Status: Open
Specialty: Breast
Date Opened: 09/05/2017
Planned Close Date: 30/04/2028
Sponsor: University College London
Principal Investigator: Dr Eaton
Study Title:
Optimal Personalised Treatment of early breast cancer using Multiparameter Analysis
It is normal clinical practice to offer several months of adjuvant chemotherapy to patients with early breast cancer who have involved axillary lymph nodes. A recommendation for chemotherapy is incorporated into a number of guidelines. Recently however it has been argued that chemotherapy may have little effect on the subtype of breast cancer that is broadly identified as being hormonally responsive without HER2 gene amplification/HER2 protein overexpression and with a low or intermediate grade. These patients already benefit substantially from hormonal therapies and for many, the addition of chemotherapy is thought to confer no significant additional survival advantage. Conventional clinico-pathological assessment however does not reliably identify those individuals with this breast cancer subtype who can safely avoid chemotherapy. Preliminary evidence however strongly suggests that multi-parameter genomic tests are superior to conventional assessment at identifying patients who will not significantly benefit from chemotherapy despite being at risk of relapse as a result of tumour size or lymph node involvement.
The OPTIMA trial seeks to advance the development of personalised treatment of early breast cancer by the prospective evaluation of multi-parameter analysis as a means of identifying those patients who are likely to benefit from chemotherapy whilst sparing those who are unlikely to do so from an unnecessary and unpleasant treatment, and to establish the cost-effectiveness of this approach. The OPTIMA study population would ordinarily be treated with a combination of chemotherapy and endocrine therapy. The trial compares the management of patients using test-directed assignment to chemotherapy with standard management (chemotherapy) in a non-inferiority design. A preliminary phase of the study, OPTIMA prelim, was successfully completed. OPTIMA prelim demonstrated the feasibility of a large scale trial and selected the test technology to be used in the main trial.
• Female or male, age ≥ 40
• Excised invasive breast cancer with local treatment either completed or planned according to trial guidelines.
• ER positive (>10% of tumour cells stained positive) as determined by the referring site as determined by the referring site in a laboratory meeting national external quality assurance standards, and in accordance with national or ASCO-CAP guidelines.
NOTE: Where ER status is reported by Allred (or Quick) Score or by H-Score, tumours with high scores meet the ER-positive definition but the %staining component of the core is required to determine eligibility for intermediate-score tumours. Refer to the table for mapping.
Eligible Eligibility determined by Ineligible
(ER staining >10%) %staining component of the score (ER staining ≤10%)
Allred (or Quick) Score 6, 7 or 8 4 or 5 3 or less
H-Score >30 10-30 <10
• HER2 negative (IHC 0-1+, or ISH negative/non-amplified) as determined by the referring site in a laboratory meeting national external quality assurance standards, and in accordance with national or ASCO-CAP guidelines.
• Tumour size and axillary lymph node status; one of the following must apply:
i. 4-9 lymph nodes involved AND any invasive tumour size.
ii. 1-3 nodes involved, with at least 1 node containing a macrometastasis (i.e. deposit >2mm diameter) AND any invasive tumour size.
iii. 1-3 lymph nodes involved with micrometastases only (i.e. deposit >0.2-2mm diameter) AND invasive tumour size ≥ 20mm.
iv. node negative AND invasive tumour size ≥ 30mm
NOTES:
a. Lymph nodes containing isolated tumour cell clusters (ITC) only (i.e. deposit ≤0.2mm diameter) will be considered to be uninvolved.
b. Involvement of lymph nodes with macrometastases or micrometastases may be determined either by histological examination or by OSNA or equivalent PCRbased assay.
• Considered appropriate for adjuvant chemotherapy by the treating physician.
• Patient must be fit to receive chemotherapy and other trial-specified treatments with no concomitant medical, psychiatric or social problems that might interfere with informed consent, treatment compliance or follow up
• Multiple ipsilateral cancers are permitted provided at least one tumour fulfils the tumour size and axillary lymph node entry criteria, and none meet any of the exclusion criteria.
• Bilateral cancers are permitted provided the tumour(s) in one breast meets the eligibility criteria and the other, contralateral tumour is not ER negative and/or HER2 positive and not clinically significant, defined by both of the following:
i. The contralateral tumour does not fulfil the tumour size and lymph node eligibility criteria required for trial entry; i.e. the following are not acceptable:
o presence of lymph node macro-metastases;
o presence of lymph node micrometastases if the tumour size is ≥20mm;
o tumour size ≥30mm when there is no lymph node involvement.
ii. The treating physician does not consider that the characteristics of the contralateral tumour alone justify consideration of adjuvant chemotherapy.
• Short term pre-surgical treatment with endocrine therapy including in combination with noncytotoxic agents is allowed providing that the duration of treatment does not exceed 8 weeks.
• Written informed consent for the study.
• ≥10 involved axillary nodes (with either macrometastases and/ or micrometastases) or evidence for internal mammary node involvement.
• ER negative OR HER2 positive/amplified (as determined by the referring site).
• Metastatic disease.
• Previous diagnosis of malignancy unless:
i. managed by surgical treatment only and disease-free for 10 years
ii. basal cell carcinoma of skin or cervical intraepithelial neoplasia
iii. ductal carcinoma in situ (DCIS) of the breast treated with surgery only
iv. lobular carcinoma in situ (LCIS) or lobular neoplasia of the breast.
• The use of oestrogen replacement therapy (HRT) at the time of surgery. Patients who are taking HRT at the time of diagnosis are eligible provided the HRT is stopped before surgery.
• Pre-surgical chemotherapy, endocrine therapy or radiotherapy for breast cancer. Treatment with endocrine agents known to be active in breast cancer treatment including ovarian suppression is permitted provided this was completed >1 year prior to study entry.
• Commencement of adjuvant treatment prior to trial entry. Short-term endocrine therapy initiated because of, for instance, prolonged recovery from surgery is permitted but must be discontinued at trial entry.
• Trial entry more than 8 weeks after completion of breast cancer surgery.
• Planned further surgery for breast cancer, including axillary surgery, to take place after randomisation, except either re-excision or completion mastectomy for close or positive/involved margins which may be undertaken following completion of chemotherapy.
Research Nurse: Andra Fielding [andra.fielding@mbht.nhs.uk]
Administrators: research.oncology@mbht.nhs.uk
Link to EDGE