Understanding the difference between a language disorder and a language difference
by Aislinn Moore
by Aislinn Moore
Learning the difference between a language disorder and language difference is crucial, particularly in the speech pathology field. Misunderstanding the two can lead to misdiagnosing and inappropriate interventions.
What is a language disorder ❓
A language disorder is impaired comprehension and or use of spoken language in one or more of the five domains of language.
5 domains of language :
Pragmatics: How the language is used in functional and socal communication
Syntax: The rules of word order and word combinations
Morphology: The structure of words and word forms
Semantics: The rules of word meaning
Phonology : The sound system of language
Key characteristics:
Challenges with social language use
conversation initiation difficulty
Limited vocabulary
working memory
morphological inflections
A language difference is the ability to speak another language, a non mainstream dialect ( southern American, African American, English language learner).
Language difference is not a disorder!
Key characteristics:
non indicative of a deficit or disorder
influenced by bilingualism, multilanguage, regional dialect
How to address language difference :
Appropriate accurate assessment: Use interpreters or bilingual SLP's during the assessment.
Understand and support cultural norms and beliefs : It is important to understand the person's language and support their beliefs.
Educate: Educate other support personnel, caregivers, ect to recognize linguistic diversity
In conclusion , Differentiating between language disorder and language difference is essential to help prioritize cultural diversity and support others effectively to communicate.
References:
https://stream.asha.org/serving-clients-from-diverse-backgrounds-speech-language-difference-vs-disorder
Owens, R. E. (2019). Language disorders: A functional approach to assessment and intervention in children (7th ed.). Pearson.
By Hailegh Wingo
Imagine you flying through space when you crash land on a planet where the language sounds familiar, but you still can not understand. You try to start a conversation with people they avoid looking at you, they repeat what they say, or they don’t acknowledge you at all. The typical structures of communication seem to be entirely different.
For many children with ASD, this isn't what some are made to take this is their day-to-day life. It’s not that they don’t desire human connection but they understand language in a unique way. The universe they live in uses a foreign language to communicate and that doesn’t always align with how they understand different words, feelings, and interactions
Children with ASD often find difficulty with reciprocal communication, the consistent and rhythmic pattern of conversation or communication. Imagine you're outside playing ball, but instead of throwing the baseball back, the other person reroutes the ball and throws it somewhere unexpected. Having to communicate can feel just as erratic.
Some kids who have ASD might not choose or be able to respond, while the other kids who have ASD might talk for long stretches of time about subjects they love like trains or history. Taking turns while communicating is also a difficulty which results in consistent interruptions and one-sided conversations.
Echolalia: When Words Repeat
A common pattern to emerge from kids who have been diagnosed with ASD is echolalia. This is when a student repeats words or phrases that they have been exposed to. This can be instantaneous or can occur sometime after the initial exposure. While it may seem random, echolalia often is used as a tool for processing language, learning sentence structure, or expressing emotions.
Children with ASD frequently interpret language literally, struggling with figurative language. Phrases like raining cats and dogs can be confusing. Their meaning is not as obvious. This struggle to comprehend figurative language can cause misunderstandings in communications
Bridging the Gap
With the right resources, support, and therapy kids who have ASD can show remarkable improvement in their ability to have conversations and socialize with others. Doing speech therapy, and using techniques like visual aids and structured scripts help them get through conversations. Most importantly caregivers, educators, and parents need to show a good bit of patience and understanding to be able to make a safe space thee children can feel comfortable expressing themselves.
The main point for humans' language ability is about connection. Children with ASD might communicate in a unique way, but their voices are important.
Owens, R. E. (2024). Language Disorders: A Functional Approach to Assessment and Intervention in Children. Plural Publishing.
Bauman-Waengler, J. A. (2020). Articulation and phonology in speech sound disorders: A clinical focus. Pearson Education, Inc.