The following selections are from the approved college textbook The Bedford Reader. I did not require you to buy this book. Instead, to save you money, I have embedded the articles from the book that are Open Resource, meaning you do not have to pay to read this content. Should you choose to read from the textbook, you may purchase a copy HERE.
1) What are the different types of argument?
2) When are they used?
3) How are they different?
Difference between argumentative and persuasive graphic organizer
Reading #2 Questions
1). Where does Chavez reveal her PURPOSE in writing? Why do you suppose she chose not to state her THESIS in the introduction?
2) What kind of argument is this?
3) On what ASSUMPTION does Chavez base her argument? Is that assumption reasonable?
4) As a whole, is Chavez's essay an appeal to emotion or a reasoned argument, or both? Give EVIDENCE to support your answer.
https://www.eng121.net/online%20textbook/argumentation/Supporting%20Family%20Values.pdf
Readings 3 & 4
"How the Death Penalty Saves Lives" by David B. Muhlhusen
1) What two main reasons does Muhlhausen's offer to persuade readers to support capital punishment? Do you find these reasons persuasive? Why or why not?
2) In which sentence does Muhlhausen state his THESIS most directly?
3) What does Muhlhausen accomplish by opening with a discussion of Earl Ringo, Jr., and the crime he was executed for?
4) Where, if at all, does Muhlhausen address opposing points of view? How effective do you find his counterarguments?
"What I Learned from Executing Two Men" by Semon Frank Thompson
1) What reasons does Thompson give for opposing capital punishment? What does he offer as EVIDENCE for his claims?
2) Who is Emmett Till? Who are John Tillman Hussey and Louis Perry Bryant? What does Thompson achieve by remarking on their deaths in his opening paragraphs?
3) Is this essay an appeal to emotion, a reasoned argument, or both? Give evidence for your answer.
4) Do you think the author expects his AUDIENCE to agree with him? At what points does he seem to recognize that some readers may see things differently?
Required Reading:
Introduction to Unit
https://www.sausd.us/cms/lib5/CA01000471/Centricity/ModuleInstance/7906/Bedford_Chapter_13.pdf
Linda Chavez: "Supporting Family Values" https://www.eng121.net/online%20textbook/argumentation/Supporting%20Family%20Values.pdf
https://www.sausd.us/cms/lib5/CA01000471/Centricity/ModuleInstance/7906/Bedford_Chapter_13.pdf
David B. Mulhausen: "How the Death Penalty Saves Lives" https://colburnjusticeleague.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/10/how-the-death-penalty-saves-lives.pdf
Semon Frank Thompson: "What I Learned From Executing Two Men" https://www.madpmo.org/post/what-i-learned-from-executing-two-men
https://www.madpmo.org/post/what-i-learned-from-executing-two-men
Current Event: Texas Postpones Execution-What Do You Think?
WRITING A POSITION PAPER