Team Accomplishments
&
Individual Awards
Team Accomplishments
1997 - 2022
NYS Championship
2010
Regional Championships
1999, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2014, 2015
Section 1 Championships
1999, 2000, 2004, 2005, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011, 2014, 2015, 2016
League Championships
1997, 1998, 1999, 2000, 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012, 2015, 2016, 2017, 2019, 2021, 2022
Over the past 24 seasons, the Pirate Softball Program has produced (1997-2021):
(Note: The 2020 season did not occur due to pandemic)
Coaches: Carlacci (1997-2012), Gaylardo (2013), Woolgar (2014-present)
New York State Champions : 2010
New York State Finalist: 2009
New York State Semi-Finalists: 1999, 2008, 2014, and 2015
New York State Regional Champions: 1999, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2014, and 2015
New York State Regional Finalists: 2000, 2004, 2005, 2011, 2016
Section 1 Champions: 1999, 2000, 2004, 2005, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011, 2014, 2015, 2016
League Champions: 1997, 1998, 1999, 2000, 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012, 2015, 2016, 2017, 2019, 2021, 2022
Overall Record: 542-105-1 (0.838)
League Record: 240-22 (0.916)
Postseason Record: 83-25 (0.769)
55 consecutive League wins from 4/17/97 – 4/27/01
Section 1 Finalist: 1997, 2002, 2003, and 2013
State Ranked ALL 26 years
Most wins by any Rockland County softball team (1997-2012 & 2014-2018)
Most wins by any Section 1 softball team 1997-2012)
15 consecutive seasons of 20 or more wins (1997-2012)
27 wins in 1999 is tied for the most wins by one team (any sport) in Rockland County History
New York State Scholar Athlete Team (90 or above team average) ALL 26 years
2 graduating class salutatorians
12 Rockland Journal News Scholar Athletes
5 times player named Section 1 Diamond Nine plus One team
2 times a player named NFCA/Louisville Slugger 2nd team All-American
3 times a player named NFCA/Louisville Slugger 3rd team All-American
12 times a player named NFCA/Louisville Slugger East Region All-American
51 times a player named All-State (thru 2023)
1 player named Schultz Ford Rockland County Athlete of the year
4 players named Rockland County Female Athlete of the Spring
6 times a player named Journal News softball player of the year
27 players have gone on to play college softball
87 times a player named All-Section
36 times a player named All-Section Honorable Mention
69 times a player named All-County First Team
29 times a player named All-County Second Team
156 times a player named All-League
2010 coaching staff named NFCA East Region Coaching Staff of the Year (2010 NYS Champions)
Coach named 2011 Dave Siegriest Memorial Sportsmanship award winner
3 times coach named New York State Coach of the Year (1999, 2009, 2010)
8 time Rockland County Coach of the Year
14 times named League Coach of the Year
Updated a/o July 2023
Over the past 7 seasons, the Pirate Softball Program has produced (2014-2021):
(Note: The 2020 season did not occur due to pandemic)
