In America, celebrities are everywhere. They're on magazine covers on shelves at the grocery store, they're dancing on your For You Page on TikTok, they're sharing their thoughts on Twitter, and they're on your TV screen. The only reasons that celebrities are as famous as they are is because of two things: money and dedicated fans, with talent being more of an afterthought. Some celebrities even got their start with little to no money, with modern day rags-to-riches stories; popular examples include Nirvana's Kurt Cobain and Oprah Winfrey. Without fans, most celebrities would have never become as famous as they did.
Why and how do celebrities become famous, and how does celebrity worship come to fruition? Sociologist Paul Hollander relates this to American society and how celebrity worship is seemingly engrained into the culture here in the U.S. Hollander describes the culture of celebrity worship in America by highlighting how many people try their best to simply meet celebrities by going to places that they frequently visit. People engage in “celebrity-watching” as a pastime activity, perhaps to add excitement to their lives or to elevate their social status, Hollander notes. He also states that in order to become famous, you don’t necessarily have to be talented artistically – you just have to be noticeable and physically attractive, and having money and connections helps. You also don’t have to be heroic or even morally sound; as long as you can generate publicity, you can become famous.³
People who are interested in celebrities are often that way because they want to see how the other half lives – those with glamorous lives and plenty of wealth are intriguing. Social media has brought celebrity worship to new heights; celebrities having public Twitter, Instagram, TikTok, and Facebook accounts allows fans to interact with them in completely new ways. No longer do people have to mail letters to a P.O. Box address to tell their favorite celebrity how much they mean to them - they can simply reply to their latest social media post. People can even connect with other fans living all over the world, forming communities and building friendships all on the basis of sharing a favorite celebrity/celebrities. However, these types of connections can lead to consequences.
People may deny their impact, but it's undeniable: stans get things trending. Every day on Twitter, you can go to the top trends in America or other countries and there is always at least one celebrity-related topic in the top five. Sometimes very random-seeming phrases or words trend, and when you click on the hashtag you'll usually see passionate fans explaining the context behind the trend. A prime example of this happened in 2016, which was an incident where angry EXO fans trended a hashtag that implied Miley Cyrus had died, when she was still very much alive. According to The Guardian journalist Michael Cragg, this started because Beliebers (Justin Bieber’s fanbase) and EXO-Ls (EXO’s fanbase) were arguing over who is more famous – the aforementioned American singer or the Korean boy band. A Miley Cyrus fan got involved and said rude things about K-pop fans, so the arguments went from there, leading to the hashtag’s creation.⁴ As mentioned earlier, fans of celebrities nowadays have constant access to said celebrities due to social media, and that the lines and power dynamics between stars and fans have been blurred because of this. Beliebers even trended a hashtag in anger over Bieber deactivating his Instagram account - a personal choice that non-celebrities all over the world make every day. Fans crossing the line with celebrities is unfortunately all too commonplace. But even more common is fans crossing the line with each other.
The #RIPMileyCyrus incident is part of a larger culture of fandom behavior, where fans of a particular artist band together to defend the artist by fighting with other fanbases. Stans tend to label celebrities as problematic and compare them to their own favorite celebrities, to show how “good” they are by comparison. These stans may not even actually care about the issue at hand; they may just hop into the drama for fun. A lot of fans also try to protect their favorite celebrity if said celebrity does something wrong, illegal, or racist/homophobic. These fans see any criticism from fans and non-fans alike as hate speech/attacking, and in turn they defend their celebrity and attack those who are calling them out. However, there are fans who are disappointed whenever their favorite celebrity does something wrong, and they may even “unstan.”⁵ These are often the two sides in fanwars - the side that defends the artist and the side that opposes the artist and their fans.
Lucas' Instagram post, February 9th, 2022
NCT is a 23-member K-pop boy group that debuted in 2016. The group is divided into four subunits, with a fifth on the way. Considering the size of the group, they rarely perform as 23, only having 3 releases with all the members. NCT fans are called NCTzens (pronounced “N-citizens”), with supporters of all 23 members called “ot23zens.”
The issue comes from a Chinese member of the group, Wong Yukhei, otherwise known as Lucas. According to four different women – one Korean, three Chinese – Lucas sexually assaulted, stole from, and cheated on his former girlfriends/partners. Following these allegations, Lucas posted an apology letter and went on hiatus on August 25th, 2021. Fans on Twitter were outraged at the allegations, with many people unstanning him and uplifting the victims’ voices. Others, however, defended the idol and looked for any signs that the victims were liars trying to get money, favors, and clout. Lucas was left out of all NCT-related and solo activities from that day on.
On February 9th, 2022, Lucas posted a black and white picture of the ocean on his Instagram page. This was his first post since he went on hiatus. Naturally, many fans who had supported him throughout the allegations were very excited. Many others, however, were not. #WelcomeBackLucas and #WeLoveYouLucas quickly started to trend on Twitter, with fans making gifs, edits, and fanart to show their support. Others were angry at how these fans were okay with Lucas posting again, knowing that there were women out there that Lucas had abused in a multitude of ways. These users, many of whom used to be fans of Lucas, objected to this post, and began to make threads calling Lucas’ fans out. “ot23zens” took offense to this and told “ot22zens” to respect their views on the matter. These fans also kept saying that the allegations were fake and that there was “no proof,” despite all four women having provided substantial evidence of what Lucas did.
3. Hollander, Paul. “Why the Celebrity Cult?” Society, vol. 47, no. 5, 2010, pp. 388–91. Crossref, doi:10.1007/s12115-010-9348-9.
4. Cragg, Michael. “#RIPMileyCyrus and the Rise of Online Fan Wars.” The Guardian, 18 Aug. 2016, www.theguardian.com/media/2016/aug/18/hashtags-hatred-ripmileycyrus-rise-online-fan-wars.
5. Oliver, David. “‘Stan’ Culture Needs to Stop – or at Least Radically Change. Here’s Why.” USA TODAY, 9 Sept. 2021, eu.usatoday.com/story/life/2021/09/07/stan-culture-fans-need-reconsider-how-they-worship-celebrities/5666108001.