The outrage brought up due to the inclusion of Tulane and James Madison in the CFP is overblown, and downright humiliating for the sport as a whole. I believe that these teams deserve to be in the playoffs, much to the chagrin of others. Do I think they will win? No. But, I believe they earned their spot here just as much of the other competitors. Why? I have 3 main reasons, which will indeed convince you why Tulane and JMU earned their spot in the playoffs.
Reason 1: Sorry Your Team Didn’t Do Well Enough
In this age, it is easier to make the playoffs and compete for a national title than ever. The problem with the system is that ESPN, the SEC, and media personalities (Paul Finebaum) wholeheartedly believe that a 3-loss SEC team "deserves" to be in the playoffs. “It Just Means More” I guess. More what? Losses to a terrible Florida team? Of course you don’t get to be in the playoffs after that, it’s on you. The problem is that the logo means more than the team itself. Everyone looks at TCU getting crushed by Georgia in the National Championship and sighs without realizing that TCU beat another big brand in Michigan right before. If Michigan had the same result against Georgia we wouldn’t be having the same conversation now.
This brings me back to the main point, which is the fact that the expanded playoffs makes higher-than-average teams think they deserve a spot. The ability to compete for the national championship is reserved for great teams, with great seasons; not great programs, with average seasons. Sorry your team didn’t make it, better luck next year.
Reason 2: What Else Are They Supposed To Play For?
So what these “lowly” teams don’t have as big a fan base as you. All of these Group of Five schools have just as passionate fans as you who deserve a chance to play for something. Before a chance to compete for the playoffs, they had to compete for the coveted BCS Bowls against the top dogs of the sport. It means just as much to them as to you that they get a shot to achieve their goals.
One could even argue that it’s harder to make the playoffs from their position. They have to compete against over 50 other teams just to get one, maybe two, spots in the playoffs. This takes a near miracle season on all fronts and a season talked about for years to come by their fans. And, get this, they actually won their conference, something a lot of you other teams can’t seem to do.
Reason 3: Just Say You Don’t Like Fun
In literally every other sport, we root for the underdogs to succeed and go on magical Cinderella runs, but in football? “They just don’t deserve to be there.” How about you just come out and say you’re not fun at parties. What’s the point in all of this if we just bash these teams for merely existing, and why do we just treat it like an automatic bye for the teams that play them. I’ll be the first one to say that these teams don’t have the talent of the big schools, but that doesn’t mean they can’t win. All of the power 4 teams got smacked in the first round last year, while the “lowly” Boise State put up a better fight than all the others. Don’t think the GO5 can win? Check the history.
2022 Cotton Bowl: Tulane beats USC 46-45
2017 Peach Bowl: UCF beats Auburn 34-27
2015 Peach Bowl: Houston beats Florida State 38-24
2014 Fiesta Bowl: Boise State beats Arizona 38-30
2013 Sugar Bowl: Louisville beats Florida 33-23
The notion that they have “no chance” of winning is false, and downright crazy. I’ll be the first one to say that I can see JMU putting up a good fight against Oregon. I was at the Louisville vs JMU game, and I can confidently say that James Madison had a similar, if not better O-Line and D-Line than Louisville. They won in the trenches the whole game, and Louisville only won due to having the 2 best players on the field. If you don’t think they have a shot, why play the game at all?
That concludes my scathing rant about how Tulane and JMU deserve to be in the playoffs. Are you sad about it? You’re allowed to be, but don’t let it get in the way of seeing how there are still going to be two good teams playing in both of those games. Good luck Tulane and JMU, prove the haters wrong.