Coach: Woolgar (2014-present)
New York State Champions : n/a
New York State Finalist: n/a
New York State Semi-Finalists: 2014 and 2015
New York State Regional Champions: 2014 and 2015
New York State Regional Finalists: 2016
Section 1 Champions: 2014, 2015, 2016
Section 1 Finalist: n/a
League Champions: 2015, 2016, 2017, 2019, 2021, 2022
Undefeated League Championships: 2015, 2016
Overall Record: 157-45 (0.777)
League Record: 60-12 (0.833)
Postseason Record: 26-9 (0.743)
17 consecutive League wins from 4/14/15 – 4/10/17
State Ranked ALL 9 seasons
State Ranked Top 5: 2014, 2015, 2016
Most wins by any Rockland County softball team over first 4 years: 86 wins (2014-2018)
Most wins by any Section 1 softball team over first 4 years: 86 wins (2014-2018)
3 Seasons of 21 or more wins: 2014, 2015, 2016
24 wins in 2015 is the most wins in past 8 seasons
New York State Scholar Athlete Team (90 or above team average) ALL 9 years
0 graduating class salutatorians
5 players have gone on to play college softball
5 Rockland Journal News Scholar Athletes
2 times player named Section 1 Diamond Nine plus One team
0 times a player named NFCA/Louisville Slugger 2nd team All-American
0 times a player named NFCA/Louisville Slugger 3rd team All-American
0 times a player named NFCA/Louisville Slugger East Region All-American
2 players named Rockland County Female Athlete of the Spring
7 players named Pearl River High School Female Athlete of the Spring
2 times a player named Journal News softball player of the year
22 times a player named All-State (thru 2023)
23 times a player named All-Section
118 times a player named All-Section Honorable Mention
26 times a player named All-County First Team
15 times a player named All-County Second Team
50 times a player named All-League
0 times coach named New York State Coach of the Year
2 time MSG Varsity Hudson Valley Coach of the Year
1 time Rockland County Coach of the Year
4 times named League Coach of the Year
Updated a/o July 2023
Team Accomplishments
1974 - 1996
Coach Jean Cary
- Section 9 Class B Championships : 1977, 1979, 1980
- County Championship: 1980
- League Championship: 1975, 1977, 1978, 1980, 1989, 1994
- Led Rockland in career wins at time of retirement - 293
- Charter member of the RCCA Century Club
INDIVIDUAL RECOGNITION
Scholar Athlete, All-State, & All-Section
2014 - Present
Rockland Journal News Scholar-Athlete of the Week
2014: Mandy McCarthy & Erin Woods
2015: Kirsten McGarvey
2017: Emily Turilli
2018: Meagan Woods
All-State State
2014: 1st Team - Mandy McCarthy, 2nd Team - Erin Woods, 5th Team - Sam Alicandri
2015: 1st Team - Jules Madigan, 3rd Team - Emily Turilli, 5th Team - Colleen McCoy
2016: 1st Team – Emily Turilli, 3rd Team – Caroline Alicandri, 7th Team – Jesse McCarthy
2017: 1st Team – Emily Turilli, 7th Team – Jesse McCarthy
2018: 4th Team – Julia Kinnally
2019: 5th Team - Julia Kinnally, 5th - Camryn McGee
2020: (No season - pandemic)
2021: 5th Team - Kiera Luckie (Fr), 6th - Grace Scrima (So)
2022: 3rd Team - Kiera Luckie (So), 5th - Grace Scrima (Jr)
