrofitted their homes to accommodate a little more than what was given. Speaking through examples of my own, the window in my house was broken down and extended outside a little more than the Chajjah given, with a low seating to allow more light while the wall around it was converted into storage. Another example would be that of one of the houses while redoing the interiors broke the kitchen and living room partition made out of brick and built a thick wood one which has an inner partition to it with openings from both - the kitchen and living room; side to provide for the lack of storage. These smaller moves are where I see architecture happening, on this scale, where for the people the design comes as a solution to make the most out of what they have rather than the aesthetics of it.
When I look at this housing scheme standing on the outside, the system and programmes running throughout have slowly made this space almost city like, where services outside of the building systems like the vegetable lady and the machhi-wala coming to sell their goods to the people instead of them going or a general goods store running in one of the units is making it a self sufficient organization that is running under administered attention. What comes with it unfortunately are the ill-implemented building methodologies with respect to its scale, proportions and pure spatial environment it generates devoid of the people who make it breathe; often proving to be worrisome dwellings for the masses. And to study, resolve and generate through its learnings will remain a constant attempt.
Density of things in the common passage
Services like those of the Istri-wala or the Paav wala come to the doorsteps of the people
*The Drawings and photos used are all original and are made by the author