New York State Softball 

All-State Awards

3-Time All-State Selection

Morgan Sheehan

Class of 2005

2003 - 2004 - 2005

First Base

Kathryn Moore

Class of 2006

2004 - 2005 - 2006

Short Stop

Katie O'Flynn

Class of 2011

2009 - 2010 -2011

Pitcher

NYS HOF Inductee

Mandy McCarthy

Class of 2014

2012 - 2013 - 2014

Pitcher

Emily Turilli

Class of 2017

2015 - 2016 - 2017

Pitcher

2-Time All-State Selection

Jessica Graziano

Class of 1999

1997 & 1999

Short Stop

Pearl River HOF

Allison Vickers

Class of 2000

1999  & 2000

Pitcher

Pearl River HOF

Erika Kostik

Class of 2001

2000 & 2001

Short Stop

Melissa Tarantino

Class of 2007

2006 & 2007 

Pitcher

Jackie Bruno

Class of 2008

2007 & 2008

Short Stop

Krystina Poloni

Class of 2009

2008 & 2009

Catcher

Jamie DeGennaro

Class of 2011

2010 & 2011 

Catcher

Sam Alicandri

Class of 2014

2012 & 2014

Short Stop

Jesse McCarthy

Class of 2017

2016 & 2017

1B & OF

Julia Kinnally

Class of 2020

2018 & 2019

2B & SS

Grace Scrima

Class of 2023

2021 & 2022

Center Fielder

Kiera Luckie

Class of 2024

2021 & 2022

Pitcher

All-State Selection

Shyne Burakiewicz

Class of 1997

1997

Outfield

Gina McKeon

Class of 1999

1999

Third Base

Christine Calise

Class of 2002

2002

Pitcher

Meslissa Harris

Class of 2004

2004

Second Base

Katie Scrima

Class of 2009

2008

Pitcher

Gemma Mahoney

Class of 2011

2010

Short Stop

Erin Woods

Class of 2014

2014

Second Base

Jules Madigan

Class of 2015

2016

Center Field

Colleen McCoy

Class of 2016

2015

Third Base

Caroline Alicandri

Class of 2016

2016

Second Base

Camryn McGee

Class of 2020

2019 

Pitcher

History of Section 1 Players Named All-State (thru 2021)

John Jay East Fishkill - 29 players

Pearl River Softball - 28 players

North Rockland - 22 players