In this project, I have been asked to develop my own mobile game that uses similar game mechanics and movements to Flappy Bird or Subway Surfers. My mobile app game must be themed around a film or TV show of my choice, although the theme choice must fit the mechanics of Flappy Bird or Subway Surfers.
We were asked to playtest the following games: Flappy Bird, Subway Surfers, Temple Run 3 and The Helicopter Game, to gather the pros and cons to the games mechanics and playability, so we can gather the best mechanics to use in my own mobile game.
Here is my analysis of the pros and cons to those games:
Playtest: https://flappybird.io/
Pros -
I really like the art style of the game and the mechanics.
The idea of a score counter is a really good idea because it allows replay ability, because you will want to play again to beat your previous high score.
Cons -
The static background really confuses me as the bird is not actually moving, it is the pipes that are moving towards the bird.
When you slow down the bird nose dives, although this is realistic, it is more than likely that you will hit the pipe as you are going through.
The bird feels sluggish, slow and really clunky, which spoils the playability of the game.
The game, in my opinion, is hard because of the fast moving pipes and the slow bird.
The is very repetitive and predictable, destroying the replay ability
Playtest: https://poki.com/en/g/subway-surfers
Pros -
I really like the movement of the character and the mechanic idea that you are running away from an angry security officer.
In addition, I really enjoy the score counter again as it allows for replayability, as well as the coins that can be used to upgrade stats and unlock new cosmetics. This is a good idea as it allows the player to feel a sense of accomplishment.
The boosts and power ups are a good idea because it allows the character to perform different bonus actions.
Cons -
I get a sense of rage and addiction when playing this game, it can be seen as a pro and a con as people will continue playing your game.
The game puts you into unwinable situations, where you are locked between trains with no escape.
Playtest: https://templerun3.co/
Pros -
I really like the take on a Subway Surfers style game that involves running away from a mythical beast and dodging obstacles.
This game is really similar to Subway Surfers as it involves the same mechanics, so it is really easy for the user to pick up the game and play.
There is an element of replayability as you feel like you want to beat your highscore.
Cons-
The UI feels cluttered, as the player is overwhelmed with information that may or may not be helpful to them.
The character feels clunky and unresponsive as the character jumps and then immediately returns back to the ground.
There is also an input delay as when you turn it doesn't turn immediately after pressing the arrow keys.
Playtest: https://www.addictinggames.com/clicker/helicopter-game
Pros -
This game is simple and easy to understand as the mechanics are similar to the mechanics of Flappy Bird.
The replayability is there, yet again with the score counter.
Cons -
The controls seem to be sensitive as when you click the helicopter immediately begins to ascend.
The art style is confusing as the blocks are of low quality, but the helicopter seems to be of a higher quality and detail.
The game is too easy for me, as it only involves going up and down using the left click of the mouse.
In this section of the research phase of this project, I analysed six mobile games that use similar mechanics to Flappy Bird or Subway Surfers. Each game is analysed into different categories and sub-categories, such as Visual, Interactivity and Audio. This task helps me to gather different visual, audio and interactive styles that I can use in my own mobile app game.
Game 1: Crossy Road 2014 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=13u9v890X98
https://toucharcade.com/2014/11/21/crossy-road-review/
Visual:
Crossy Road, in my opinion, is a great simplistic endless runner that I can not put down after setting a high score, “This is already the kind of game where I’m going back and forth with people for high scores, and sharing my high scores to Twitter”. The array of characters and collectable coins available allow the player to continue playing, to complete every character collection.
Character, Environment, Perspective and Colour Palette -
I really enjoy the 3D and environment design that really creates an immersive experience due to the ‘over the shoulder’ perspective. The bright colour palette that flows between the UI and the game itself, invites the player in and creates a happy, enjoyable sensation that will make the player want to pick up the game more often.
Sound:
Mood and Sound effects -
Crossy Road has minimal sound effects and no overall soundtrack, so the mood of the game is up to the interpretation of the player. The sound effects that are in the game are parallel to the events in game, so when the player picks up a coin a happy upbeat effect is played letting the player know they have carried out a good action. This is very helpful so I will make sure to include a range of sound effects in my game.
