It does exist! Even with all of the Nazi's attempts to limit and crush opposition to their power. However, the Nazis were extremely brutal in dealing with opposition and their punishments.
The nature and form of opposition to the Nazis is hard to gauge, due to the use of terror, threat of violence, concentration camps, informants and security apparatus in the Gestapo.
Also what constitutes opposition? Is it anti-Nazi jokes, plots to assassinate Hitler, or just not listening to Hitler's speech?
Here is where we learn about the people who dared to fight back, who were willing to die for their cause.
PRE-1933, a significant number of Germans did not support Nazism (July 1932: 37.4% vote)
POST-1933, there was very little organised opposition to the Nazi regime due to the rise of acceptance of Nazi rule (despite whether it was sympathetic or supportive).
TYPES OF OPPOSITION:
institutional: from institutions, e.g. political parties and trade unions
personal: individuals/smaller groups
OPPOSITION MANIFESTED IN:
Private and public acts of defiance
General discontent over small matters
Active resistance:
Political activism
Attempted coups
Assassination attempts: 1933-44: at least 12
VERY LITTLE POSED A SERIOUS THREAT TO HITLER'S POWER:
Fuhrer Myth protected Hitler's power
The regimes methods of control were effective:
Goebbels + propaganda
Himmler + terror / repression
Gestapo / denunciation
risked the lives of family/friends
Opposition groups had different visions of a post-Hitler Germany and therefore did not work together
The political left were the Social Democrats (SPD), Communists (KPD), and the Trade Unions, who were ideologically opposed to the Nazis.
Left-wing opposition in Germany was severely impeded in the first weeks after the Nazi takeover. SPD, KPD and union leaders were arrested and imprisoned in concentration camps; buildings and funds belonging to the parties and unions were seized, and the parties and unions themselves were prohibited.
As a result, all opposition that followed took the form of underground resistance, and its effectiveness was limited.
Their Actions:
Engaging in poster and pamphlet campaigns
Encouraging acts of sabotage
Absenteeism in factories
Some members of the military were frustrated and concerned with the aggressiveness of Hitler’s foreign policy. They encouraged discussions about the removal of Hitler from power, which occasionally amounted to plots.
Their Actions:
There were several unsuccessful plots to remove Hitler during the 1930s, either in the form of a military-led Putsch or through assassination.
An important opponent of Hitler was Ludwig Beck, who was the Chief of Staff of the German Army between 1935 and 1938.
– Beck believed that Hitler could be overthrown if a confrontation were forced between the Nazi Party and the military. Accordingly, in 1938 he attempted to persuade his fellow generals to ignore Hitler’s orders to invade Austria.
– Beck was unsuccessful and resigned from the army shortly after this, but he continued to lead the military conspiracy against Hitler until the failed Operation Valkyrie in 1944.
Unfortunately, the churches in Germany were not united in their attitudes to the Nazis, due partly to the Concordat signed by the Catholic church and the division of Protestant churches.
Opposition to Euthanasia:
The Nazi Euthanasia programme for the ‘unfit’ began in 1939 and led to the murder of 75 000 victims.
The Cardinal Archbishop of Munster gave a powerful sermon against it in 1941, resulting in widespread public opposition.
The Archbishop notified the civil police and the protest that developed as a result of the sermon brought an end to the programme.
German workers organised resistance campaigns that were based on the economic interests of the working class. There were examples of workers exercising collective pressure on Nazi organisations and employers to improve working conditions.
Workers suffered from rising food prices and participated in various acts of defiance against workplace rules and government decrees, such as: - -
Absenteeism
Strikes and demonstrations
Slow-downs in production
The sabotaging of factory machinery.
Organisers were arrested and imprisoned in concentration camps.
Such behaviour posed a significant challenge for Nazism; however, it was not a principled challenge against the Nazi regime.
A number of youth movements developed in Germany that rejected conformity, opposed the totalitarian state and engaged in protest against Nazism.
The Edelweiss Pirates:
One of the best-known of these groups was the Edelweisspiraten (‘Edelweiss Pirates’).
The Pirates, who were working class in origin, consisted of youth in the 14-18-year-old age group.
They were opposed to Nazism, and their resistance ranged from refusing to join in mainstream activities to beating up bands of Hitler Youth.
They rejected the principles of Nazi social and cultural policy and evaded the requirements that young men serve the Reich Labour Service and the army.
The ‘Swing‘ Movement:
A different subculture developed among middle-class youths in the form of the ‘swing’ movement.
Jazz and swing music were regarded as degenerate by the Nazis, which inspired a form of protest against the regime.
During the twelve years of the Third Reich, there was very little organised opposition to the regime either by individuals or groups, and almost none of it was successful. Gleichschaltung proved to be a highly successful period for the Nazi Party through the use of terror and conservative support which made opposition difficult.
Nonetheless, there were examples of resistance, Nazi criticism and dissent between 1933 and 1939.
Reasons for the failure of opposition against the Nazi Party:
The impact of propaganda and the popularity of Hitler
Fear and terror in Nazi Germany
The increasing control over the lives of everyday people
No mass organisations to coordinate opposition
Research a resistance group and present your findings as a PPT in class.
Here are some starters, but you don't have to do these ones if you find something more interesting to you.
The Swing Movement
Edelweiss Pirates
Operation Valkyrie
Georg Elser