2023: 3rd Team - Kiera Luckie (Jr)
All-Section & Honorable Mention Selections
2014: Sam Alicandri (Sr), Mandy McCarthy (Sr), Erin Woods (Sr)
HM: Jules Madigan (Jr)
2015: Jules Madigan (Sr), Colleen McCoy (Jr)
HM: Kirsten McGarvey (Sr), Caroline Alicandri (Jr), Emily Turilli (So)
2016: Caroline Alicandri (Sr), Jesse McCarthy (Jr), Emily Turilli (Jr)
HM: Julie Marsico (Sr), Meagan Woods (So)
2017: Jesse McCarthy (Sr), Emily Turilli (Sr), Meagan Woods (Jr)
HM: Maggie Ryan (So), Julia Kinnally (Fr)
2018: Julia Kinnally (So)
HM: Meagan Woods (Sr), Matteson Donnelly (So), Corinne Miedreich (So)
2019: Julia Kinnally (Jr), Camryn McGee (Jr), Corinne Miedreich (Jr)
HM: Allison Tarsnane (Sr), Maeve Woods (Fr)
2021: Olivia Turilli (Jr), Grace Scrima (So), Kiera Luckie (Fr)
HM: Maeve Woods (Jr)
2022: Olivia Turilli (Sr), Grace Scrima (Jr), Kiera Luckie (So)
HM: Brigitte Collins (Sr), Maeve Woods (Sr)
2023: Cat Arnold (Jr), Kiera Luckie (Jr)
HM: Grace Scrima (Sr), Taylor Donnelly (8th)
INDIVIDUAL RECOGNITION
All-Rockland County
2014 - Present
All-County Selections
Rockland County Player of the Year
2014: P – Mandy McCarthy (Sr)
2017: P – Emily Turilli (Sr)
First Team All-County
2014: P – Mandy McCarthy (Sr) – POY, 2B – Erin Woods (Sr), SS – Sam Alicandri (Sr), OF - Jules Madigan (Jr)
2015: 3B – Colleen McCoy (Jr), OF – Jules Madigan (Sr), OF – Kirsten McGarvey (Sr)
2016: P – Emily Turilli (Jr), 1B – Jesse McCarthy (Jr), 2B – Caroline Alicandri (Sr), OF – Julie Marsico (Sr)
2017: P – Emily Turilli (Sr) – POY, 2B – Julia Kinnally (Fr), OF – Jesse McCarthy (Sr)
2018: INF – Julia Kinnally 2B (So), OF – Matteson Donnelly CF (So)
2019: P – Camryn McGee (Jr), INF – SS Julia Kinnally (Jr), OF – RF Allison Tarsnane (Sr)
2020: (No season - pandemic)
2021: P – Kiera Luckie (Fr), OF – CF Grace Scrima (So)
2022: P - Kiera Luckie (So), INF - SS Maeve Woods (Sr), OF - CF Grace Scrima (Jr)
2023: P - Kiera Luckie (Jr), OF - CF Grace Scrima (Sr)
Second Team All-County
2014: P – Emily Turilli (Fr), LF – Kirsten McGarvey (Jr)
2015: P – Emily Turilli So), 2B – Caroline Alicandri (Jr), SS – Meagan Woods (Fr)
2016: SS – Meagan Woods (So)
2017: SS – Meagan Woods (Jr)
2018: SS – Meagan Woods (Sr)
2019: INF – 1B Corinne Miedreich (Jr), INF – 2B Maeve Woods (Fr)
2022: C - Olivia Turilli (Sr), UTL - LF Brigitte Collins (Sr)
2023: INF - Cat Arnold (Jr)
All-County Honorable Mention
2014: 1B – Caroline Kardashian (Sr), C – Deirdre O’Malley (Sr)
2015: P – Jill Beckerly (Sr), OF – Julie Marsico (Jr)
2016: 3B – Colleen McCoy (Sr)
2017: C – Michaela Murphy (Sr), OF – Maggie Ryan (Jr)
2018: 1B – Corinne Miedreich (So)
2019: DP – Julia Pozzuto (Sr)
2020: (No season - pandemic)
2021: C – Olivia Turilli (Jr), INF – SS Maeve Woods (Jr)
2022: N/A
2023: OF - Bella Capparrelli (8th), Taylor Donnelly (9th)
INDIVIDUAL RECOGNITION
All-League & Rockland Senior Athlete of the Season
2014 - Present
All-League and Honorable Mention Selections
2014: Sam Alicandri (Sr), Mandy McCarthy (Sr), Erin Woods (Sr), Deirdre O’Malley (Sr), Jules Madigan (Jr)
