By the end of this lesson, students will be able to:
Comprehend the elements of melodic construction, including motif, contour, conjunct and disjunct motion, range, phrase, and melodic cadence.
Identify where phrases begin and end and whether the phrase ends with an open or closed melodic cadence.
Provide a motivic analysis of a melody.
Interpret the expressive qualities of melodies from different musical genres.
Compose a melody using a given pitch collection and specific melodic features (as described above).
"Melody" (Global Musix)
"Melodic Motives" (Kevin Laskey)
Optional: For another explanation of melodic features and examples see "Melody" in Music Appreciation: Melody, Harmony, Scales
What is a Motif?
(Two Minute Music Theory, 2 mins)
How to Write Music Using Motifs
(Two Minute Music Theory, 2 mins)
Motivic analysis: Watch one of the following videos to learn how to do a motivic analysis.
A Good Melody? What makes a good melody? . . . and what exactly is melody?
Talk through some of the melodies that you identified in your pre-class assignment as examples of great melodies. Listen to a few of these melodies as a class and talk about why you picked the melody you did. What is it about the melody that makes it a great melody? Can you pinpoint any specific melodic features that help support your argument?
The bossa nova jazz standard "One Note Samba" by Antônio Carlos Jobim only uses one pitch in the melody. (See the score here and a recording here.) Does a melody need more than one pitch to be a good melody? What other musical features keep the melody interesting?
Phrasing and Cadence: What is a melodic phrase? Aurally and in terms of melodic and rhythmic features, what defines where a phrase begins and ends? What makes a phrase sound complete or incomplete (or open/closed)?
In Western art music, specific features of harmony and melody are important for defining cadence. Consider what some of these features are, but also consider the other musical cues or elements your ear draws on to help define phrase boundaries and melodic groupings.
Consider examples outside of the Western art music tradition that use different types of harmonic syntax. As an example, songs like "Dreams" by Fleetwood Mac and "Tired of Waiting for You" by the Kinds only alternate between two chords, and F and G. Consider monophonic and heterophonic examples that don't use harmony, but use alternative pitch collections or rich polyphonic rhythmic textures that don't incorporate pitched melody. Listen to a few musical examples selected by the class; use your ears and discuss.
How might cultural or historical context influence our perception and interpretation of phrase boundaries in music?
Motives: What is a motif? How is it used as a compositional element? Discuss some of the different ways that motives can be varied.
Worksheets for Practice:
Melodic Pitch & Rhythm: Turek, Today's Musician Workbook, pp. 64–77.
Motivic Analysis
Sondheim, "Side by Side by Side": Complete a motivic analysis of Sondheim's melody from "Side by Side by Side" from the musical Company. Use the model for motivic analysis provided by John Peterson in the "Explore" section above. A copy of the score and the audio are included in the anthology section for this lesson. (See the link below). Start by listening the whole excerpt. Mark where you hear cadences and repetitions, then work through a motivic analysis in groups or as a class using the labels X, X', Y, etc., to describe motivic repetitions and development. When you're finished, listen to the entire example again with a focus on hearing motivic development.
Sonny Rollins, "St. Thomas" Jazz Solo: Follow the directions then answer the questions in this worksheet. Use Dr. Laskey's motive handout from the reading as a guide for your analysis. (Youtube link for the audio)
Analysis of a Blues Sentence: Listen to "Great Balls of Fire," by Jerry Lee Lewis and analyze the first page of the score in class. Discuss the elements of music that comprise the initial motive and how they change upon repetition. Which elements of the motive are present in the fragmentation?
Melodic Analysis: Select a few melodies from your Music Theory Anthology, or melodies that you brought with to class. Working in groups or as a class, listen to each melody, then complete a melodic analysis:
For each melody:
Describe the melodic motion by drawing a rough contour line.
Describe the interval structure or melodic character as conjunct or disjunct.
Identify the range of the melody, noting the interval between the highest and lowest note. Describe the range as narrow, wide, or moderate.
Bracket any rhythmic or melodic motives that are used and describe how they are varied.
Identify the type of pitch collection or scale used.
If there is more than one phrase, identify where each phrase ends. Describe the melodic cadence as open or closed.
Note any articulations, dynamics, or other expressive markings used.
Based on these characteristics, compare differences in the melodies you've analyzed.
Melodic Composition
Working in groups or individually, select one of the melodies that you analyzed in the activity above. Using the descriptions that you came up with, compose a different melody that uses the same characteristics. You may create a different melodic/rhythmic motive or vary the original motive.
Play and sing the melodies as a class. Discuss which features of the melody you like and why. Discuss any spots that don't quite sound right to you and try to pin down why you think that is. Work as a group to adjust problem spots.
Melodies for Analysis: This section of the anthology contains a compilation of melodies for melodic and motivic analysis.
Check out Aniruddh Patel's lesson on "Melody & Harmony" from his series Music and the Brain to explore cognitive relationships between music and language and ways in which melody and harmony create expectation. (Also see pp. 64–71 in the Study Guide for the lesson).
Or, explore relationships between pitch and language in sub-Saharan African music in the SMT-V video "Melodic Language & Linguistic Melodies: Text Setting in Ìgbò" by Aaron Carter-Ényì & Quintina Carter-Ényì. (See the video notes here. )
Melodic Language & Linguistic Melodies: Text Setting in Ìgbò
(Carter-Ényì & Carter-Ényì, SMT-V Vol. 6.6)