We were each tasked with designing a multiplayer educational game to teach a core concept using multiple modalities.
I wanted to come up with a game that taught a computer science concept through gameplay, but still felt like a game.
I'm fortunate to be friends with a lot of fellow computer scientist and programmers, so I spent the first week asking friends to help me come up with some potentially fun concepts. These ideas include:
Markov Chains got the most interest, but felt a bit too niche to be useful to teach 6-12th graders. Instead, I pivoted to state machines.
We came up with some more common board game features such as public and private goals with a shared shop, but most of these got removed from the finished product for being too complicated to implement in the amount of time I had.
When I would work later at night and I was by myself, I would start to "brain dump" my ideas into ChatGPT to ideate. The transcript of that multi-week chat can be found here.
ChatGPT was useful to push through when I felt stuck, as well as help me remember what I'd previously decided on. However, I don't like the designs that ChatGPT comes up with. Even designs that I'd thought I'd written out sufficiently I would find subpar and would end up making myself in Affinity Designer!
As stated above, I drafted the game pieces myself using Affinity Designer (an older version of the free Affinity Studio). I found a sufficiently sci-fi font and used Noun Project for the icons.
The game boards were made of cardstock I had on hand, but the tokens were laser cut out of acrylic! I did some testing on whether or not the writing looked better (and more importantly, more readable) if the letters were etched on the top or bottom of the acrylic. Most of the colors looked better with the etching below (which requires cutting and etching the pieces backwards), but the red acrylic ended up being too dark to see the etching from below. Lucky for me that an X is symmetrical!
In addition to the laser cutting, I also 3d printed the robot game piece! Initially I wanted to have a whole rover buggy, but it would have taken a lot of time to print out all of the parts! I'd already used blender to add eyes to the windshield (as seen in the screenshot!), and once that was printed out I decided he was already a sufficient game piece all on his own. I used some acrylic paint pens to color him in and called it done!
I could have just drawn the eyes on and skipped the 3d modeling, but it was more fun this way!
I'm proud of the final product, especially considering the amount of time I had to work on it! I spent a long time paring down my idea into something that felt enough like a game without getting too complicated to implement.
The game requires utilizing multiple modalities in order to play it.
Players have to utilize the linguistic modality to discuss their moves with each other while working together. In addition, they're introduced to relevant vocabulary such as "state", "priority", and "stack."
The spatial modality is utilized while helping the robot navigate the game board. If the robot always has to turn right, how does it reach a sample towards the left?
The gestural modality is used when the players are manipulating the game tokens. They may also point or gesture to where the robot will go after the end of the turn.
The game board requires players to use the visual modality. Players can use the current board state to figure out what's going to happen next and whether or not they can do certain actions (like move past an obstacle or pick up a sample).
The guide book as written before the final class can be seen here. I'd like to update this game system in the future, as noted below!
Because this was a summer class, there was only one in-class oportunity for game testing and feedback. Through this game testing session, we discovered the following:
The battery system is too punishing. Because battery is used after every robot action, users are not incentivised to make an efficient state machine. Some potential fixes are:
Battery is only consumed if the robot is not able to act
Replace the battery system with one that instead uses the amount of changes made to the robot before it starts moving again.
As is, the game requires too much prior knowledge in order to play. This can be helped by improving the guide book or otherwise introducing the concept better before starting the game.
In addition, I'd like to go further on the theming and design of the boardgame. Because I spent so long fabricating the tokens, the boards themselves are a little lackluster in comparison. Even just adding a background to the game board would go a long way!