Interactivity:
Controls -
Crossy Road uses simple and easy to pick up and play controls, so a range of players can simply play the game as intended. Recognisable controls are a must for a mobile game, because if your controls are complicated then players will get fed up and stop playing. So I will include a simple control set in my game.
Game 2: Jetpack Joyride 2011 - https://poki.com/en/g/jetpack-joyride
Visual:
Character, Environment and Colour Palette -
The character and environment design in Jetpack Joyride feels bland and lacking in variation, the environments repeat themselves after a while and the obstacles which the player has to avoid are predictable and yet again lacking in variation. This creates a boring atmosphere for the player as the designs are lacking in colour and creativity. When planning for my game I need to ensure that the designs are not too boring and the game does not become predictable over time. The colour Palette in the game is very dull, this creates a sense of sadness and lack of emotion as the majority of the colours are black, grey and white.
Perspective -
The endless runner uses a side-facing perspective, just like Flappy Bird, which allows the player to see every obstacle that the player will encounter next. The 2D assets are used in a way that it looks almost 3D and the assets pop off of the screen at the player, this creates a sense of immersion for the player.
Sounds:
Mood and Soundtrack -
Jetpack Joyride uses a cheery soundtrack that completely contrasts to the aim of the game, which is to fly through a lab avoiding lasers and missiles whilst shooting lab workers as the player moves or interacts with the mouse. The mood created from the soundtrack is a happy and upbeat one which will allow the player to continue to play.
Interactivity:
Controls -
The controls are simple to understand and interact with, anybody who has a basic understanding of a game will be able to move the character along the never ending screen, these simple controls that are seen in many mobile games allow for replayability.
Game 3: Doodle Jump 2009 - https://doodlegames.io/doodle-jump
https://www.ign.com/games/doodle-jump/user-reviews
Visual:
Character and Environment -
The character and environmental design of the endless runner game is simplistic and aesthetically pleasing on the eye. Every asset in the game looks as if it was drawn on a notebook complementing the title of Doodle Jump. The creator of the game has thought about every detail of the movement and designs of the characters, this is seen in the amount of detail in each asset. This in turn attracts more players to the game as it functions and responds to inputs with zero lag or delay and the designs are well rounded and finished with perfection. When designing my own character and environment I need to think about the amount of detail that I am to include in the design, as this can either make or break my game.
Perspective -
Doodle Jump uses a 2D front facing perspective that is common amongst classic platformers and more evidently like Flappy Bird.
Sounds:
Mood -
The game has minimal sound effects, but the sound effects that are present in the game provoke a mood of happiness because of the satisfying beeps and pops as the character navigates up the endless screen of obstacles and platforms. In addition to this, no soundtrack is present in the game so any other feelings or moods are up to the player's interpretations.
Interactivity:
Controls and playset -
This popular 2009 mobile game has simplistic directional controls, “it's a simple, fun, and addictive arcade game that you can enjoy offline.”, which contributes to its easy replayability and accessibility for players. As well as this, the inclusion of a high score system like most of the games I have analysed, allows the player to continue mastering their top score to further better their in game experience. The controls are very easy to understand, all the player has to do is use the directional arrows to move the character and shoot enemies. Easy controls are a good way to attract an audience of players, so I will make sure to include familiar controls in my game to encourage as many players as possible to play it and to continue playing it.
Game 4: Subway Surfers 2012 - https://poki.com/en/g/subway-surfers
Interactivity:
Play Set -
Subway Surfers is one of the most downloaded mobile games currently on the app store, “Over ten years in the making, we’re beyond proud of our team at Sybo for hitting this milestone of 4 billion downloads” (GamesBeat, 2023). This success is mostly due to the unique visuals, sound and replayability mechanics that come in force with this highly addictive game. The high score tally system and unique cosmetics and upgrade items that are available through the collection of glistening gold coins, allows the continuing replayability amongst the audience. This score system encourages gamers to spend a longer time mastering the game, by trying to beat their highscores and beating the highscores of their friends. I believe that the developers at Sybo utilised this high score tally system to lengthen the time in which the user spent mastering the endless levels on Subway Surfers. This game mechanic encourages the achiever gamer type to continue playing the game, to feel a sense of accomplishment from beating their previous high score.