2015: Jules Madigan (Sr), Kirsten McGarvey (Sr), Colleen McCoy (Jr), Caroline Alicandri (Jr), Emily Turilli (So),
Meagan Woods (Fr)
2016: Caroline Alicandri (Sr), Julie Marsico (Sr), Colleen McCoy (Sr), Jesse McCarthy (Jr), Emily Turilli (Jr),
Meagan Woods (So)
2017: Jesse McCarthy (Sr), Emily Turilli (Sr), Michaela Murphy (Sr), Meagan Woods (Jr), Julia Kinnally (Fr),
Maggie Ryan (So)
Honorable Mention: Kelli Scanlon, Maddie McGee
2018: Meagan Woods (Sr), Matteson Donnelly (So), Julia Kinnally (So), Maddie McGee (So),
Corinne Miedreich (So)
Honorable Mention: Maggie Ryan (Jr)
2019: Julia Kinnally (Jr), Camryn McGee (Jr), Corinne Miedreich (Jr), Allison Tarsnane (Sr), Olivia Turilli (Fr),
Maeve Woods (Fr)
Honorable Mention: Julia Pozzuto (Sr), Maggie Ryan (Sr)
2020: (No season - pandemic)
2021: Olivia Turilli (Jr), Maeve Woods (Jr), Brigitte Collins (Jr), Grace Scrima (So), Kiera Luckie (Fr)
2022: Olivia Turilli (Sr), Maeve Woods (Sr), Brigitte Collins (Sr), Jillian Donnelly,
Grace Scrima (Jr), Kiera Luckie (So)
2022: Cat Arnold (Jr), Taylor Donnelly (8th), Kiera Luckie (Jr), Ella McHugh (8th), Grace Scrima (Sr)
League PITCHER of the Year (League Specific Awards Established 2017)
2017: P - Emily Turilli (Sr)
2019: P - Camryn McGee (Jr)
2021: P - Kiera Luckie (Fr)
2022: P - Kiera Luckie (So)
League PLAYER of the Year (League Specific Awards Established 2017)
2023: P - Kiera Luckie (Jr)
Rockland County Senior Athlete of the Season
Rockland County Athlete of the Season Scholarship Award Winner
2014: P – Mandy McCarthy (Sr)
2017: P – Emily Turilli (Sr)
Pearl River Spring Season Nominee
2015: Jules Madigan (Sr) – CF
2016: Caroline Alicandri (Sr) – 2B
2019: Allison Tarsnane (Sr) – RF
2022: Olivia Turilli (Sr) – C
2023: Grace Scrima (Sr) – 3B
INDIVIDUAL RECOGNITION
Varsity Team Awards
2014 - Present
Individual Recognition
(2014 – Present)
Team Awards
Most Valuable Player
2014: Mandy McCarthy (Sr) & Erin Woods (Sr)
2015: Emily Turilli (So)
2016: Emily Turilli (Jr)
2017: Emily Turilli (Sr)
2018: Julia Kinnally (So)
2019: Camryn McGee (Jr)
2021: Kiera Luckie (Fr)
2022: Kiera Luckie (So)
2023: Kiera Luckie (Jr)
Most Improved Player
2014: Kirsten McGarvey (Jr)
2015: Meagan Woods (Fr)
2016: Jesse McCarthy (Jr)
2017: Julia Kinnally (Fr)
2018: Camryn McGee (So)
2019: Maeve Woods (Fr)
2021: Olivia Turilli (Jr)
2022: Jillian Donnelly (Sr)
2022: Cat Arnold (Jr)
Coaches Award
2014: Deirdre O’Malley (Sr)
2015: Jill Beckerle (Sr)
2016: Caroline Alicandri (Sr)
2017: Michaela Murphy (Sr)
2018: Meagan Woods (Sr)
2019: Maggie Ryan (Sr)
2021: Grace Scrima (Jr)
2022: Olivia Turilli (Sr)
2023: Grace Scrima (Sr)
Hawk of the Year “Flying Since 2014” (Outfielders)
2015: Jules Madigan (Sr) - Original Hawk, Kirsten McGarvey (Sr) - Original Hawk
2016: Julie Marsico (Sr) - Original Hawk
2017: Jesse McCarthy (Sr)
2018: Matteson Donnelly (So)
2019: Allison Tarsnane (Sr)
2021: Maggie McGrane (Jr)
2022: Brigitte Collins (Sr)
2023: Taylor Donnelly (8th)
Offensive Player of the Year
2015: Colleen McCoy (Jr)
2018: Maddie McGee (So)
2022: Grace Scrima (Jr)
Comeback Player of the Year
2019: Julia Pozzuto (Sr)
