Princeton/Rod

James Murray

Nicky/Trekkie Monster/Ricky (voice)

Matt Valyo

Kate

Meghan Krencicki

Lucy

Anayah Maldonado

Gary Coleman

Moriah Lightner

Christmas Eve

Angie Ruiz

Brian

Travis Weaver

Mrs. Butz

MacKenzie Foster

Bad Idea Bears

Kelsey Egan

Samantha Szumloz

Newcomer

Matthew Forman

Citizens of Avenue Q

Ava Calp

Ashley Closel

MacKenzie Foster

Matthew Forman

Vanessa Rubin