Controls -
The controls are very simple and easy to understand, this easy control set allows users to pick up the game and immediately begin to play. This is very important as it allows any gamer of any ability to play the game, and allows them to continue playing the game. Also, the controls are very responsive and snappy which is a good feature because the user will not get frustrated when interacting with the game.
Visual and Sound:
Colour Palette, Mood and Soundtrack/Sounds -
Another factor that could have resulted in the major success of this game is the unique visual and sound design that evokes a sense of happiness and enjoyment amongst the user. The soundtrack that is played throughout the entirety of the users journey through the game brings happiness due to the upbeat instruments and tempo, this encourages the gamer to continue playing the game as they feel less stressed and more focused on setting a newer high score. Furthermore, the unique UI design and colour palette evokes a hip-hop, joyous and happy atmosphere as the colours are very bright and vibrant, this encourages the user to continue playing as the bright colours allow them to feel happy. The use of different sound effects when playing and interacting with different power ups or abilities, allows the user to understand each powerup and collectable. For example a clinking sound is heard when collecting a coin, this lets the player know they have
Character -
The character can be customised and adjusted to the preference of the user, this allows the user to feel a sense of uniqueness as the playable character can suit the style of the gamer.
This can allow for replayability which is a very important factor when designing a game.
Environment -
The environment is very well designed and is packed with a lot of detail, every asset fits within the style of the game and better yet the location of the environment changes every in game season. This changes the entire look and feel of the game as assets are designed to fit in with a different setting, this allows for user replayability as users will want to try out the new settings and unique rewards.
Game 5: Minion Rush - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UkVoNvYdKBs
Visual:
Character, Environment and Colour Palette -
Minion Rush has been developed with consideration to the classic and easily recognisable characters of Despicable Me, this use of the recognisable character design has led to the game having over 500 Million downloads on the Google Play store alone. The Minions have a distinctive yellow coloured body, this use of bright colour creates a happy and joyous atmosphere which will encourage the player to continue playing because they feel cheerful due to the vividness of the environments and characters.
Interactivity:
Controls and Perspective -
Just like Subway Surfers, Minion Rush adopts a back view of the playable character as they navigate past themed obstacles and collect bananas that can be used to unlock cosmetic items. The use of a familiar game style and controls allows for an easy playable experience that can be enjoyed time and time again.
Sounds:
Mood and Sounds -
Minion Rush uses an upbeat soundtrack that fits perfectly with the mischievousness of Minions, this soundtrack can create a fun and enjoyable experience for the player as they can enjoy the recognisable sounds that can be heard in the Despicable Me movies, as they battle their way through the endless movie based environments. Various sound effects can also be heard when interacting with collectables and boosts, this lets the player know they have carried out a good action, this will make the player feel rewarded and create a sense of accomplishment as they have picked up another banana or boost that will change the overall feel of their run.
Game 6: Geometry Dash - https://geometrydash.io/
Visual:
Character and Colour Palette -
The playable character in Geometry Dash as well as the endless environments in the levels are all made up of blocks, which fits perfectly with the theme of Geometry because it is all about angles and timing to the jumps that the character must perform. The character can also be customised to the players preference, this allows for self expression which would attract an array of different players because of the sense of expression and customisation. The colour palette changes in every level so the mood of the player can change throughout each level in the game, so no consistent mood will follow the player throughout their playthrough.
Perspective -
Geometry Dash uses a side-facing perspective that is common amongst games of this genre, and this perspective allows the player to become the character as they jump and dodge the various obstacles that lay in their path.
Sounds:
Mood and Soundtrack -
The soundtrack changes with each level and speeds up the further the player moves, this creates a tense mood and feeling as you begin panicking as you try to time your jumps perfectly. This aspect of the game and the use of a progress bar allows for replayability because the player will feel good with themself after they beat the many levels in Geometry Dash. When the character dies a death sound is made to let the player know that they have hit an object and the game will now reset and start from the beginning.
Interactivity:
Controls -
The controls to this game are as simple as possible, all the player has to do is touch the screen or space bar to make the playable character jump and avoid the many spikes that can be seen in each level. These controls may have been one of the factors for the popularity of this game, as almost any player of any ability can instantly pick up the game and play.